‘Classical reception studies’ — as readers of this journal hardly need reminding — are booming. Yet for all our interest in the afterlife of classical ideas, texts and materials, the reception of Greek and Roman architecture remains a relatively open field. Yes, there have been various histories of architectural ‘neoclassicisms’, whether packaged as longue durée narratives about motifs, forms and styles, or else structured around the buildings of particular times and places. So too, and increasingly in recent years, there has been an emphasis on the media of reception: scholars have come to appreciate how material monuments mediate the past in ways both like and unlike those of literary texts. But while there has been a growing concern with the reception of classical art (and especially classical sculpture), much less attention has been paid to buildings. So too, the little work that has been done tends to concentrate on specific case studies — on single buildings, regions or periods — at the cost of broader methodological reflection.
This is the scholarly backdrop for the two edited books under review, each exploring classical reception from the perspectives of architectural monuments and interior design, and each focused on the period between the late eighteenth and late twentieth centuries. Both volumes derive from conferences, the first from a 2014 panel of (what was then) the American Philological Association in Chicago, the second from a symposium held in Stockholm in 2008. Both books also bring together an array of specialists, with the explicit aim of building disciplinary bridges between the fields of (inter alia) classics, art history, archaeology, architectural studies, cultural history, philosophy, geography, object studies and museology.
Of the two books, Housing the New Romans lays out the more ambitious intellectual agenda. Despite the titular promise of addressing ‘the new Romans’, this is in fact a volume about responses to various ‘ancient’ architectural forms; ‘neo-antique’ is the term preferred by the editors, covering references to not only Greek and Roman forms, but also Egyptian motifs. If contributors cover the period between the late eighteenth and twentieth centuries, they also proceed from European (for which read British and French) to North American case studies: ‘the essays …’, we are promised, will ‘aim to provide a framework for understanding the reception of these ancient styles, their appropriation and recreation in the architecture and decor of the modern age’ (1).
Book-ending the seven chapters are two editorial interventions, providing an introduction to ‘architectural reception and the neo-antique’ on the one hand, and an afterword about ‘new Romans, new directions’ on the other. For this reader, six aspects of this larger collective agenda stand out. First, the editors use the critical framework of ‘reception’ to bridge the ‘disciplinary boundaries’ between classics and architectural studies (4), while taking their inspiration from Charles Martindale and a ‘Bristol School’. Second, they argue that ‘studies of the reception of Classical material culture are largely underrepresented in many of the recent major companions and edited works on Classical reception’ — largely because ‘reception studies has its genesis in literary studies’ (5). By extension, we are told, ‘Classical archaeologists have often lagged behind their colleagues in other archaeological fields and literary Classical colleagues in the exploration and deployment of theoretical frameworks to their studies’ (6). Third, the editors mount a defence for this term ‘neo-antique’ — which they variously define as ‘an eclectic sensibility’ (7), ‘a new architectural and decorative style’ characterised by a ‘a bricolage of eclectic and/or achronic elements’ (9), and a critical ‘framework [that] encourages us to make connections between the silos of knowledge, specifically here the Neoclassical and the Neo-Egyptian …’ (268). Fourth, the project takes issue with the tendency to theorise architectural influence in reductively positivist terms, premised on the quest to track formalist parallelisms: ‘much of what has been written suffers from what one might term the “Look, it's Roman!” or ‘Look, it's Greek!” model of interpretation’ (9); importantly, the editors also insist that issues of reception have as much to contribute to the study of the classical past as to that of receiving cultures (11–12; cf. 191–2). Fifth, the editorial rhetoric of ‘dwelling’ accommodates not only the monumental, civic and public, but also the domestic and private; in particular, it here includes ‘tombs …, model homes, hotels, gardens and park benches’ (16–17). Sixth and finally, the book is said to advocate a ‘“big tent” approach to the reception of ancient architecture and for a broader understanding of reception studies’, thereby aiming to move ‘the study of ancient architecture solely from the preserve of civic and public realms toward a more nuanced understanding of the reception of ancient architecture in spaces of dwelling’ (272).
