This is an excellent book and a much-needed contribution to the historiography of British India. Elizabeth Kolsky's starting point is the routine, everyday violence that both subverted and sustained colonial rule. She draws on a range of readily accessible archives and, finding little need to read against their grain to find histories of ‘white violence’ in India, she asks “why the historiographical silence?” The chapters blend key moments in Indian colonial history (including Burma) with a number of interconnecting themes, to discuss colonial law; medical jurisprudence; evidence, testimony and perjury; juries; and so-called ‘accidental death’. Key to understanding the book is the idea that “law normalized the violence that sustained British dominance. . .Violence was not an exceptional but an ordinary part of British rule in the subcontinent”. (pp. 231, 232).
The book presents multiple examples of colonial violence, necessarily in all its brutal and often deeply affecting detail. The discussion encompasses the corporal punishments codified in the legal regime (flogging, execution) as well as verbal abuse of Indians, near-casual kicks and punches, shootings, torture, rape and sexual assault. For Kolsky, law and violence are exemplary of the “tensions of empire” earlier described by Frederick Cooper and Ann Laura Stoler. “It is a central argument of this book”, she writes, “that the tension between the promise and practice of colonial law snapped around trials of violent Britons, exposing the centrality of race to the workings of colonial justice and the violence that was central to empire itself” (p. 210). The concept of the ‘rule of difference’ is thus highly significant, and Kolsky shows that law in theory, and in practice, operated on two distinct ‘racial’ registers.
In this review, I would like to dwell for a moment on Colonial Justice. . .White Violence's chapter on the tea plantations of Assam, for in many ways it encapsulates the book's central theme (which Kolsky describes as simultaneously the menace and maintenance of empire, pp. 146–147). Indian labourers were made subject to dreadful levels of violence, and though they engaged in resistance against the plantation regime, a distinct double standard emerged. As Kolsky writes: “European violence was viewed as a rational and necessary mode of labor control, peasant attacks were generally described as acts of insubordination, fanaticism, or insanity” (p. 175). Her analysis of plantation life sits very well against other research on Indian indentured labour overseas in the Mascarene and Caribbean islands. It also coalesces neatly with work on colonial labour regimes in India, and on Indian prisons, penal settlements and colonies. Violence was written into strategies of colonial discipline on sugar plantations, in coalmines, and in chain gangs. Indentured labourers, prisoners and transported convicts were brutalised by the colonial state. They were sworn at, beaten, flogged and assaulted. They resisted and reproduced this violence, individually and collectively. But, as for the contexts that Kolsky describes, the odds were always stacked against them. Typically, white perpetrators of violence got off lightly; Indians were almost always on the receiving end of harsh penal sanctions.
With respect to colonial labour regimes elsewhere, I was also very interested in the book's multiple allusions to the world beyond India. Rightly, Kolsky frames her argument within the enduring legacies of the cruelties of the African slave trade and slavery, as also with metropolitan concerns about the treatment of ‘aboriginal’ peoples in Australia (and, I might add, elsewhere across empire) (p. 41). But I would also like to view her arguments within the devastating violence against indigenous peoples in places like the Cape Colony, Van Diemen's Land and – close to the Indian mainland – the Andaman Islands. In this respect the book, I think, speaks to the networking of India within larger colonial circuits. Beyond the comparisons across colonial regimes, there are lots of references to the social problems caused by sailors, escaped convicts, loafers and European vagrants from across the empire, in India, suggesting that the ‘rule of difference’ was constituted within a larger imperial framework. Indeed, as Kolsky implicitly acknowledges in her discussion of the legal codification of ‘race’, the ‘poor whites’ of India could also be Eurasian, African, Chinese and American (p. 105). I was reminded in the book's discussion of the difficulty of establishing ‘racial’ identities within legal frameworks (Chapter 2) of anthropologist Laura Bear's fascinating recent account of Anglo-Indian railway workers’ efforts to prove their European descent (Lines of the Nation, 2007). It is noteworthy too that the colonial regime relied on a whole range of ‘mixed’ descent Europeans, and they became imbricated in the rule of violence, which always positioned ordinary Indians at the bottom of the heap. And, in this respect it is also important that one of the principal tensions of empire drawn out by this book is not just that between the promise and practice of law, or about racially variegated rule, but around elite disquiet at the violence of their social ‘others’.
Colonial Justice. . . White Violence is necessary reading for scholars interested in colonial India and empire. For ‘traditional’ historians, who still seek to weigh the costs of empire against its benefits, it will make uncomfortable reading. It pushes all of us to ask penetrating questions about the practice of history – about what we choose to write about (and teach) and how we do so. It leaves us wondering also about the many other unwritten histories of empire, urging us to turn back to reading along, rather than against, the archival grain (Ann Laura Stoler, Along the Archival Grain, 2009).
