The American musical form has, in many of its notable and lasting creations, dramatized the concepts of race and racial identity. There is, I feel, something about a narrative story combined with music that allows composers and lyricists to engage with such social constructions in subtle, coded, and sometimes contradictory ways. Show Boat and Porgy and Bess are two works central to the history of the musical's engagement with questions of race. Much connects the stories—one a multigenerational tale of performers upon a Mississippi show barge, the other about life among the black lower class in Charleston, South Carolina; most important for historians, both have had common trajectories over time through various media, in ways that alter their meanings as they circulate as cultural objects. Both Show Boat and Porgy and Bess began as books that were adapted into musical forms, which were adapted into films, and which subsequently underwent critical revivals. Both the musical Show Boat and the opera Porgy and Bess were enthusiastically reviewed and sharply criticized in their original versions; they were later vilified and deemed outdated due to racial stereotyping; ultimately, they both secured comfortable places in the musical theatre canon. Additionally—although both include African American characters and black cultural expressions—from their inceptions as novels and through their various staged and filmed versions, they are the creations of white novelists, lyricists, composers, and directors. Todd Decker's “Show Boat”: Performing Race in an American Musical and Ellen Noonan's The Strange Career of “Porgy and Bess”: Race, Culture, and America's Most Famous Opera trace these strikingly similar paths. Although each volume boasts numerous strengths as it creates a detailed portrait of its respective story across various media, both books tend to fall short in their theoretical engagements with the performativity of race.
The two histories have several themes in common. For example, the concept of “making and remaking” is a major structural device of both. Decker writes, “The story of Show Boat's making and remaking proves an ideal place to begin the effort to understand how black-cast shows and white-cast shows, blackness and whiteness, blacks and whites, have played against and with each other in the creative realm of the musical over the last eighty years” (5–6). And, as Noonan describes her investigation, “The making and remaking of Porgy and Bess is a case study in the ways that white Americans in the twentieth century craved stories about African Americans featuring earthy authenticity and frictionless progress toward racial equality, while African Americans, particularly African American artists, had to maneuver within the cultural marketplace created by such white desires” (1). The known and recycled qualities of both stories that mutate over the course of time relate neatly for both authors with the changing state of racial relations in the United States.
Decker and Noonan both employ the term “authenticity” throughout their analyses, as they note that a faux-closeness to African American life is key to the imprimaturs of both Show Boat and Porgy and Bess. Both authors situate the experience of this “closeness” as part of audiences' collective enjoyment of the two shows, especially as so-called natural African American behavior onstage is contrasted with the sterility of white, northern, urban life. “Central to [author DuBose Heyward's] understanding of African Americans,” writes Noonan, “was the idea that encroaching urbanization and modernity (forces to which he often obliquely referred in his writing as ‘reform’ or ‘reformers’) were destroying their rural innocence” (17). Similarly for Decker, “[Author Edna] Ferber uses black music and attendant ideas of its authenticity—its immediacy and spontaneity, for example—as a means to critique the sterility of modern New York in general and the Broadway dramatic theater in particular” (20). A related element emphasized by Decker and Noonan is the way the patronizing racial paternalism of each source novel was amplified and amended in equal measure when embodied by black actors and singers.
Todd Decker finds an interesting way of structuring his analysis in Performing Race: he avoids straightforward chronology while retaining a focus on the forward motion of Show Boat's trajectory throughout the twentieth century, focusing not on the story's timeline but emphasizing instead its people and personalities. His first chapter, “A Ferber Plot,” details the author's initial inspiration for the 1925 novel; the following four chapters (“The Robeson Plan”; “The Morgan Plan”; “A Ziegfeld Soprano and a Shubert Tenor”; and “Colored Chorus Curtains”) describe in detail the making of the original musical version of Show Boat in 1927. In Chapters 2 and 3 Decker explains how the singing styles of Paul Robeson and Helen Morgan influenced the creation of the roles of the stevedore Joe and the “passing” actress Julie. Lyricist Oscar Hammerstein and composer Jerome Kern tailored the characters and songs to these individuals, thus impacting later productions or interpretations, and Decker convincingly analyzes “Ol' Man River” as an amalgamation of 1920s musical styles and the spirituals Robeson was then performing in concert. He similarly explains that “how Julie sings ‘Can't Help Lovin’ Dat Man' remained a crucial performance decision across the history of Show Boat, marking larger shifts in how the work was understood and where the sympathies of the audience were directed” (65). Decker summarizes the different elements that created the show when he writes, “The 1927 Show Boat brought together on one stage virtually every aspect of mid-1920s New York entertainment—from white-cast operetta and musical comedy to black-cast folk dramas and revues, with trends in the concert hall and the nightclub also prominently represented” (122).
The latter half of the book explores the various touring productions and film versions of the stage musical, and Decker's archival work is extensive: he tracks every alteration and cut to Show Boat over the years. It is in these later chapters that Performing Race overextends itself, becoming a catalog of productions from the 1950s to the present without offering analysis other than quotes from print reviews; yet, this is where the accumulation of various circulating forms of the story might have yielded interesting connections. (Lauren Berlant's marvelous essay on this subject, “Pax Americana: The Case of Show Boat,” goes unmentioned.) This lack of critical race theory leads to another oversight in the examination of the musical's propagation of simplistic portrayals of its black characters: Decker almost completely lets Hammerstein and Kern off the hook, ascribing any paternalistic racism in the story to Ferber alone. (Noonan similarly pawns any stereotyping in Porgy and Bess off onto Heyward, while composer George Gershwin and colyricist Ira Gershwin get passes.) Decker further takes for granted that there's nothing wrong with Hammerstein's use, or appropriation, of black musical idioms, preferring instead to describe this practice as both progressive and an homage—a debatable point, but one Decker doesn't raise in his otherwise exhaustively researched and well-written book on a story central to American cultural history.
