‘The seat between Dorothy Sayers and Jane Austen’, I used to joke with fellow undergraduate English majors, ‘should be the most coveted seat at the Heavenly Banquet’. I have since amended this fanciful declaration: that coveted seat should instead be located exactly five feet behind Austen and Sayers, whose tête-à-tête could proceed unimpeded by contributions from their devotees. Eavesdropping would be pleasure enough. Reading In Search of the Common Good often reminded me of that whimsical image – a delightfully intelligent conversation which it is a pleasure to overhear. This volume appeals precisely because it offers readers the chance to eavesdrop on the contributors’ three-year conversation about the relationship between Christian theology and the common good.
That it is a conversation may, of course, make it less interesting for some readers. There is no sustained argument, no survey of the state of the question, no forced harmonisation of incongruous voices (the usual task of an editor's introduction). The contributors are drawn from a variety of disciplines and thus approach the question from different angles and with different intellectual tools. Yet the articles are clearly contributions to a conversation rather than (merely) a collection of disparate opinions: the authors reference each other's work, making clear not only their agreements and disagreements but also how they've learned from each other.
Structurally, the book emphasises disciplinary approaches: biblical and historical approaches comprise the first two sections, while the second two sections offer synthetic proposals and critiques. Patrick Miller, Jacqueline Lapsley and Victor Paul Furnish survey biblical texts (Deuteronomy, Jonah and the Pauline corpus, respectively), teasing out the moral and political obligations stated or implied in each text. Jean Porter details Thomas' deployment of the common good, while Dennis McCann traces the development of the concept as a response to modernity in nineteenth- and twentieth-century Catholic social teaching. The work of Thomist John Courtney Murray helps Robin Lovin locate a constructive theological conversation about the common good within the context of Rawlsian liberalism.
Eric Mount, Cheryl Kirk-Duggan and Josiah Young draw on cultural theory, literature and theology, arguing that the standard construction of the common good is overly dependent on authoritarian assumptions about both what is ‘common’ and what is ‘good’. Contrasting the history of American judicial decisions regarding Native American nations with the history of a certain Lakota convert to Roman Catholicism, Milner Ball suggests that ‘translation’ is a profitable metaphor for religious dialogue (itself a common good) and necessary to avoid religious imperialism. James Skillen is similarly wary of imperialistic visions of the common good; he proposes that protecting what William Cavanaugh calls ‘complex space’ is the main task of political society. Cavanaugh laments both the loss of this complex space and the myth of the nation-state as protector of the common good. Max Stackhouse and Robert Jenson share a vision of the common good as eschatological, though the two emphasise different problematics. Stackhouse is interested in the way globalisation has intensified the challenge to maintain diversity within a commitment to the common good; Jenson underscores the analogical distance between temporal common goods and the ultimate common good that is the divine life.
The conversation includes some noteworthy convergences. The common good is seen as a necessarily eschatological concept. Miller finds an anticipation of the divine kingdom in the Deuteronomic covenant material; McCann discerns in Catholic social teaching a (sometimes oblique) recognition of the transcendence of the common good; Mount suggests that ‘isms’ become idolatries when advanced as an equivalent to the divine kingdom; Young, following Moltmann, insists that the common good of the promised kingdom is more perfectly common and more perfectly good than Aristotle's version; Cavanaugh and Jenson point to God as the ultimate common good. There is a shared recognition of the provisional nature of all human efforts to conceive and enact the common good, even if there is sharp disagreement about the degree to which this recognition relativises one's commitment to particular states, institutions or ideologies.
The contributors also share a sense of what the common good isn't: sectarian withdrawal or theocratic imperialism. In many of the articles, George W. Bush (whose religious language is assumed to legitimate his militaristic and economic imperialism) plays Scylla to Christian pacifists’ Charybdis – twin dangers from which moderating distance must be maintained or the dogmatic dyad to which a liberating third alternative must be posed. If there is an unsatisfying element to this collection, it is this common refusal to engage with nuanced accounts of Christian pacifism. John Howard Yoder, Stanley Hauerwas and Richard Hays are clearly conversation partners in absentia, and their work was given less careful attention than it could have been.
The most important convergence, however, is the dominant one: that public, theologically minded conversation about the common good must continue. This volume is a delightful invitation not only to overhear the conversation which has already taken place, but to join it.