As so often with edited volumes, the chapters themselves vary in the extent to which they engage with this programmatic agenda. The first half of the book begins with three European case studies, with contributions by Ann Kuttner (on Sir John Soane's House and Pitzhanger Manor), Caroline van Eck and Miguel John Versluys (on the Hôtel de Beauharnais in Paris) and Shelley Hales (on the 1889 Paris Expo). By contrast, the final four chapters turn to State-side material, examining American nineteenth-century ‘Pompeian’ styles (Marden Fitzpatrick Nichols), the history of exedra configurations in twentieth-century public spaces (Melody Barnett Deusner), ‘entombing antiquity’ in the Woodlawn Cemetery in New York (Elizabeth Macaulay-Lewis) and ‘hyperreal’ recent reconstructions of Roman gardens (Katharine T. von Stackelberg). In some cases, the chief contribution lies in surveying materials that are still too little known (as with Nichols’ scintillating chapter: ‘Despite a wealth of published research on classicizing American interiors …, the popularity of the Pompeian style in the United States remains underresearched’, 127). In others, and most notably in the strongest chapters, authors bring their discussion back to bear on the critical issues that the editors introduce. The chapter by van Eck and Versluys is exceptionally strong here, dedicated to the multicultural associations of the ‘Empire Style’. The Hôtel de Beauharnais offers, we are told, a ‘unique case to study the dynamics of transformation of Greek, Roman, and Egyptian forms’ (55); by extension, the chapter champions a diachronic and comparative approach, positing a transhistorical parallel between the ‘Alexandrian’ styles of Augustan Rome on the one hand and Napoleonic Paris on the other (89–91).
There is much to admire in this volume, not least the editorial efforts to turn a series of (essentially self-contained) articles into a harder-hitting scholarly intervention. Perhaps inevitably, some residual problems remain. One issue lies in coverage. A book such as this, with just seven chapters, is always going to be selective. Yet there is something slightly disingenuous about the editorial rhetoric — which claims that ‘the essays collected within this volume supply a comprehensive study of issues and approaches on the subject of the architectural reception of the Classical world in the nineteenth and twentieth centuries’ (21): among other conspicuous absences, the book says virtually nothing about issues of race, colonisation or imperial power (only in the book's penultimate paragraph do the editors mention ‘the Asian subcontinent, Africa, and South America’, 274). Another issue is nomenclature. Quite apart from the questionable assertion that ‘Europeans and Americans … from c. 1750 to 1970’ amount to ‘New Romans’ (3), I wonder how much this term ‘neo-antique’ offers an improvement over others. On the one hand, the term collapses the manifold associations of classical forms not only with ‘Greek’ and ‘Roman’ models, but also with those of intervening receiving cultures (not least those of the Renaissance). For another, I ended up wondering why ancient Egyptian tropes are included while other ‘antique’ forms are not; the editors offer little justification for their decision to group ‘Classical, classicizing, Egyptian, and Egyptianizing tropes’ together (3). Not everything here will convince everyone. Still, Housing the New Romans will absolutely fuel further debate and discussion: it is essential reading for anyone interested in the material vestiges and reconstructions of the Graeco-Roman past.
Returns to Pompeii is at once narrower and broader in scope. Narrower, in that rather than dealing with ‘architectural reception’ tout court, the focus here is exclusively on responses to Pompeian materials (hence the chronological parameters, extending back to the rediscovery of Pompeii in the eighteenth century). Broader, because the editors deem it ‘neither possible or desirable to arrive at a common set of approaches’ (16). While the title of the volume frames its ‘returns to Pompeii’ in relation to ‘interior space and decoration’, various sorts of afterlife in fact come into play. Alongside ‘Pompeian’ allusions in Italian, Spanish and Scandinavian interiors, chapters also discuss twenty-first-century museological displays (in the Palazzo Reale at Portici and at an exhibition in Helsinki), as well as two nineteenth-century architectural imitations (the Pompejanum constructed by Ludwig I in Bavaria and the Maison Pompéienne in Paris).
