Although the importance of tribal organization for medieval Islamic societies is a truism, attempts to explore this more closely have led to scholarly disputes concerning its patterns, impact on state conduct, and the overlapping of tribalism and nomadism. These issues received an impetus in the 1980s and 1990s, when Ernest Gellner, Patricia Crone, and others started to include contemporary anthropological perspectives on tribe and state in historical research. Particular attention was given to the formative period of Islam and therein to the problem of the binary opposition between the Qays and the Yaman confederations. Since then, the debate has somewhat ebbed away. The doctoral thesis of the now Zurich-based Orientalist Eva Orthmann, Tribe and Power: The Arab Tribes in the 2nd and 3rd Centuries of the Hijra, submitted to the University of Halle, Germany, adds fresh vigor to the discussion of this conflict and Islamic tribal affairs in general. By shifting the focus away from the earliest period of Islam, her book is the first extensive study to reconstruct tribalism in early

Abbasid times.
The author argues that confederations had much less practical influence on tribal activities than is suggested by the sources at hand, with the consequence that emphasis on the Qays versus Yaman polarity is a simplistic misrepresentation. Instead, she undertakes the reassessment of the sources so as to conceive the complexity and the real-life activities of the tribes.
Although the author addresses a specific period of history (little material refers to times posterior to al-Ma

mun), she starts from a source-critical analysis (ch. B): Arab genealogists, lexicographers, historians, and geographers present stereotypical views of tribal action which contain only a very modest amount of socioeconomic data; moreover, information is unevenly distributed over time and space. Because these shortcomings forbid focusing strictly on diachronic history, she adopts instead a systematic approach in that she combines anthropological positions with historical hermeneutics and literary criticism. As accounts of political crisis and revolt provide the bulk of the documentation, they become anchor points for the discussion (among these, the revolts of al-Nafs al-Zakiyya in 762-63 and Abu al-Haidham al-Murri in 792-93 figure most prominently).
In the run of the sociogeographical analysis (ch. C), Orthmann demonstrates that tribal groups were embedded in regions with an urban center like the ghūṭa of Damascus and the ḥawf of Mosul (or, less significantly in the countryside) in very dissimilar ways. Further variations derive from their plural economic, that is, occupational, activities as nomads, peasants, great land owners, or military personnel (ch. D). By following up exemplary events, Orthmann quickly makes clear that the Qays–Yaman conflict formed an ideology that was not as effective by far in local practice as the sources suggest. This also shows that the alleged weakening of tribal ideology by the

Abbasid revolution does not signify a major turn in either intertribal or tribe–state relations. As the book's professed core subject is largely settled at this early stage, Orthmann expands the discussion to the whole of tribal phenomena in an almost encyclopedic way (ch. E). On the one hand, the importance of structural elements like kinship,

aṣabīyya (both tribal esprit de corps and intertribal hostility), alliance, and blood feud is validated in a plethora of cases. On the other hand, the genealogical system and tribal nomenclature are of limited relevance as optional arguments, whereas the economic self-interest of tribal groups and leaders within local contexts is found predominant throughout. When finally tribe and state get examined (ch. F), attention to the lesser tribal groupings pays off in that their flexibility to use or to ignore tribal patterns becomes evident during the whole period of study. Tribal affiliation is welcome as one potential lever to obtain power, status, subsidies, or booty, and weakness of the central government regularly triggers the surfacing of tribes as political actors. However, apart from this logic, tribal activities vis-à-vis states and rulers generally lack a common strategic denominator, and vice versa.
Orthmann concludes convincingly that the tribal system, including the idiomatic Qays–Yaman opposition, persisted in both urban and rural contexts until the early 9th century A.D. without suffering a major blow from the rise of the

Abbasids. At the same time, tribal affiliation alone could not be held responsible for collective action when it would have intersected with more powerful forces such as socioeconomic or territorial interests. Consequently, rejecting Crone's view, Orthmann states that behind tribal names there were genuine tribal organizations, not just military contingents or some kind of factions seeking state positions. Skepticism is justified insofar as tribes were indeed perceived by members and outsiders as genealogical groups, but, in fact, they functioned as political associations along the lines of specific group interests.
Although the main line of argument is characterized by admirable consideration and methodical clarity, a few points stand out. The author makes clear in the beginning that the imprecision and overlapping of the terms

arab, a

rāb, and bādiya must not mislead the observer to identify tribalism with nomadism, yet she does not stay the course but mixes up empirical findings on Bedouin groups with statements on tribes in general (e.g., with regard to the refusal of tax payment). In such places the so-called inductive approach turns out to be deductive. Another inconsistency is due to the all too straightforward treatment of the caliphal houses as tribes (e.g., in the sections on kinship), as if monarchical dynasties were not very special cases. Finally, some deliberation on the notion of power would have been helpful. Speaking of the effectiveness of tribal structures is hardly a substitute.
Moreover, presenting the evidence by repeated leaps in time and space results in a partly cumbersome reading because it necessitates many arguments of (im)probability and presumptive generalizations on the author's side before she can sum up a paragraph. For this we are fully rewarded by an impressive series of results of what is an authentic account of tribal action. Among these accounts are valuable notes on the limits of historical reconstruction, for example, with regard to the overall spatial distribution of the tribes. In this way she also contributes to the history of medieval Arabic historiography by positioning herself between the two extremes: those historians who widely trust the sources and those treating them with utter skepticism.
Through her careful and thorough analysis of the available sources, Orthmann has exhausted the material on early Islamic tribes for some time to come. She has set new parameters for further research in this particular period and provided a stimulus for Orientalists, historical anthropologists, and historical sociologists who are concerned with the subsequent periods. Systematic arrangement of the material, a clear structure, a name index, and an elaborate two-tiered subject index make this volume an indispensable and easy to use vademecum for studies in medieval Islamic tribalism, societal organization, and power relations.