Ellen Noonan's The Strange Career of “Porgy and Bess” covers the various permutations and productions of another singular yet traversed work: Heyward's 1925 novel Porgy. Like Decker, Noonan breaks up the linearity of the trajectory of the work's adaptations; her method is to include various “interludes” that examine life in Charleston, South Carolina as it inspired Heyward, and later, how the novel and opera based on it shaped perspectives of that city and its African American denizens. She begins Strange Career by laying out the racial and cultural dynamics of the work, noting the “attempts to define racial authenticity that make the history of Porgy and Bess so revealing of twentieth-century changes in white ideas about African Americans and black ideas about the relationship between cultural representation and political progress” (3). Throughout, Noonan describes reactions to Porgy and Bess in mainstream white papers, and then alternative, usually negative, responses from the black press. Response to all of Porgy's iterations signaled the tension between white enjoyment of a “realistic” black community in the South, and African American criticisms that such ersatz documentary style reinforces negative stereotypes.
At its most perceptive, Strange Career analyzes how the story itself can allow for such widely differing reactions. For example, Noonan devotes her second chapter (“A Chocolate-Covered Lithograph Strip: Porgy, 1927”) to the 1927 stage version of Porgy; in it she notes, “Racial authenticity was the lens through which . . . [white] critics, and audiences . . . saw and evaluated Heyward's play. For black critics, the theatrical production of Porgy prompted a more complex conversation about authenticity, class, and racial representation, but one that always pivoted back to the pragmatic demands of black theatrical employment and cultural legitimacy” (75). This eye on the pragmatic continued throughout the life of the opera, even as evolving African American self-empowerment rendered its characters more problematic.
The two central chapters of Strange Career (Chapter 3, “Gershwin's Idea of What a Negro Opera Should Be: Porgy and Bess, 1935,” and Chapter 4, “Neither the Measure of America nor That of the Negro: Porgy and Bess, 1952–1956”) focus on the creation and reception of the 1935 opera and a subsequent international tour. Noonan notes: “These three interdependent milestones—Gershwin's success as a serious composer, unprecedented opportunity for African American opera performers, and the creation of a successful American opera—all rested on the assumption that authentic African American sound was central to American music” (145). The term authentic is again central to the analysis: “If the black performers in Porgy the play bore the burden of proving racial authenticity to critics and audiences, with Porgy and Bess, that burden fell to Gershwin” (143). In Porgy and Bess's strange career, the question of who carries the burden of racial authenticity shifts from a white author with local connections, to black performers and their physical presence, and to a white musical composer. This is a fascinating idea that I wish Noonan had explored more.
My favorite chapter in the book details the touring production of 1952–8. Because of Noonan's strengths as an archival researcher, this is a case study that illuminates her central argument. With the tour, the racial tensions of the opera are newly scrutinized due to geopolitical maneuvering. As Noonan explains, “Both [Truman and Eisenhower] administrations hoped to use Porgy and Bess and its cast to counter Soviet charges that American democracy denied equal rights and opportunities to its African American citizens. . . . Porgy and Bess was as much an intervention in the domestic politics of race as it was an exercise in creative foreign policy” (187). It was due to this change of contexts, Noonan wryly notes, that the white press began, in discussion, to distinguish Porgy and Bess's literate, college-trained black actors from the characters they portrayed—something the black press had been doing since the 1920s stage version of Porgy.
Noonan's thorough archival work locates some surprising pop culture reflections of Porgy and Bess—for example, a 1960s Mad Magazine parody. But as in Decker's Performing Race, the latter part of Strange Career becomes rote summations of small variants in revivals of the opera. A telling omission in Noonan's text is the lack of any textual analysis or close reading. Neither dialogue from Porgy nor any lyric or musical selection from Porgy and Bess is directly cited. These elements are instead referenced by way of quoted reviews or interviews—sometimes pages and pages of them. Given Noonan's extensive investigative work into the permutations of the story, and her appreciation for the complexities of Porgy's career, I wish she had woven more theorizing about the performativity of race into this history.
Decker's “Showboat”: Performing Race in an American Musical and Noonan's The Strange Career of “Porgy and Bess”: Race, Culture, and America's Most Famous Opera fascinate on their own and in combination, as their source stories weave in and out of each other's paths and make their way through the twentieth century. Both histories end with discussions of recent revivals, which point to how these shows will be received in the future. Decker, for example, writes that the “1994 Show Boat was shaped in its making and reception by unprecedented and intense public protests” (217); yet, according to Noonan, arguments over the 2011 Porgy and Bess rested on aesthetics and authorship, not race. How could these two works, possessed of such similar racial concerns and complex cultural trajectories, be met with such oppositional receptions in recent days? The answer to that question is a book I also want to read.
