Garcia-Arenal's Messianism is a thorough survey of the messianic figures and movements of the region of North Africa and Muslim Spain until the 17th century. Because she defines messianism broadly—including “false” prophets, renewers, Sufi puritans, and imperial dynasts—the book is almost a history of the development of Islam in the region. As it is, Messianism is a major contribution to the field of Islamic religion and social movements and is very well documented.
Working chronologically, Garcia-Arenal focuses first upon the phenomenon of Berber prophets (8th to 10th centuries) whose somewhat eclectic interpretation of Islam heralded their eventual conversion. She then details the rise of the puritanical impulse of al-amr bi-l-maʿrūf wa-l-nāhy ʿan al-munkar (also recently covered by Michael Cook) and its significance in the appearance of messianism. Next she explores the manner in which Sufism included messianic themes. Having already included materials about the messianic nature of the early Kharijites, the Idrisids, and the Fatimids, Garcia-Arenal follows a more dynastic approach for the rest of the book, detailing in turn the Almoravids, the Almohads, the Marinids, the Saʿdids, and the end of the Spanish Muslims.
Although Garcia-Arenal bases herself squarely upon preexisting scholarship, carefully reviewing the pros and cons of each approach, she still manages to produce a significant amount of completely new material. This stems in part from the depth of her scholarship, which is impressive, but also from her inclusion of so many different phenomena under the rubric of messianism and renewal. Although she does quite a good job of putting most of this into context, some elements of the treatment of Sufism—which in itself could fill volumes—are too cursory for the reader to understand the significance of what she is saying. For example, the treatment of the messianic thought of Muhyi al-Din ibn al-ʿArabi (pp. 139–43) is far too abbreviated to do him justice (although, to be fair, because of the complexity of his thought it is difficult to know how one would overcome such a problem). Other major Sufi thinkers, such as al-Ghazali, are treated insofar as their reception in North Africa and al-Andalus is concerned and within the context of their continuing influence upon messianism and revivalism.
Garcia-Arenal's treatment of context within the Spanish and North African region is very detailed. She does not suffice merely with Muslim materials but includes a great deal of comparative Christian and Jewish material as well as a selection of syncretistic Muslim (either Berber or Spanish Muslim) material that sheds light upon standard Muslim beliefs or explains the spiritual trends against which they are reacting. Beyond this, she also marshals impressive evidence concerning the imperial messianic aspirations of the Saʿdid dynasty, including architectural details of the 16th-century palace of al-Badi (pp. 274–82). This analysis of imperial messianic tradition in North Africa is very welcome and could be easily expanded to a number of Muslim dynasties (as Cornell Fleischer has also done for the Ottomans).
At the beginning of Messianism Garcia-Arenal includes a general treatment of the role of messianism within Islam. This theoretical and definitional study, which includes a good deal of comparative material (although oddly not the work of J. J. Collins), could be expanded. One basic problem of the study of Muslim apocalyptic and messianic movements and tendencies is the need for scholars to free themselves from Christian and Jewish terminology that can obfuscate elements of Islamic belief and practice. Although it is clear that Muslim tendencies did not develop in a vacuum, there are problems with using certain terms like “millenarian” (p. 6) with respect to Islam (because of the term “millennium” that it conjures, which has no Muslim equivalent). For the most part, Garcia-Arenal overcomes these definitional problems by using Arabic terminology as much as possible. Her discussion of the differences between the terms “messiah” and “mahdi” (pp. 4–6) are particularly useful.
Garcia-Arenal's treatment of Maghribi messianism and reform movements is an invaluable addition to the still meager selection on Muslim apocalyptic and messianic beliefs and movements. Messianism is extremely well documented and well translated into English (from Spanish), although users in a classroom setting would probably require some background knowledge. All in all, Messianism is a magnificent accomplishment—one that is certain to be the basis for any further study in the field of messianic renewal in Islam.
