The political upheavals shaking the Arab world since 2011 have intensified a Western public discourse that tends to attribute regional instability and violence in large part to the persistence of ancient sectarian differences and hatreds. James Grehan's book directly challenges that narrative with a bold and important reconceptualization of “popular religion” supported by a detailed and engaging historical ethnography. Grehan's exploration of popular religion focuses on Ottoman Syria and Palestine from the late 17th century to the early 20th century, but the conclusions may reasonably be extended to other parts of the Middle East and elsewhere across Afro-Eurasia, as the author's broad reading and judicious comparative comments make clear, and resonate with earlier premodern periods stretching back to the medieval age and antiquity.
Grehan is concerned with the religion of the mass of the population, who were largely illiterate; he is not concerned with institutional religion as expressed formally in scripture, law, and theology. He terms this form of mass religion “agrarian religion,” which is characterized by its “essential worldliness and pragmatism,” and defıned by “the use of propitiatory magic, reverence for miracle-workers, for nature cults and spirit cults, and various forms of ancestor veneration” (p. 192). Agrarian religion is a conceptual departure from the various commonly used scholarly terms. It is not popular religion, which Grehan argues is imprecise and fraught with conceptual contradictions, nor is it “rural religion,” confined to zones beyond the urban centers of institutional religion, nor can it be equated to Sufism, which in this period was enmeshed with institutional religion and captures only part of the diverse folk practices described by the author. Agrarian religion is founded on the premise, derived primarily from anthropological theory, that religion is not so much an independent cultural entity as it is an integrated component of a larger social ethos, given coherence by geography, material environment, and oral culture. For the modern observer, perhaps the most striking aspects of this form of religion were the free exchange of ideas and practices among worshippers of differing faiths, who lived in close proximity to one another, and the production and reproduction of a shared religious culture bringing together Muslims, Christians, and Jews on a frequent and regular basis (p. 14).
While the book is formally divided into six chapters, thematically its chapters might be grouped into four parts. Constituting the first part is Chapter 1, entitled “Religious Possibilities,” which examines the various factors that limited the reach of institutional religion into the everyday lives of believers. Making extensive use of late Ottoman yearbooks (salnames), Grehan shows with few exceptions that formal houses of worship, whether Muslim or non-Muslim, tended to be concentrated in the towns, with rural areas having a markedly lower density, even absence, of such structures. Correspondingly, educated men of religion, who were the only persons qualified to teach doctrine, overwhelmingly resided in the towns, leaving at best partially literate and trained imams, priests, or monks to guide the faithful in the villages.
The cultural horizons of the general population therefore largely remained within the bounds of agrarian religion, as Grehan defines it, until the early part of the 20th century. A central part of this religious world was the veneration of saints, which is treated in depth in the following part, Chapter 2, entitled “Magic Men.” In this chapter and throughout the book, the sheer number of sources used is impressive and the range extraordinary, encompassing Orientalist studies of legal and literary texts, early 20th-century ethnographic works, local travelogues, urban topographies, chronicles, biographical dictionaries, legal treatises, and fatwa collections. Carefully orchestrating this diverse set of sources, many of which are written in Arabic and Turkish, the author demonstrates the operation of a vast sphere of popular culture in which men and women from differing walks of life became saints, performed miracles, and addressed the spiritual and psychological needs of the mass of believers.
Forming a distinctive, third part of the book are Chapters 3 and 4, entitled “A Religion of Tombs” and “Sacred Landscapes,” respectively. They focus on the geographical aspects of agrarian religion and how believers invested places and spaces with meaning. In encyclopedic fashion, Chapter 3 details the architectural, social, legal, and religious functions of the tombs of saints. On particular display in this chapter is Grehan's patient and sophisticated use of the travelogues of the well-known Sufi and jurist ʿAbd al-Ghani al-Nabulsi (d. 1731), whose extensive journeys and pilgrimages took him through the Syrian and Palestinian countryside. Chapter 4 makes clear that it was not only the exemplary lives of saints that could engender a tradition of worship but also a more ambient sense of the supernatural embedded in the physical environment, whether in trees, caves, rocks, the sky, or bodies of water.
The fifth and sixth chapters, entitled “Haunted Landscapes” and “Blood and Prayer,” respectively, might be coupled together in a fourth part, as they describe the world of “spirits and demons” existing in parallel with the material world, and how worshippers, both Muslim and non-Muslim, should interact with them. Chapter 5 discusses the spirits’ diverse personalities and their intervention in human affairs both benign and malignant, such as poltergeists and possessions; techniques and devices, such as spells, talismans, and icons, used to protect oneself from malignant spirits; and the interpretation of dreams and visions, which were accorded great importance. Notable in this chapter is a discussion of the ways in which even members of the ʿulamaʾ recognized the potency of spirits. Chapter 6 is perhaps the analytical highpoint of the book. It marshals an impressive range of evidence to show that Muslims and non-Muslims shared not only a common devotional etiquette and votive language but also similar calendars of observance, rituals of sacrifice and, in many cases, the same place of worship.
Overall, Grehan makes a compelling case for the existence of a common, premodern religious culture in which ordinary Muslims, Christians, and Jews were full and active participants, despite their different confessional affiliations. In a book as ambitious and wide-ranging as this, there will inevitably be points that will draw debate and criticism. First, the consistent characterization of agrarian religion in terms that are seen as overwhelmingly positive by the modern-day reader—open, tolerant, ecumenical—risks an idealization of the premodern religious practices. To his credit, Grehan interprets some events of interconfessional amity as the likely outcome of both personal calculation and sincerity, but this level of analysis could have been done more systematically. The rich trove of historical evidence deployed throughout the book to describe women visiting shrines and performing other acts of religiosity, for reasons of fertility or for securing the affections of wayward husbands, suggests an opportunity to discuss patriarchy and social hierarchies more generally. Second, another point is that the narrative of the transition from agrarian religion to modern, literacy-based religion in the late 19th and early 20th centuries (pp. 196–206), while deftly written, could have been lengthened to discuss more fully the key elements of change and continuity and to suggest areas of further research.
These points do not detract substantially from what is a major achievement in early modern religious and social history. This book should be read by the widest possible audience, from scholars of Ottoman, Arab, and Islamic history, to historians of religion, to social scientists specializing in the Middle East. The accessible and graceful language and well-chosen illustrations will further attract the general educated reader.
