It is common for reviews of more than one title to seek a common thread across the books even when this is not obvious to the naked eye. However, in this case there is a genuine synergy/complementarity/contrast between the two titles which is really quite interesting. Social Movements and Globalization (Fominaya) casts its net wide in examining how contemporary social movements are both shaped by and in turn themselves shape what we call globalization. It poses clearly the question of the challenges posed but also opportunities opened up for social movements under the present global order. Mobilizing Democracy (Almeida) on the other hand is a close up view of social movement campaigns in Central America from 1980 to 2013. It seeks answers to the question of what sparks mass mobilizations against particular state economic policies. The connection between global and local economic transformation and social mobilizations are illuminated by both titles taken together.
Social Movements and Globalization is a very readable survey of the global justice movement and its more recent manifestations in the Occupy, Indignado and Arab Spring revolts with particular attention to the role of communications technologies in social protest. From the Battle of Seattle (1999) onwards, we have seen a tension between the autonomist and institutional left strategies that are examined critically and even-handedly by Fominaya. There is considerable emphasis placed on the cultural dimension of resistance, recognising in Gramscian terms that the cultural domain is an arena of domination (as in culture of consumerism) but also where counter-hegemonic narratives are forged. The section on the role of information technology is particularly interesting and the author seems to be arguing that the emphasis on role of social media in these protests has sometimes been overstated. A final section on whether we have been witnessing a ‘global wave’ of protest since the global financial crash of 2007/8 raises what is a key issue in social movement theory and analysis. Even if we have not seen the emergence of a ‘global movement’, as communism for example once was, we have arguably experienced a global wave of protest and continue to do so.
Mobilizing Democracy operates on a different level, focusing on the complex local reactions to the impact of global neoliberal policies. It moves beyond earlier blanket descriptions of these neoliberal conditions as ‘IMF roots’. We see much more coordination in practice and a repertoire of protest actions, including strikes, rallies, marches and boycotts. There is an emphasis on regional variations at the subnational level that lead to mobilizations against globalization on a national scale. Where state and community structures are stronger and more extensive, there is a greater chance for coordinated collective action to emerge. The dynamics of local mass mobilization in the global South in the era of globalization cannot be reduced to a simple reaction against global forces as tended to be the case in the massive citizens’ protests such as the ‘IMF’ riots interpretations. The legacy of the earlier state-led development period in particular offered a springboard for action today. Protecting the state infrastructure has been a major strand in moving into the post neoliberal period and this again sets a different context from the notion of ‘new’ globalization in an absolutely novel way.
What these two texts taken together pose is the nature of the relation between the global and the local. Global movements and global waves of protest do not necessarily map neatly on to the local or national level. To put in another way, the protests in Central America do not respond to the same causes as those other ‘local’ protests in the US, Spain or North Africa that are seen as ‘global’. The campaigns against the impact of neoliberalism on specific issues (e.g. privatization or labour flexibility) in the global South are, arguably, part of a ‘global’ wave even if they cannot be placed in the same category as the democratic revolts of the Arab Spring for example. Yet we remain unclear on the precise politics of scale involved in these revolts and the dynamics of uneven development which shape them. What these two texts – read alongside each other – provide us with is a rich insight into the dense fabric of social movement mobilizations in all their social, political and discursive complexity.
