These two compelling books explore life for communities on the periphery in island Southeast Asia from very different perspectives. Anthropologist Michael Eilenberg's ethnography examines state power along the Indonesian border, while Thomas Gibson and Kenneth Sillander's edited volume explores how nine egalitarian societies maintain high levels of both personal autonomy and intergroup unity and cooperation.
In At the Edges of States, Eilenberg builds upon a recent interest in borderlands by exploring the process of Indonesian state formation and state-society relations at the remote border between West Kalimantan and Malaysia. He seeks to counter earlier studies that portrayed state power along borders as cohesive, instead arguing that state formation is an ongoing and “fluid process of contestation and negotiation” (p. 52). He draws on extensive ethnographic research carried out with ethnic Iban, whose traditional lands span the Indonesian-Malaysian border, to demonstrate how the Indonesian state's power in the borderland fluctuates over time and is challenged by local communities. By focusing on Iban elites, he illustrates how they take advantage of shifting political landscapes and frequently operate in a gray zone between legality and illegality.
Utilizing a range of sources, such as Dutch colonial records and Iban oral histories, Eilenberg examines how the Iban developed an ambivalent relationship with the Indonesian state because of a particular border history going back to the colonial era when the Iban challenged Dutch efforts to reduce their autonomy. During the 1960s and 70s, the Indonesian state heavily militarized the borderland, first in an attempt by Sukarno to prevent the formation of the Malay Federation, and later as part of Suharto's effort to purge “Communist insurgents” in the region (p. 125). Caught in the midst of the fighting, most Iban attempted to protect themselves by appearing neutral. A small handful of Iban, however, fostered connections within the army and were awarded forest concessions and special positions representing their communities. While claiming loyalty to the Indonesian state, they also maintained networks in Malaysia. These individuals formed the border elite.
After the fall of the Suharto regime in 1998, the state began a program of decentralization. The border elite quickly drew on the patronage networks they had developed in the army and local government, as well as their cross-border connections, to work the new political situation to their advantage by facilitating logging operations run by Malaysians. While the central government saw timber extraction as illegal and the involvement of Malaysians as a threat, the Iban understood logging as part of managing their traditional forest lands and welcomed the involvement of Malaysians who respected Iban values. Eilenberg focuses on the activities of an individual Malaysian logging broker to effectively illustrate how patronage networks operated.
Beginning in 2005, the central government increased the military presence along the border to regain control of the “lawless” region, justifying their actions through the rhetoric of “security” and “development” (p. 236). At the time of Eilenberg's research (2007), the border elite were once again strategically engaging with the new political situation. In order to push for increased autonomy through the creation of a new administrative district, they were drawing on the government's security and development rhetoric and emphasizing their loyalty to the state. Simultaneously, they were playing the “border card” by threatening to become a part of Malaysia if the negotiations failed (p. 271).
Eilenberg's compelling analysis demonstrates the value of borderlands as productive sites to explore the complexities of state power. Importantly, he points out that many studies of borderlands overemphasize local populations' resistance to the state. By contrast, the book makes a significant contribution to the literature on state-society relations by illustrating how local elites engage in “networks of collusion” with state authorities to best serve their interests (p. 55). In addition, Eilenberg draws attention to how political decentralization can blur the line between legality and illegality, because local authorities often have a different understanding of wrongdoing than that established by state laws. These discussions will make At the Edges of States helpful to scholars interested in state-society relations and political decentralization in Indonesia and beyond.
The edited volume Anarchic Solidarity examines nine small, anarchic societies in the Malay Peninsula, Borneo, and the Philippines that are clearly distinguished by strict egalitarianism and high levels of personal autonomy. Associations between people within these societies are informal and fluctuate frequently, a characteristic the editors describe as “open aggregation” (p. 2). Almost all of the societies are distinctly peaceable, and sharing is their primary mode of transaction. Despite having fluid and nonhierarchical organizational principles and virtually no forms of social control, people express a sense of unity and cooperate extensively. The volume is premised on a question sparked by this point: what is the source of solidarity in anarchic societies?
Each of the nine central chapters explores this question based on the contributor's long-term ethnographic fieldwork in a particular society. Two major themes emerge, the first of which is the importance of shared values. Based on his work with the Batek in Malaysia, Kirk Endicott (chapter 3) argues that tacit ethical principles form a primary source of solidarity, namely respecting and helping others and being self-reliant, nonviolent, and noncompetitive. A community based on mutual aid is formed when children are inculcated with these principles. Lars Kaskija (chapter 8) identifies a sense of deprivation vis-à-vis outsiders as a core value of the Punan in Borneo. He suggests that this feeling unites people together and is reinforced through pelulup urip, a ritualized form of collective commiseration in which Punan express pity for themselves. The nomadic maritime Sama Dilaut (chapter 9) attribute words with particularly high value and power. Clifford Sather argues that this understanding allows them to constantly manage relationships through frank and open speech and resolve all conflicts verbally. The “never-ending flow of words” that characterizes Sama Dilaut social life thus helps maintain their solidarity (p. 244).
A second theme in the book is the significance of kinship for solidarity, making the volume relevant to a renewed interest in kinship studies in anthropology. Kenneth Sillander (chapter 6) suggests that the Bentian of Borneo have a “practice-based” understanding of relatedness based on familiarity with others, and extend kinship terms for close consanguines to distant cognatic and affinal kin (p. 155). He argues that this use of terms extends positive relations and moral obligations to a large and flexible network of people in the community. In the Philippines (chapter 5), the Palawan kinship system produces asymmetrical dyadic relations between individuals without resulting in a system of overall ranking. Charles Macdonald believes that the “limited formal inequality” of these dyads serves to regulate possible tensions between kin, helping the community at large to remain stably egalitarian (p. 135).
The volume contributes rich ethnographic material to the upsurge in research on non-state peoples in Southeast Asia. As Gibson and Sillander point out in their introduction, it dovetails nicely with James Scott's work on mainland Southeast Asia in The Art of Not Being Governed by focusing on societies in peninsular Malaysia and island Southeast Asia.Footnote 4 By providing nuanced description and analysis of several forms of “actually existing anarchy,” the volume also makes a vital contribution to a recent interest in the theory and practice of anarchism both inside and outside academia (p. 10). As was the editors' hope, the book's vivid accounts of alternate forms of social organization furthermore offers inspiration to readers whose values are similar to those upheld by these societies.
