This is a lavish book with an abundance of illustrations, figures and maps. It expertly presents all the evidence related to the inkwell, an instrument of ancient writing that has not hitherto attracted attention and the cultural significance of which has been neglected. While individual inkwells have sometimes been published, no corpus of them has previously existed that would allow us to take their social significance into account. This book focuses on writing and material culture in Roman society through consideration of this instrument in particular. Eckardt is aware of the need not to overemphasise writing in the assessment of literacy because other factors, such as orality and memory, were of great importance. Much has been written on literacy on the basis of textual evidence, but the approach of this book is new in so far as it concentrates on the physical practice of writing.
The book is divided into three main sections, which include some subsections. In Part I (‘Understanding Literacies, Material Culture and Practice in the Roman World’), E. reviews past definitions of literacy and examines writing surfaces and implements used to write on wax, on lead and with ink, including spatulae for applying wax, rulers and pen knives. Most previous considerations of literacy have focused on the written word — texts, inscriptions or letters, with a concentration on levels of literacy — but this book emphasises material culture and explores the practice and chronological contexts of literacy. An important theme of the book that is followed throughout is the relationship of ancient literacy, material culture and identity, considered in light of the technology of writing, in this case the inkwell.
Inkwells are the protagonists of Part II, the most technical. The author shows that they were not a Roman invention, as some are attested in the fifth century b.c. and in the Hellenistic period, but the peak of their use was in the first century a.d. They were mostly made of ceramic, glass and metal; of the last, more than four hundred specimens are known. The material is fully catalogued online (https://dx.doi.org/10.5284/1039969). E. reviews in great detail the characteristics and production of inkwells, and identifies some known makers. She also includes some copper-alloy vessels whose function is still unclear. Because they vary greatly in size, shape and decoration, a general description of the use of inkwells is difficult. Their distribution confirms their heavy presence in military milieux and in urban sites where, as is well known, literacy and numeracy were widespread. Of 440 inkwells, 131 come from cemeteries and burial sites, pointing to the significance of literacy in funerary rites.
Part III of the book (‘Literacy as Performance: Self-Presentation of the Educated Elite’) focuses on the depiction of writing equipment in funerary contexts and on the iconography of tombstones as a manifestation of the identities of the deceased and the mourners. This very interesting section brings together all that precedes. Depictions of writing equipment may refer either to the literacy of the individuals commemorated or to their pride in having servants who could read and write, an impasse that cannot be resolved. The author relates writing materials and literacy to gender, age and status. The evidence of inkwells found in female graves complements other information from letters from Egypt. Graves of women containing inkwells are considerably less numerous than those of men. The author rightly points to modern prejudices, and yet this also reflects the reality of women's education. While E. mentions that some women did attend the school of the grammarian, this was a rare occurrence. It is unfortunate that the paucity of modern osteological analysis impedes sexing evidence and detailed analysis of the use of inkwells across ages and gender. Information on childhood education, therefore, comes mostly from written sources and iconography. The author also turns her attention to other objects found in graves along with inkwells that may contribute to identifying the buried individuals.
E. is well acquainted with modern archaeological theories and with practice theory as a means of understanding objects, not only in their function and characteristics, but also in terms of what they did in ancient society. This research is based on published material and not on personal inspection, which somewhat limits the results. She clarifies, for example, that ceramic inkwells, which are usually not published in detail, are overlooked and that this fact, rather than actual use, explains the rarity of metal inkwells in Spain or Italy. Throughout the book E. declares that she is focusing on literacy in the Roman world, but she does not define the geographical area of her study. She includes only European territories in the relevant period, paying almost no attention to other parts of the Roman Empire. Some clarity would have been welcome. The current reviewer has found less satisfying the parts that consider literacy in general, beyond the inkwell. Undoubtedly because of the author's focus and need to cover so much material these sections contain some imprecisions. These observations do not detract from a very positive evaluation of this book, which adds an important tessera to the complex mosaic of ancient literacy and will allow scholars to raise new issues and ask new questions.
