In the spring of 1998, President Suharto was forced to step down, thus ending 30 years of authoritarian rule. Defying most Indonesia watchers’ expectations, the country underwent a transition to democracy and then seemed to consolidate political reforms. Enough time has now passed for a crop of books and articles to have been published about the downfall of authoritarianism and the question of democratic consolidation. Democracy & Islam in Indonesia , edited by Mirjam Künkler and Alfred Stepan, and The Institutional Origins of Communal Violence, by Yuhki Tajima, are two such books.
The goal of Democracy & Islam is to examine the country’s democratic transition and consolidation and to see it as an example of an Islamic country successfully implementing democracy. The volume is organized around Juan Linz and Alfred Stepan’s conceptualization of democratic transitions and consolidations. The chapters correspond to the three dimensions of democratic consolidation: attitudinal (there is significant public support for democratic political frameworks); behavioral (there are no significantly powerful groups trying to overthrow democracy by violence); and constitutional (the political and legal framework, “rule of law,” is robust enough to channel diverse interests in a fair and meaningful way).
The first two chapters, by Künkler and Stepan and by R. William Liddle and Saiful Mujani, review the literature on democratization and democratic consolidation. These scholars agree that Indonesia has successfully navigated the democratic transition and that the country is well on its way to consolidating those changes (albeit in incomplete and sometimes problematic ways). The second section addresses attitudinal elements; Künkler looks at the development of democratic attitudes among Muslims and argues that support for democracy has come about not because Islam in Indonesia (as some assert) is more syncratic or “moderate” (although it might be) but because key religious leaders and intellectuals saw and propagated the idea that Islam is compatible with a pluralist political process. The most significant threat to democracy, according to Franz Magnis-Suseno’s chapter, is not from violent organizations but from government timidity and inaction in the face of intolerant acts.
The third section looks at behavioral factors, particularly from the military, radical Islamist groups, and separatist forces. At Suharto’s fall, many predicted that these actors would not only doom Indonesia’s chances for genuine political reform but could also cause the country to disintegrate. Marcus Mietzner’s chapter on the military explains how the military went from effectively running the country from 1965 to 1978, to being in a weaker political position by the end of Suharto’s tenure, to finally losing their formal political power as part of democratization efforts. Although the military is far less powerful and influential than before, and less so than many predicted (p. 103), military officers are still major actors in politics; they have retained the territorial command structure, their immunity from prosecution, and economic opportunities.
Two critical points can be drawn from Sidney Jones’s chapter on radical Islamic groups: first, that the escalation of religious violence and the terror attacks on Bali and Jakarta (ironically) prompted a greater strengthening of state and police capabilities and professionalization of internal security institutions; and second, that the bigger threat to democracy in Indonesia is actually not jihadi groups but the thuggish groups like FPI (Islamic Defenders Front) and HTI (Hizbut Tahrir Indonesia), who harass people for un-Islamic behavior and commit violence against minorities like the Ahmadiyya (p. 122). Rounding out this section, Edward Aspinall’s chapter on separatist movements finds that after letting East Timor break away, other separatist problems have been “managed” through a combination of political and economic concessions, the use of force, and institutional elements that helped channel separatist demands as the center weakened after 1998.
The last section examines legal institutions. Looking at local adoption of sharia law, John Bowen argues that this should not be interpreted as a uniform national increase in religiosity, but as part of the process of decentralization where local elites are looking for their own autonomy and legitimacy, sometimes using religious law as a way to assert themselves and as a way to mobilize citizens (and to collect more revenue through the zakat). The final chapter by Tim Lindsey and Simon Butt examines attempts to clean up the judicial system. While some progress has been made to professionalize legal institutions and clean up corruption, there is still a long way to go. Decentralization has created parallel institutions and overlapping legal mandates that the legal system has yet to regulate.
Tajima’s Institutional Origins explains ethnic and religious violence in Indonesia from 1996 to 2000. Indonesia is a highly diverse archipelagic nation; ethnic and religious violence is not uncommon in the country’s history. Under Suharto’s tight rule, communal violence was mostly controlled. Beginning in 1996 (before the 1997 economic crisis and before Suharto was pushed out of office), there was a significant spike in communal violence, and it fell off again after 2000. As Tajima notes (pp. 1–3), this is similar to outbreaks of communal violence in other circumstances during periods of regime transitions. Why does communal violence escalate during authoritarian breakdown in some places and not in others? If the explanation is simply the weakening of the coercive powers of the state at the end of an old order, why do we see it occur in some parts of Indonesia and not in others; why do we see communal violence in some ethnically or religiously divided countries and not in others? And, what accounts for the decline in violence after 2000?
To answer these questions, Tajima looks at both national and local-level institutions, as well at informal institutions at the local level, and he performs statistical analysis to understand the importance of other possible variables. One of the unique things about this book is Tajima’s use of statistical testing. Most in-depth country studies rely on qualitative analysis. His statistical analysis and his close examination of several local episodes of communal violence confirm his hypothesis that the key determinant of violence is a mismatch in formal and informal security institutions, which leads to communal violence during periods of transition. Villages closer to police posts were more accustomed to military intervention and therefore more dependent on the military to keep order. When the military’s power decreased toward the end of Suharto’s rule, and there was less willingness to use heavy-handed tactics to keep the peace, and when the regime fell and there was uncertainty over the military’s continued role in politics and internal security, villages that had developed informal mechanisms for containing communal violence were better able to deal with threats to communal order than were communities more reliant on a strong interventionist military. In places where there was this mismatch of institutions, we saw spikes in communal violence. Where formal security measures become weaker, it took time for informal institutions to realign themselves to this security vacuum, but once they did, communal violence abated.
