Over the past two decades, queer and trans studies’ focus has increasingly been on the rise of neoliberal economies, nationalist regimes, racial capitalism, and how these structures are predicated on the exclusion of queerness; this scholarship is also enriched by work on queer survival tactics, resistance, and pleasures that thrive within heteronormative cultural spaces. Kareem Khubchandani's Ishtyle: Accenting Gay Indian Nightlife is a compelling contribution to this latter body of work. Khubchandani's research follows gay South Asian men—from both the diaspora and urban India—as they navigate nightlife in the pursuit of romance, sex, pleasure, and belonging. Based on fieldwork conducted primarily in Chicago and Bangalore, the book explores how queer nightlife spaces are dense affective sites that offer opportunities for the performance of style, dance, and expressions deemed effeminate, uncool, or crass within the Westernized and neoliberal imaginaries of gay male worlds.
Khubchandani proposes “ishtyle,” or accented style, as an analytic to capture these performances. A South Asian colloquialism for “style,” ishtyle is sometimes aspirational style, sometimes friendly mockery of assumed pretensions. Ishtyle is exemplified in choreography, gestures, expressions, and the collective labor of participation in dance and spectatorship at the nightclub. For Khubchandani, ishtyle is “a useful rubric to consider performances of cultural difference across geopolitical scales while also demonstrating the historically politicized nature of Indian accents and habitus” (5). By narrating their interlocutors’ ishtyle as political and liberatory acts of queerness and identity, Khubchandani foregrounds the terrain of nightlife over other political sites of study, like labor, migration, or the law. In particular, the book focuses on migrant, middle- or upper-middle-class professionals whose labor is well-compensated but whose creative and sexual lives are regulated within the homonormative and Westernized social spaces they frequent. Khubchandani reads the spontaneous cultural work of ishtyle performances as fleeting but powerful communal avenues where identity is affirmed.
Part I of Ishtyle is set in Bangalore, a major urban center in south India. Here, Khubchandani discusses the narratives and anxieties that coalesce around the figure of the “techie,” an employee in one of the city's various multinational corporations and a salient symbol of modernity and aspiration. Khubchandani's interlocutors are primarily drawn from this new labor class. The focus in these chapters is on how techies are interpellated within nightlife as modern, cosmopolitan subjects through performative scripts that favor Western music and dance forms and privilege light-skinned, English-speaking, upper-caste bodies as desirable and deserving. Khubchandani also explores the popular positioning of Bangalore as “Pub City” or “India's ‘Silicon Valley’” and the contradictory “logics of sexual propriety” (59) and moral policing that commonly manifest in the forms of curfews and curbs on nightlife and dance bars. This discursive regulation queers not just gay men, but often their dance itself, which is seen as too feminine, too local, or too disruptive within the heavily regulated cultural space of the contemporary Bangalore nightclub.
In Part II, the author looks to the gay male South Asian diaspora in Chicago for their discussion of race and desire. An important site for observation is the Jai Ho! party, a recurring event for queer South Asians in Chicago coorganized by Khubchandani. The author draws on Orientalist tropes and contemporary discourses on model minorities to show how race and desire work together to inform romance, sex, rejection, fetish, and connection among their interlocutors. Khubchandani argues that queer South Asians, despite their vaunted status as skilled workers in the United States, have social and sexual identities enmeshed in older histories of colonialism and more recent “militarized logics” (99). These ways of knowing constrain a fuller expression of the self but also are often the only conditions through which the gay brown body is legible in the West. Within these rigged dynamics, the author notes the crucial “capacity for ishtyle to unsettle whiteness . . . as well as ishtyle's ability to emplace migrant subjects” (111).
In Part III, Khubchandani explores popular filmic and musical worlds in urban India through which their interlocutors come to see and express themselves. In the part's first chapter (the strongest in the book), Khubchandani notes that the filmi (melodramatic or excessive) features of popular Bollywood cinema (like the song-and-dance performances or dramatic dialogue) are queer events on which their interlocutors often draw in the articulation and enactment of their own femininity and queer expression. Khubchandani focuses on their interlocutors’ attachments to two particular Bollywood divas, Madhuri Dixit and Sridevi, to show how their onscreen dances “become repositories of affect, performatives that activate individual and collective memory on the club dance floor, facilitating alternative forms of sociality, or even of being with oneself” (137). In the second chapter of Part III, Khubchandani discusses imbrications of caste, class, and sexuality through the example of Koothnytz, a series of parties held in Bangalore that use popular dappankoothu music—fast-paced songs with distinctive drumming rhythms—in their music repertoires. Khubchandani suggests that the “expansive sonic landscape” (174) of Koothnytz disrupts the elite, caste-coded space of Bangalorean nightclubs in productive ways by allowing exciting vernacular choreographies and engagements in urban nightlife.
Although the registers of pleasure and aesthetics are useful here, ishtyle as an analytic does not always work. It is too vaguely defined and can seemingly be applied to anything; its very definition as accented style means that the author considers ishtyle expressions as supplement, slippage, or ephemera, and not as absolute ways of knowing and being. There is also a troubling elision of caste throughout, which the last chapter does not fully address. Ishtyle is invoked as a uniform lens for understanding interlocutors’ narratives, but the migrant professional groups on which Khubchandani focuses are not homogeneous. Although Khubchandani shows how race and power work in the nightclub, they are less attentive to how caste informs cultural and embodied knowledges. A more rigorous engagement with caste privilege would strengthen the author's insights into the redemptive possibilities of performance. On the whole, however, Ishtyle is an absorbing and deftly written analysis of brown gay worlds and an important addition to previous scholarship on South Asian and queer cultural studies.