A defining aspect of this second volume is the quality of its illustrations. With the exception of three double-sided plates, Housing the New Romans had to make do with black and white images — reproduced on partially transparent paper, sometimes at questionable resolution, and very often at a size unfit for purpose (e.g. 138, fig. 4.5). Returns to Pompeii, by contrast, is illustrated in colour throughout, within a larger-format volume, and on thick, glossy sheets: the standards of the Swedish Institute in Rome put Oxford University Press to shame. Considerable effort has also gone into weaving the various contributions together. As the editors declare in their preface to the book (7), ‘much work has been invested in making it a coherent whole, in spite of its character as an anthology with different authors’. For instance, while readers of Housing the New Romans are faced with individual, chapter-structured lists of references, Returns to Pompeii offers a single consolidated bibliography (with only occasional errors: e.g. the repetition of the entry for Bergmann 1994 on 285).
So much for the form of the book. But what of its content? This project follows hot on the heels of others concentrating on the reception of Pompeii, including the important anthology edited by Shelley Hales and Joanna Paul, Pompeii in the Public Imagination (2011), a catalogue accompanying the 2012 Getty exhibition on The Last Days of Pompeii, and Eric Moormann's monograph Pompeii's Ashes (2014) (cf. 15–16). As a single volume, however, this particular project looks set to be valued less for its theoretical contribution than for its rich individual contributions. Consider the introduction. The editors explain the interdisciplinary collaborations that lay behind the project, as well as their intention to cover new physical and metaphorical sites of reception (‘We offer this volume as an attempt both to take stock and to reinvigorate discussion of the Pompeian interior precisely by looking at it from new angles, literally in terms of the regions covered but also conceptually in terms of the questions of context and motivation that are asked throughout’, 16). This seven-page overview certainly succeeds in situating the project against previous strands of scholarship. For better or worse, though, the introduction offers relatively little in the way of broader methodological take-home.
The contributions that follow treat a veritable miscellany of subjects. One question to emerge in initial chapters is the problem of referring to ‘Pompeian’ (or indeed ‘Neo-Pompeian’) styles in the first place, since ‘very little of what is conventionally called “Pompeian” in neoclassical décor has any direct relation to the city’ (12). This theme recurs — with different responses — in surveys of various case studies in eighteenth- and nineteenth-century Naples (Margot Hleunig Heilmann), Spain (Mirella Romero Recio) and Northern Europe (Sweden: Margareta Nisser-Dalman; Denmark: Ulla Houkjær; Stockholm: Anne-Marie Leander Touati). Readers then find a translation of two eighteenth-century Swedish ‘professional’ accounts of visiting Vesuvian sites (Anne-Marie Leander Touati and Ulf Cederlöf), and a long chapter on the rationale behind the ‘Herculanense Museum’ at the Palazzo Reale at Portici, which opened in 2009 (Irene Bragantini and Renata Cantilena). As a general rule, these chapters — together with a final museological chapter by Antero Tammisto and Helena Wassholm, and a strange ‘appendix’ by Hleunig Heilmann (offering a bizarre set of ‘terminological clarifications’) — are all stronger in description and narrative than in critical analysis and evaluation.
In terms of ambition and scope, the two penultimate chapters by Bettina Bergmann and Shelley Hales offer something markedly different. Bergmann succeeds in framing her contribution as much around the House of the Dioscuri in Pompeii as around Ludwig I's imitation in mid-nineteenth-century Aschaffenburg (‘the ancient house tells us as much about its Bavarian counterpart as the recreation reveals of its Pompeian model’, 184). In a wholly complementary chapter, Hales likewise explores the history and legacy of the Maison Pompéienne in Paris (destroyed in 1891), all the while pondering its significance for ‘returning to Pompeii’: ‘neither past nor present is a copy of the other but caught in a kind of spin cycle as the order of reference is lost’; ‘return is recast as a kind of reception of the past, which is always locked in the present’ (231).
Particularly exciting about both these books is their sense of a field still in its infancy. If the two volumes mobilise material monuments to interrogate the dynamics of classical reception, neither can claim to have the final methodological word. This is very much the virtue of both collections — as a stepping-stone for future work.
