No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 01 September 2004
This volume consists of 13 papers presented at a Japan Center for Economic Research-National Bureau of Economic Research joint conference on labor markets and firm benefit policies in Japan and the United States, held in January 2000. The strength of the volume is the rigor and quality of the individual papers, which contain interesting empirical findings about contemporary employment, health, and retirement issues. However, nearly all of the papers are devoid of comparative analysis of the similarities and differences between Japan and the United States. Also, the volume lacks connective material (e.g., discussant comments) that might help readers integrate the wide range of topics covered here. Helpful but not sufficient in this regard are an introduction by David Wise that summarizes the papers and a lead paper by Richard Freeman on the relative macroeconomic performance of Japan, the United States, and other advanced economies.
There are three groups of papers. The first group focuses on employment practices in Japan. It includes a pair of papers by Takao Kato and by Hiroyuki Chuma that discuss the persistence of consultative and relatively egalitarian activities within Japanese firms, such as labor-management committees and less formal practices linking engineers to production workers (in the machine-tool industry). Another pair of papers includes Yuji Genda's study of youth unemployment and Yoshifumi Nakata and Ryoji Takehiro's analysis of employment adjustment in large firms. Although Genda attributes youth unemployment to laws protecting workers from economic dismissal, Nakata and Takehiro show that large-scale employment adjustment is quite common in Japan, although part of this adjustment occurs via hours worked.
The second group of papers is on the United States, and its focus is limited to the interplay between public and private provision of health and retirement insurance. Matthew Eichner, Mark McClellan, and David Wise use simulation analysis to show that tax-free medical savings accounts, perhaps administered by employers, could be a feasible way of providing “catastrophic” health insurance. David Cutler discusses private supplements to public health insurance, as in the Medicare program, and finds that supplemental policies often but not always raise public costs through moral hazard effects. There is an additional paper on how private pension-plan provisions affect retirement decisions.
The final group consists of five papers on health and other benefit programs in Japan. Seiritsu Ogura and Takehiko Hagino ask why drug prices are so high in Japan and blame poorly designed government regulations for controlling prices, which create incentives for pharmaceutical companies to switch to new and more costly drugs. Tadashi Yamada and Tetsuji Yamada confirm the common wisdom that health checkups, while costly in the short-term, reduce long-term hospitalization costs in Japan. These papers, like those preceding them, cry out for comparative analysis: How different is drug regulation in Japan and the United States? What, if anything, can the Japanese learn from the United States with respect to health checkups and Americans from Japan with respect to the treatment of catastrophic health problems?
Two other papers discuss more general aspects of benefit provision in Japan. Yukiko Abe focuses on the problems of female part-time workers, a group whose size has expanded rapidly in recent years in Japan. Although Japan has universal pension and health insurance, how one receives benefits and who pays for them are related to employment status. Low-income married women do not pay social security tax if their earnings are below threshold but if earnings rise above threshold (yet remain low compared to the husband's earnings), tax rates increase considerably without a commensurate rise in benefits. Nevertheless, social-insurance participation by female part-timers rose in the early 1990s. Fumio Ohtake examines the relationship between authorized time-off (holidays and vacations, sick leaves) and unauthorized absenteeism. Ohtake uses an efficiency-wage framework to explain why workers represented by unions will feel less threatened by dismissal and hence are more likely to be absent from work. The effect is strongest for very large firms, whereas smaller nonunion firms have higher absenteeism rates and total days lost than their unionized counterparts.
Finally, Toshiaki Tachibanaki summarizes his research on the interplay between public and private welfare provision in Japan. Social insurance in Japan is funded through indirect (payroll taxes) and direct (fringe benefit) employer provision. Tachibanaki speculates on the possibility that Japanese firms in the future will pay less to support public insurance programs. and will transform nonstatutory fringe benefits to wage payments. As Tachibanaki notes, Japan and the United States have in common relatively low rates of public social expenditure counterbalanced by relatively high rates of private provision by employers. One wishes that this insight had been more systematically pursued throughout this volume, which uncovers many within-country consequences of a “mixed” approach to benefit provision but misses an opportunity to learn from a “between-country” framework.