Shany Payes' study aims to investigate the political role of Palestinian nongovernmental organizations in Israel (PNGOs). As Payes illustrates, previous studies of contemporary PNGOs have portrayed the organizations either as holding no political significance or as revolutionary actors with the potential to change the political system of Israel. In her view, however, both schools of thought present in previous studies of PNGOs obscured the main focus of the organizations they purported to study: their struggle for equality through the mobilization of the underrepresented Palestinian citizens of Israel. Sadly, the structure of the book leaves the author's own views on and answers to her many research questions hidden in the text, impeding the reader's ability to identify her conclusions.
The chapters of the book that are directly based on Payes' fieldwork constitute the most compelling parts of the study. In these, the author discusses the evolution of individual organizations and their specific focus, aims, obstacles, and successes. She introduces the reader to the dilemmas of PNGOs that are caught between their community's needs for practical improvement and their confinement within the very discriminatory system they are trying to change. In chapter 3, Payes presents national PNGOs, defined as organizations operating nationwide to improve the predicament of the Palestinian minority. Because the state refused to accept organizations demanding “change in the status quo of state minority relations” as representatives of Palestinians in Israel (p. 110), organizations belonging to the first generation of PNGOs, established in the 1970s after the military government of Palestinian citizens was lifted in 1966, had little opportunity to influence the Israeli state system.
Learning from this experience, the second generation of organizations emerged in the 1980s and focused on working for change from within the system. For example, the Galilee Society: the Arab National Society for Health Research and Services focuses on technical rather than political projects and provides services that the state is required to provide to all citizens by law, but which it does not provide to its Palestinian citizens. Such organizations provide much needed services to some Palestinian citizens, but also alleviate the state of its responsibilities, thus helping to sustain the system of inequality. This paradox remains a central dilemma of PNGOs to this day: by working for equality and change from within the system, PNGOs ultimately prolong and validate the system that discriminates against them.
The dilemma is illustrated further by the activities of the legal advocacy organization Adalah: the Centre for Arab Minority Rights in Israel, which was established in 1996. Adalah chooses cases that represent first-time legal challenges on issues that are considered especially significant to the Palestinian minority. As Adalah's general director, Hassan Jabareen, explains, “Turning to legal procedures emphasizes the importance of citizenship and civil rights issues for defining state–minority relations” (p. 125). In contrast, Adalah's board member Raef Zureik offers a more critical view: “The Court is not a neutral institution, but an armour of the state, committed to laws that prefer the common good of Jews to that of Arabs” (p. 126).
In chapter 4 Payes looks at interactions between the state and geographically defined local organizations established in direct response to discrimination against Palestinians. The author convincingly argues that local organizations are significant because they empower their communities and involve them politically. However, she is less convincing in showing how these organizations exert impact beyond their locality and specific focus.
In the very opening of the book Payes writes that “as a national and ethnic indigenous minority in a state that is both Jewish and democratic, Palestinian citizens enjoy many of the same formal democratic rights as Jews” (p. 1). However, in the chapters that follow this claim, Payes describes multiple obstacles established by the Jewish state and its related institutions through legal, military, economic, and political means to discriminate against its Palestinian citizens. These obstacles clearly undermine the state's democratic claims, but Payes does not challenge the characterization of Israel as a democracy. Moreover, during her discussion of joint Jewish and Palestinian activism, the author argues that this cooperation is never able to rid itself of the existing power relations between Jews and Palestinians. Drawing on Gramsci, Payes concludes that Israeli civil society mirrors, rather than challenges, the power structure of this majority-controlled state system (p. 190). However, this conclusion is not directly related to Israel's self-identification as a democratic and Jewish state. Rather, Payes' conclusion appears to dilute her criticism by describing Israeli society as “divided,” instead of taking issue with the undemocratic discriminatory state system she has described in compelling details.
Overall the book would benefit from a reorganization that would bring the author's own research material to the forefront of her analysis, thus minimizing instances of repetition and saving the reader from flicking between pages to connect theory and practice. Nevertheless, based on an impressive number and variety of sources, this book provides readers with original and instructive material about the understudied predicament of the Palestinian citizens of Israel—a significant but often-neglected constituency in the broader Israeli–Palestinian conflict.
