Alan L. Olmstead and Paul W. Rhode offer a magisterial account of the advent of effective federal efforts to control the spread of animal diseases in America from the post-Civil War period to the present. Arresting Contagion connects them to scientific, legal, and policy developments and the changing political economy. The authors use a multidisciplinary approach, smoothly combining historical and economic analysis to make a compelling case that increased governmental activism efficiently stymied a plethora of devastating diseases, avoiding a high toll in animal and human lives, as well as substantial financial costs. By centering on agriculture, they successfully challenge the standard history of the rise of federal regulation and oversight in trade and health. Animal diseases were a global problem, and the authors rightly touch on transnational developments by comparing national programs and their outcomes. They suggest that the United States assumed an active role in this sector before other nations generally considered to be more centralized and interventionist.
After the Civil War, the livestock business and its national and global markets expanded dramatically with improvements in long-distance transportation and meat processing. The problem of disease transmission became more critical with the mass movement of animals and with breed specialization, which by increasing the value of individual animals upped the costs of contagion. While private, local, and state efforts were not enough to quash transmission, prevailing interpretations of the Constitution for a time blocked federal regulatory power. That began to change when, in 1884, Congress created the Bureau of Animal Industry (BAI) within the U.S. Department of Agriculture to regulate the livestock industry and arrest the spread of contagious diseases. The BAI was a new type of agency that combined research and oversight functions. It made impressive advances in virology, bacteriology, and immunology, and pioneered the application of science to public policy. The agency established de novo an intricate regulatory network that stretched from the local to national level; it depended on buy-in from farmers and business and effective inspection and monitoring operations—no small feat. The BAI's success can be partially attributed to its placement within the agricultural bureaucracy, whose growth, funding, and capabilities far outpaced other federal institutions well into the twentieth century.
The authors draw out the connections between agricultural scientists and medical and public health specialists; they shared knowledge across urban–rural sectors and national borders. While the agricultural, biological, and veterinary sciences were specializing and professionalizing in the early twentieth century, knowledge boundaries were permeable; key etiological discoveries advanced understandings of both animal and human health. Still, the BAI's search for preventatives and cures was less immediately successful than its research resulting in accurate diagnostic tests. The BAI implemented a series of innovations, including mandatory cull and kill measures, even when lacking a silver bullet. Its panoply of programs ultimately reduced the spread and incidence of several diseases.
Addressing single diseases in individual chapters, the authors analyze the related advances in science, the programmatic approaches specific to each disease, and the shifting balance of power among farmers, legislators, scientists, and bureaucrats that opened the door to increased governmental intervention. For example, large meat packing companies first opposed and then promoted regulation, accepting it for financial and health reasons. These developments interlocked with a series of landmark legal, legislative, and policy changes, many of which occurred in the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries. The author's holistic approach adds new perspective to animal diseases that have seen some previous historical study, such as Texas Fever and Hog Cholera, and on underexamined ones, including Bovine Tuberculosis, Trichinosis, and Foot-and-Mouth Disease. Some livestock diseases can spread to humans, and the success in controlling them had profound epidemiological ramifications. The turn-of-the-century discovery that the bovine form of tuberculosis infected humans through the consumption of meat and milk led to a sustained eradication campaign that all but eliminated such risk by the 1940s.
The authors specifically engage two competing assessments of regulation: public choice theory, described as critical of big government and federal interventions for their inefficiencies; and the public interest school, which welcomes regulation as a means to address market imperfections and business abuses. The book offers an intermediate interpretation, showing how a close examination over time of markets, costs and benefits, and group actions generate historically specific conclusions rather than generalizations. This analysis also leads them to reject the narrative that “rent-seeking” bureaucrats, politicians, and special interests increasingly sought regulation simply to protect their own interests. They offer a more complex interpretation: interventions aimed at controlling disease led to a common good in the form of reduced public costs and fewer lives lost. The authors support their claims with counterfactual analysis, demonstrating that this approach can add dividends to the strictly historical approach. Appendices contain detailed explanations of their methods for each scenario.
The authors challenge the standard account of the evolution of federalism in the United States. The BAI predates the Interstate Commerce Commission, commonly depicted as the starting point for federal economic regulation and big government. The book thus joins a spate of recent works spotlighting agriculture's role in spurring the rise of the modern activist state.Footnote 1 “Coercive federalism” dawned in the 1880s, the authors conclude, and not the 1960s (89). Indeed, as early as 1900, the United States became a world leader in controlling livestock disease, although it was a “laggard” in human medicine and the biological sciences (5). In tracing transformative institutional change and early public health improvements to the agricultural realm, the book moves the focus away from the urban industrial world, which tends to dominate the histories of these subjects, particularly for the Gilded Age and Progressive Era.
This significant book sets a new standard for the twined history of health, economic development, and the state. A minor complaint is that dividing the accounts of single diseases into multiple nonsequential chapters compromises the continuity of storylines. I also wished for more analysis of the implications that the new systems of “surveillance” had for individuals and governance (137). That said, the book is a must-read for those interested in environmental, agricultural, and veterinary history, public health history, and economic development. Historians of science and medicine will benefit. Scholars in the field of American political development and others seeking to bring together the study of institutions, history, and political science will also find it useful, as will public policy experts. The findings are pertinent to current discussion of the role of government and its efficiencies (or lack thereof). Offering keen insight; a deep historiographic base; and profound, expansive arguments, this is a book I will return to often.
