This volume commemorates the 30th anniversary of the Intergovernmental Committee for Promoting the Return of Cultural Property to its Countries of Origin or its Restitution in the Case of Illicit Appropriation. The idea was proposed and financed by Korea and was compiled and published in a very short space of time.
Condensed extracts of previous publications have been drawn together to provide diverse perspectives that alternately challenge, endorse, and engage the reader. Content has been derived from many varied sources including texts of speeches, transcripts from meetings and workshops, newspaper and journal articles, web sites, legal instruments, and books.
The volume is divided into five parts. Lyndel Prott's editorial comments ably orient the reader and serve to interlink the rich array of material on offer.
Part 1 presents The History of Return of Cultural Objects and explores the dispossession and evolution of thinking that have led to the development of international legal instruments driven in particular by World Wars I and II and by decolonization in the 1960s but with substantial reference to Quatremère de Quincy in the eighteenth century through to the United Nations (UN) Security Council Resolution 1483 relating to Iraq in 2003 and the International Law Association Principles for Cooperation in the Mutual Protection and Transfer of Cultural Material adopted in 2006. This gives a flavor of the breadth of the coverage that infuses the entire volume. Regardless of the reader's expertise in issues of repatriation and restitution, much that is unfamiliar will still be encountered.
Part 2 is concerned with Philosophy and Ethics. Here Elazar Barkan's view of restitution as serving to amend historical injustices butts up against Kwame Anthony Appiah's advocacy of greater sharing of cultural heritage in the interest of a shared cosmopolitan outlook. Stephan Turner's paper neatly deconstructs the binary opposition of internationalism (cast in a positive light) versus nationalism (spun pejoratively), arguing that the two approaches to heritage are intertwined. The arguments for and against universal museums are also rehearsed. However, Kavita Singh's contribution, a speech she gave at the Salzburg Global Seminar, diverges from the usual refrain, and argues that the encyclopedic museum should be regarded as an artifact of history in its own right, acknowledging the imperialistic context of its formation. This is a thoughtful and elegant paper that needs to be read to be savored and fully appreciated. The section concludes with excerpts from the 2000 Museums and Galleries publication by Jane Leggett entitled Restitution and Repatriation: Guidelines for Good Practice. The checklist that serves to sum up the individual sections is extremely useful and would have been worth including here as well.
Part 3 addresses Repatriation in Different Contexts and is peppered with examples, some that have been resolved and many that continue to be disputed. In an effort to provide structure and manage the information, it has been subdivided into seven somewhat (as acknowledged by Prott) more discrete sections.
The first of these, Cultural Objects Displaced during War and Hostilities or Occupation, focuses largely on the Second World War and its aftermath. It includes Nazi-looted art, Wojciech Kowalski on the Russian–German debate concerning restitution elaborating on the 1997 Federal Law on Cultural Values Removed to the USSR as a Result of the Second World War and Located in the Territory of the Russian Federation, and concludes with the less well-known issue of Japanese swords, large numbers of which were taken after the end of the war. Toshiyuki Kono's article states that “the Japanese Government filed a petition for inquiry and return of these missing swords” in September 1948 (p. 178). Thus far, only one of these swords has been returned.
Colonial Contexts are discussed in the second section, which begins with a 1979 ICOM study to document losses in Bangladesh, Mali, and Western Samoa. Extracts from Ana Vrdoljak's 2006 book are knitted together seamlessly, producing a compelling argument for changes in international law to facilitate restitution of cultural objects to the dispossessed indigenous peoples of the world.
It is an unfortunate fact that collecting and the trade in cultural objects have often impacted destructively on sites. Dismembered Items, the third section, tackles some of the issues and outcomes by featuring the restitution and restoration of a New Zealand Maori carved meeting house, a brief mention of the prolonged campaign to recover the Parthenon Marbles (not rehearsed in detail here but supported for the reader by a series of references), a Mayan temple façade where the eventual discovery of provenience provided evidence crucial for understanding the past, and the Casenoves frescoes from France, a classic example of the immovable made movable and marketable. The text of the Council of Europe Recommendation No. R (98) 4 on Measures to Promote the Integrated Conservation of Historic Complexes Composed of Immovable and Movable Property provides a useful introduction to these cases.
