Writing about family policy, especially in a comparative context, is an ambitious undertaking for two main reasons. Firstly, defining what or who counts as family and what family means can be difficult and different within and across countries. Secondly, defining and identifying family policy/policies is possibly even more challenging. Within the comparative literature, the most basic distinction is between explicit and implicit family policies (see Kamerman and Kahn, Reference Kamerman and Kahn1978; Gauthier, 1998, among others). Explicit family policies are those targeted directly at families, while implicit family policies are those that are not directly aimed at families but affect families nevertheless, e.g. education or housing. This distinction has been criticized by Wasoff and Dey (Reference Wasoff and Dey2000), who argue that implicit family policies encompass almost all policies, which somewhat defeats the point of an analytical category. The authors present three alternative approaches to analyzing family policy: firstly, to focus on its aims, whether those are to distribute resources, regulate behaviour or to create/modify procedures and structures; secondly, to focus on the origin of family policies, whether they are the outcome of rational or incremental choices, the reflection of cultural or elite preference, of institutional structures and processes or the competition between groups; thirdly, by locating them within the main analytical categories of traditional social policy analysis, namely needs, problems and rights of families. In contrast, Millar and Haux (Reference Millar, Haux, Alcock, May and Wright2012) propose that family policy can be captured by its activity such as the legal regulation of family behaviour, support for family income and provision of services for families.
Robila's compilation adopts the explicit/implicit dichotomy as its analytical framework. The editor draws on the work by Bogenschneider (Reference Bogenschneider2006) who uses this dichotomy as part of a broader argument for the implementation of a family impact assessment. In other words, arguing that policies need to be tested for their effect on families before being designed and implemented (see also the recent announcement of a ‘family-friendly test’ by the current coalition government – DWP, 2014). In this context, both the dichotomy and a focus on evidence-based policy making seem relevant. However, Robila does not develop the dichotomy further into a more comprehensive analytical framework, e.g. by integrating any of the analytical concepts mentioned above, nor does she adjust it to the countries included in the compilation. Instead, the twenty-nine chapters contain an ‘analysis of the impact of historical, cultural and socioeconomic context on families and family policy development . . . a description of family characteristics and the state of research on families as background for evidence based policy development’ (p. 4). This specification is very ambitious and difficult to do justice to within the restricted word limits of individual chapters. This is especially true given the diversity of the countries covered, some of which are unlikely to have comprehensive statistics about family composition, while others can draw on highly sophisticated evaluations of individual policies.
In terms of policy areas, the chapters tend to cover family policies around marriage, child rearing, work–life balance and supporting families at risk (ibid.). The discussion of the policy areas works well across the chapters and here the compendium comes into its own. I enjoyed reading those chapters and learnt a lot about aspects of family policy in countries I was not familiar with. Having said that, I would have expected to see key authors and resources more clearly cited in all of the chapters. Many of the chapters are not written by established experts in the field, and while this does not take away from the quality of the individual chapters, it would be useful for readers to get a sense of the key sources and texts on family policy in the respective countries if they want to find out more about it.
The book also covers a wide range of continents and countries as the title suggests. The chapters are grouped geographically and cover the following countries: Africa (Sierra Leone, Kenya, Botswana and South Africa), Europe (Norway, Sweden, Iceland, Ireland, Germany, Italy, Spain, Portugal, Moldova, Russia and Turkey), Asia (China, Taiwan, India, South Korea and Japan), South America (Colombia, Ecuador and Brazil), as well as Australia, the US, Canada and Mexico. Neither the order nor the range of countries suggests a particular analytical framework. Instead, it is an interesting mix of countries one would expect to see included in a compilation such as this and includes countries, which many readers may know less about.
Finally, Robila's book is the first truly global compilation of family policies covering both the economic South and North. This makes it both an achievement for the editor and a good resource for scholars from all different countries wanting to learn more about the family policies and their context in a whole range of different countries. Moreover, one can hope that in putting this compilation together the foundations, in terms of knowledge and networks, for a more analytical approach to comparing family policies across the globe have been laid. Such a result could prove to be truly exciting.
