In its contemporary form, political Islam or Islamism has preoccupied scholars and policymakers for over three decades since the 1979 Iranian revolution, taking on an even more pronounced presence since the attacks on the United States in 2001. In virtually every Muslim-majority country, as well as in Europe and other places where Muslims are a minority, Islamism's identity, purpose, and methods have been analyzed and reanalyzed through a plethora of ideological, historical, and theological prisms. Contrary to what the scholarly enterprise is supposed to achieve in its cumulative quest for knowledge and understanding, the more scholars have addressed and studied political Islam, the less one understands its purpose and meaning. This has been the case with scholarship on North Africa as in other parts of the Arab and Muslim worlds. What has complicated analysis in the case of political Islam in Morocco, the subject of the book under review, is the complex, long-enduring, and multilayered character of Islamic identity and existence in the country. It is no surprise that anthropologists, political scientists, historians, students of religion, and sociologists have produced an abundant literature on Moroccan Islam given Morocco's relatively open research environment and the relevance of the topic being studied; a literature amply represented in the author's extensive bibliography.
Zeghal's overall purpose is to analyze critically the ways in which political Islam in the case of Morocco has confronted authoritarian state power that is itself being reconfigured in seemingly pluralistic ways, thereby allowing Islamist parties to contest elections. For their part, and through putatively democratic institutions and practices, incumbent regimes in the Middle East and North Africa are co-opting the Islamist idiom in their quest to maintain the authoritarian order. Indeed, a true understanding of Islamism's universalizing presence in Morocco, as in other parts of the Arab and Islamic worlds, is as much the result of carefully crafted and cynically engineered state-sponsored policies of promoting religiously based legitimacy as it is the product of a deeply devout mass public searching for meaning and purpose in a world of material deprivation, social dislocation, and spiritual aridity. The author is correct when she observes that “Islamism, rather than being the ideology of Islamists only, is . . . the product of the accrued competition between Islamists and the state around the understanding of Islam” (p. xiii).
The author organizes her book in three parts, including ten chapters and an epilogue, with each substantive part focusing on a distinctive political-religious element of the state–society divide. Part 1 provides a fairly standard historical account of how the monarchy institutionalized Islam as a central component of modern Moroccan nationhood. The second and third parts, which deal with Abdessalam Yassine and the Party of Justice and Development (PJD), respectively, are more innovative and insightful. Yassine's Movement of Justice and Benevolence, a movement never recognized by the regime but always its most consistent critic, represents a fusion of mysticism, messianism, and mobilization. To this day, it remains the most authentic expression of an Islamic political opposition movement that forcefully challenges the monarchy's legitimacy, however quixotic its leader appears to many. In a world of manipulation and dissimulation, where “opposition” and “supporter” are but opportunistic derivatives of each other, Yassine has remained faithful to his religiously inspired beliefs. His motto remains, “Islamizing politics rather than politicizing Islam.” One measure of Yassine's impact on regime behavior has been the degree to which the monarchy has felt it necessary to reinforce, reinvent, and reify Islamic politics in an unending quest to broaden its base of legitimacy. The author is fair-minded and informative in her treatment of the man and his movement as well as in her assessment of the impact Justice and Benevolence has had on the Islamization of the Moroccan state and society.
Zeghal's treatment of the PJD is equally perceptive as she provides both historical context and analytical precision to an understanding of a so-called Islamist party—the PJD publically disavows this label, declaring that it “is not an Islamist party but a political party with an Islamic frame of reference” (p. 203)—and its relationship to a regime with which it competes for religious legitimacy. But like other students of the subject, Zeghal imbues the PJD with much more influence, both politically and electorally, than it actually possesses, however impressive its parliamentary victories. Having accepted the regime-imposed rules of the game, the PJD's degree of political maneuverability has been severely constrained. The monarchy's divide and rule tactics, finely honed over many decades, undermine any claims to meaningful contestation, participation, and democratization. The future of Morocco's political field, including the incorporation of Islamic parties into the political process, remains an open question with room for scholarly debate.
This then is a book filled with sharp analytical observations in regard to an important set of political and religious relationships as they impact on the performance of Moroccan state and society. One learns a great deal about “religion, authoritarianism, and electoral politics” in Morocco, however much that knowledge leads to a problematic optimism. The book is only handicapped by an uneven and awkward translation from the original French and the all too frequent repetition of events and facts. Yet none of these stylistic limitations take away from the importance of this study from which both students and scholars will benefit.
