Moving away from extant research practices which study the effect of gender stereotypes on women candidates in hypothetical scenarios—and using an originally collected dataset on voters’ attitudes and behaviors from the 2010 U.S. elections—Kathleen Dolan presents an encouraging and fresh look at the political impact of gender stereotypes. After gathering data from real voters on real candidates across several types of electoral races, Dolan shows that, contrary to conventional wisdom, the influence of gender stereotypes on the success or failure of women candidates is much less than previously assumed. Besides offering a positive message, which has the potential to change the public involvement of women for the better, Dolan’s original study makes several contributions. The first, and most important one, is the methodological improvement over existing studies in that her study collects data on attitudes and choices of actual voters. She surveys 3,150 adults who experienced either single sex (man vs. man) or mixed-sex (man vs. woman) races for Congress and governorships. Second, she moves away from the typical focus on whether the United States is ready to elect a female president, to considering women running for other important offices, such as the House, Senate, and governorships. Broadening the pool of candidates allows her to examine the dynamics of races involving nearly 650 candidates. In collecting this data, her study also makes a tremendous empirical contribution to research concerning the effect of gender stereotypes on the fate of women candidates in American politics. Last, her study serves as the ground upon which many further interesting questions can be posed and provides an inspiration for scholars interested in them to seek the answers—not in an “electoral laboratory,” but rather out in the real world.
After opening Chapter 2 with anecdotes of sexist treatment of women in American political life, Dolan emphasizes the need to address the questions of candidate sex and gender stereotypes on women’s opportunities in politics. She further notes that gender stereotypes may in turn affect how voters evaluate women candidates, and ultimately what choices they make at the ballot. Taking current research, which would suggest that voters have gender-stereotyped ideas about the skills and abilities of women who run for office into account, Dolan reminds us that many scholars and campaign professionals believe that this reliance of voters on stereotypes would eventually hurt women. Yet, she also cites Jody Newman’s (1994) emblematic statement that “when women run, women win.” This brings her to claim that while we know that voters hold political gender stereotypes and that women win elections, we know far less about the connection between the two. In effect, much of this implicit connection is assumed, leaving questions about what use of stereotypes do voters make, how are they employed, and do they matter in a real way to electoral outcomes, unanswered. Dolan sets out to answer these questions by anchoring her study in social psychological theory, which claims that stereotyping is as pervasive as it is because it provides an informational short-cut through which individuals can simplify their interaction with the world.
The primary question that Dolan tries to answer is whether gender stereotypes really matter in politics. Specifically, whether they matter for the success or failure of women candidates. She conceptualizes attitudes about gender into “abstract gender stereotypes” and “specific candidate evaluations” (p. 45). The key difference between the two is that the first accounts for voters’ general beliefs about traits and capabilities of men and women, while the second captures the respondents’ evaluation of the traits and policy abilities of particular candidates. In essence, this conceptualization tries to unpack the assumed relationship between beliefs and evaluations. Chapter 3 presents a series of descriptive statistics on public attitudes toward women in politics. The data presented offers a rich crosscutting view on respondents’ beliefs in which we generally observe large support for the inclusion of more women in elected office. The specific stereotypes that are examined here deal with respondents’ beliefs on the relationship between the gender of candidates and their policy competences, personality traits, and ideology. Overall, the data illustrates that large majorities see no difference between men and women with the exceptions of women being perceived as slightly better on abortion and child care policies and are seen as more liberal than men. In the remainder of the chapter, Dolan examines potential personal characteristic predictors of these abstract gender attitudes and finds that women have significantly more positive attitudes toward women in office than men do. Positive attitudes toward women were also significantly more common among respondents who identified themselves as Democrats, those with higher levels of education, and those with liberal views. To continue piecing the story together, Dolan examines whether gender stereotypes about policy competence and personal traits relate to people’s abstract gender attitudes. The results confirm that political gender stereotypes help shape people’s attitudes about women candidates and women in government. However, when put against vote choice, abstract gender stereotypes show to be almost non-relevant. This suggests that while stereotypes may have some value to voters, they play little role in determining vote choice. Rather, vote choice is primarily influenced by political party (with women being chosen by respondents of the same political party) and incumbency (women who are already in office tend to be re-elected).
The rest of the book delves deeper into the relationship between stereotypes and vote choice. Dolan systematically examines whether abstract stereotypes shape evaluations of candidates (Chapter 4), to what extent stereotypes and evaluations determine vote choice (Chapter 5), and to what extent female and male candidates differ in the quality and manner in which they conduct their campaigns (Chapter 6). The evidence on the role of stereotypes on specific candidate evaluations is mixed, showing that stereotypes seem to play a larger role in evaluation of women candidates for higher offices, and in evaluation of Democratic women. However, when vote choice is considered, Dolan shows that the actual influence of stereotypes is quite limited, while political party is far more influential in all electoral races for both genders. Dolan claims political party has the dominant influence on vote choice, and there is no evidence that people cross party lines just to avoid voting for a woman candidate.
The contributions of Dolan’s study are commendable, both in shifting the way in which we approach the examination of the effect of gender stereotypes on political outcomes, as well as the wealth of data which the study has produced. A clear avenue for furthering and bettering this research would be the inclusion of another wave of surveys. It would be interesting to see whether respondents’ beliefs and evaluations change over time, as well as whether there is a change in how they affect their vote choice in subsequent elections. An elaboration on the finding about the centrality of political parties on vote choice determination could also significantly enrich our understanding of the relationship between stereotypes and vote choice, as it could very well be that other political factors, such as the electoral system, have an important play as to whether party stereotypes overrule beliefs about gender. All in all however, When Does Gender Matter offers a very rich study of the existence of gender stereotypes and their interplay with candidate evaluations in affecting vote choice in America.
