No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 22 July 2005
In 1996, François Burgat, the internationally recognized French research scholar of political Islam, wrote L'islamisme en face, in which he presented a cogent and well-informed analysis of the Islamist phenomenon. Nearly a decade later, the book has been translated into English with a new foreword and conclusion added to the original text. Despite the momentous events that have transpired since the book's original publication which involve the radicalization of Islamist politics from which a jihadist current has emerged that is engaged in global terrorism (most devastatingly expressed in the attacks of 11 September 2001), Burgat's essential thesis remains valid. Unlike that of his well-known French contemporaries Olivier Roy and Gilles Kepel, who have portrayed political Islam as a spent force incapable of meeting the challenges of modernity, democracy, and equality, Burgat's thesis focuses on Islamism's authenticity as a populist voice of political democracy, cultural integrity, and social identity. While he emphasizes the robust nature of Arab authoritarianism in which incumbent regimes have forestalled the emergence of genuine democracy through survivalist strategies that mix coercion and cooptation, Burgat maintains that reformist-oriented political Islam of the kind represented by such movements as Egypt's Muslim Brotherhood, Algeria's Islamic Salvation Front, Tunisia's al-Nahdah party, and Morocco's Justice and Welfare Association serve as the most legitimate, if not democratic, expression of mass-based political activism.
The evidence he presents is wide ranging and compelling. Like few other scholars of the subject, Burgat possesses the linguistic competence (fluent in modern standard Arabic and several regional dialects) and long-term in-country experiences (in North Africa, Egypt, and Yemen, among others) to fuse textual, attitudinal, and behavioral data into a coherent picture of political Islam's multivaried expression. The author consistently maintains that Islamism is best understood through the prism of power politics, both domestic and global, rather than through any close investigation of Islam's theological roots or textual meanings and interpretations.
The book is organized into twelve chapters, with an introduction and conclusion. The first five chapters present a historical narrative explaining how successive ideological incarnations—whether Arab nationalist, Nasserist, socialist, or communist—intended yet failed to capture the hearts and minds of the mass publics. This should not have come as a surprise, given the elite-oriented nature of Western-inspired political formulas founded on purely secular principles and rationalist calculations.
Despite adequate material resources in the form of oil and strategic or other “rents,” these ideological orientations often promised more than they could deliver. It was inevitable, therefore, that once the Arab state failed to deliver on the inflated promises of development and democracy that its ideological rhetoric propagated, a counterhegemonic, if not a countercultural, project would emerge to fill the void.
Yet the rise of political Islam, according to Burgat, cannot be explained purely on instrumental grounds. To be sure, falling standards of living, economic mismanagement, wasted resources, and endemic corruption have all taken their toll on society's lower and middle classes. Groups who have suffered disproportionately blame those in power for their deprivation. Economic discontent, coupled with social marginalization, cultural alienation, political powerlessness, and spiritual aridity, has created an environment conducive to Islamist appeals in which each of these real or perceived grievances finds resolution.
Several chapters are devoted to case studies, including Egypt, Algeria, and the Gaza Strip. These serve to illustrate Burgat's central thesis that Islamic activism and its radical offshoot are inevitable responses to institutional exclusion and state repression. In Egypt and Algeria, for example, Islamist attempts in the 1980s to play by the “rules of the game” quickly degenerated into antisystem protest as military-backed regimes in both countries violently suppressed any attempts by populist forces to achieve power through democratic means. For Burgat, Islamic “terrorism” in Algeria seems a rational response to institutional exclusion, while state-directed “terrorism” is “nothing more than the retreat, the desperate solution, the last gasp of a regime that has not only lost the support of its core supporters but also the hordes of people in its own ranks” (p. 110).
The book's last three substantive chapters focus on the highly contentious issues of Islam and democracy, Islamism and women, and “from imported to imposed modernity.” For his part, Burgat adds his name to an increasingly long list of scholars and specialists of political Islam who reject the notion that Islam as religion, culture, or “civilization” is antithetical to modern, procedural democracy. As far as Burgat is concerned, “two major processes occurring in the Arab world are anything but incompatible: the reconciliation of political discourse with Muslim culture on the one hand, and the slow and laborious emergence of pluralist and tolerant conduct in line with the democratic world on the other” (p. 138).
In his discussion on the view of women within political Islam, the author is unambiguous in his belief that patriarchal culture, and not Islam or Islamism, is the principal source of feminist exclusion in the Arab world. The quote of one female Algerian psychiatrist seems to capture this essence: “Compared to North African tradition, Islam is progress” (p. 148).
In his concluding chapter, Burgat attempts to incorporate and reinterpret the meaning of the events after 11 September 2001 in the context of Islam's worldwide radicalization. While others see the futility, if not the destructive impulse, of Islamism, which needs to be countered by all possible means (“the war on terrorism”), Burgat continues to believe that the source of social unrest, violence, and terrorism is found in the authoritarian state that employs a combination of repressive and cooptive strategies to maintain itself in power at all costs. Incumbent regimes, he argues, “have all succeeded in putting their power well beyond the reach of their fellow citizens' electoral whim by the means of timely constitutional reforms” (p. 166). Yet despite this effort at political stasis, significantly aided by external actors, Burgat believes that Islamism as a political discourse remains active in two areas: “in the internal contestation of Arab political orders and, internationally, in the context of East–West relations” (p. 183).
Whether one agrees with Burgat's thesis or not, his book provides a deeply reasoned yet impassioned understanding of a complex phenomenon whose activism currently challenges world public opinion. While at times the translated text can be awkward and perplexing, this study remains essential reading for anyone interested in coming face to face with political Islam.