The most interesting chapter is the one on small-scale conflicts in Lampung Province. Tajima looks at three cases: one where violence was averted, one where the lynching of two young thieves threatened to escalate into retaliatory violence between migrant and indigenous communities in two villages but was halted by local leaders, and one where violence spiraled before local elites could regain calm. He demonstrates how the mechanics of the interaction (matching and mismatching) of local informal institutions and the actions and proximity of security forces worked to address communal conflict. These examples demonstrate the critical role of effective local leaders at impacting communal relations.
While both of these works tell us something significant about transitions from authoritarian rule and the consolidation of democracy, there are areas that could have been improved. While the conceptual framework of Künkler and Stepan’s book works, had it been a single-authored monograph, one might have chosen different topics or focused differently than did some of the contributions here. For example, the section on legal and institutional reforms could have used greater depth and breadth in looking at problems of governance. Some of the chapters in Democracy & Islam are now dated, particularly after the 2014 presidential election.
Scholars agree on two significant challenges to further democratic consolidation. The first is high levels of corruption, even within the institutional bodies created to address the problem, which indicates significant weaknesses of governance more broadly (see Michael Buehler, “Of Geckos and Crocodiles: Evaluating Indonesia’s Corruption Eradication Efforts,” USINDO Brief, November 23, 2009); this is a point that deserves greater discussion by Lindsey and Butt. The second challenge is intolerance toward minorities and groups like the Ahmadiyya, or “liberal” civil society (points raised by Jones, Liddle and Mujani, and Magnis-Suseno and by Künkler and Stepan as well) (see Jeremy Menchik, Islam and Democracy in Indonesia: Tolerance without Liberalism, 2014). Künkler and Stepan’s work touches on all of these elements (elections, governance, and attitudes) within the framework of consolidation literature, yet their ultimate assessment is quite positive. Several issues discussed in the book have changed, something beyond the authors’ control. From 2013 to 2014, Freedom House downgraded Indonesia’s status from “free” to “partly free” due to intolerance, violence, and the passage of laws that increase oversight and monitoring of civil society groups.
The presidential election of (relative) outsider Joko Widodo in 2014 triggered a profoundly antidemocratic backlash by the losing coalition in the legislature to end the very system of local elections for local leaders that brought Jokowi to power in the first place. The push back from the losing coalition has raised new questions about the durability of some of the democratic reforms. Liddle and Mujani mention the possibility of threats to democracy coming from antidemocratic actors, and it turns out that this minor point was quite prophetic. They give former President Susilo BambangYudhoyono (SBY) credit for legal reforms and anticorruption efforts. Yet as Mietzner laid out in a talk in October, 2014, it was under Megawati that the anticorruption body was formed. Although SBY talked a good game about anticorruption efforts, it was under SBY that efforts were undermined and stymied. Likewise, credit should be given to Presidents Wahid and Megawati for implementing institutional reforms that resulted in decentralization of power, removing the military from politics, and instituting local elections.
Generally, this is a worthwhile collection of essays. Its contribution comes more in the breadth of topics covered than in the depth of any of the issues individually. The chapter notes and bibliographic references are extensive and useful to those who want more information on any given topic.
Tajima takes a methodological risk in his work: Area specialists are more accustomed to reading detailed monographs based on interviews and firsthand knowledge. He does this, but also includes statistical analysis to help consider the weight of different variables and to confirm the power of his explanatory variable, that the mismatch of political institutions leads to communal violence. This may give him added credibility among political scientists, but is of less use (perhaps) to Indonesia specialists. Tajima reviews the statistics in Chapter 5 and in a somewhat more detailed appendix. The explanation would have benefited from greater detail and clarity of some of the additional demographic, social, and economic data. For example, the appendix lays out alternative variables like ethnic and religious fractionalization and ethnic/religious clustering within districts and subdistricts. It would have been useful to have more information provided on what these variables mean and why they might matter but do not in terms of the composition of the villages and communities examined in the more detailed narrative.
Tajima’s overarching goal is to address why communal violence spikes during authoritarian breakdowns, and he does an excellent job answering this question. Like Jacques Bertrand’s 2008 article “Ethnic Conflicts in Indonesia: National Models, Critical Junctures and the Timing of Violence” (Journal of East Asian Studies 8 [no. 3, 2008]: 425), Tajima’s work accounts for both cross-temporal examples and local variation within Indonesia. And he helps provide a comparative framework for looking at similar episodes of communal violence in other countries.
The work would have benefited from a clear discussion of what is a “cause” of communal violence and what are structural/institutional factors that make communal violence likely to occur. By itself, institutional mismatch does not cause communal violence; one imagines that there were examples of institutional mismatch where violence did not occur. Historical circumstances and grievances, the role of local elites or outside provocateurs (elements to which Jones’s chapter in the edited volume gives more weight), and continuing dynamics of identity: These are the reasons people commit violence upon one another. The institutional framework helps determine if that violence escalates or not. Likewise, Tajima needed to examine more closely how in some cases of communal violence, police and military units were part of the violence, not just trying to suppress it. Here, too, the citations and bibliography are extensive and impressive. Tajima is clearly well read and deeply engaged in scholarly debates on transitions and communal violence.
The two works reviewed here are valuable contributions to help us understand the dangers and difficulties with transitions from authoritarian rule and consolidation of democracy.