Sacred Objects, the fourth section, consists predominantly of a paper by Patrick O'Keefe that explores the particular difficulties that obtain in repatriating such material. Examples to illustrate his points range from the relics of saints to Zuni war gods. He presents an extremely persuasive argument for repatriation as a human right. The return of a Ghost Dance shirt from Kelvingrove Museum in Glasgow to the Lakota Sioux stands alone here as a case study.
Successful collaborative ventures between the dispossessed and museums expose the potential benefits that such engagement offers in the fifth section, Indigenous Knowledge. John Stanton's impressive paper offers invaluable insights into the sensitivity required to help negotiate traumatic histories, in this case the suppression of Aboriginal culture by separation of children from their families.
Two-thirds of the sixth section, Human Remains, consists of U.S. and U.K. legislation and guidelines for their care in museums. This indicates that the progress made in the return of such material, although still contested, is much more widely accepted. The selected case studies of the return of Inakayal to Patagonia and Saartjie Baartman to South Africa demonstrate how important restitution can be in helping to heal harrowing pasts and achieve greater mutual understanding.
The seventh and final section concerns and is aptly titled Archives. The absence of any form of agreement for restitution of this kind of material, elucidated by Patricia Kennedy Grimsted, stands in stark contrast to the previous section on human remains. The case study of the Korean archives seized by French naval forces in a punitive raid in the nineteenth century brings together conflict, colonial attitudes, and the historical record.
Part 4, Legal Issues, focuses on problems that impede recovery of cultural objects. In addition to conflict of law regarding the relative protection of the good faith purchaser and the victim of theft, statutes of limitation and a discussion of the 1995 UNIDROIT Convention intended to ameliorate these difficulties, an excellent paper by Marie Cornu rehearses French legislation, its definitions of heritage used to identify what is French, and a review of possible means to resolve disputes. The Korean archives are discussed in this context, which augments the paper in the Archives section of the previous chapter. In one case study for this section that is concerned with archaeological material, Patty Gerstenblith reflects on the significance of the conviction under the National Stolen Property Act, of U.S. antiquities dealer, Frederick Schultz, for handling stolen Egyptian artifacts and suggests that future potential claimant states should ensure that national patrimony laws in particular are drafted clearly to maximize chances of success. Extracts from the UN Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples, and Principles and Guidelines for the Protection of the Heritage of Indigenous Peoples are also usefully included.
Part 5, Procedures for Requests, provides consideration of processes with a valuable varied selection of skillfully scrutinized case studies. Norman Palmer's well-defined paper evaluates the relative merits of litigation, arbitration, and mediation in dispute resolution. Folarin Shyllon's stimulating contribution critiques the recovery of objects by African states suggesting that a focus on losses while colonized has led to inattention to more recent depredation that threatens knowledge of the past. He also considers options for recovering cultural objects and advocates ratification of the 1995 UNIDROIT Convention. Scrutiny of the case studies offers prior practical experience that should prove useful to those contemplating the initiation of some form of action for the return of a cultural object.
Although this is not a volume that invites reading cover-to-cover, it is much more than a reference book to facilitate locating particular case studies (although I have used it this way). Rather, I have found it richly rewarding because of the number and caliber of the lengthier entries that are less well known. I thus urge readers to browse and make such discoveries for themselves. Color images enliven the text as well. My particular engagement in this area is the ongoing looting and resultant loss of cultural heritage. Stemming this is essential before the damage to sites and monuments occurs. Claims for recovery can only be made after the fact of the destruction but they are essential in deterring possible recipients of this material. Understanding the impact of such losses is a central part of this effort and is communicated forcefully here. The contributions offer vast coverage both geographically and chronologically. There is much of value for anyone interested in cultural heritage, its uses and abuses and meaning for humanity.
