We might imagine, given the prevalence of audio-visual media in our lives, the growing numbers of people who identify as Latino/a in the United States, and the high rates of media consumption among those groups of people, that Latino/a media studies would be a well-trodden field. But it is not, and this volume is a welcome intervention, bound to open up conversations about media access, politics, and circulation from a number of different perspectives. Editors Arlene Dávila and Yeidy Rivero have helped shape the field with their own research, and here they have assembled a collection of political scientists, journalists, literary scholars, anthropologists, media studies and radio and television producers. The volume thus eschews a tightly controlled shared methodological or theoretical perspective in favour of a wide-ranging set of approaches and topics. This might have led to the kind of ‘dog's breakfast’ outcome that can plague edited collections. But it did not. Instead, the book manages its diversity with grace, and even as the articles head off in different directions they do share a politics of cultural critique and an underlying demand for greater equity across mediascapes in the United States. Ideally, it would have been fascinating to see a more explicit discussion of how the different approaches do or do not work together, and some more attention to historical as well as materialist perspectives, but this is only a wish inspired by the strength of the volume as a whole.
Divided into three thematic sections entitled ‘Production’, ‘Circulation, Distribution, Policy’ and ‘Cultural Politics’, the idea is to move away from content analysis, which has received much more attention, towards research that embeds media in political economy, keeping a close eye on the ways that they are part of capitalist structures and their concomitant social relations and cultural hegemonies. The question of ownership of television stations receives nuanced attention from authors such as Juan Piñon and Christopher Joseph Westgate, who explore the increasing transnationalisation of ownership of media companies as well as the linguistic politics in which they engage. Frances Negrón-Muntaner shares some of her data from her ambitious research that tracks the presence of Latino/as, both in quantity and quality, in the US media. Together these essays can suggest a contradiction: Latino/a media is huge business, but marginalisation of Latino/as in the media is more often than not the norm. In some ways, the entire volume rests on this paradox. Other essays take on this conundrum to a greater or lesser degree; such as Mari Castañeda's article on the ways that neoliberalism has favoured commercialism over community radio, even as market researchers profoundly misunderstand Latino/a audiences.
Indeed, one fascinating, and recurrent theme is the very difficulty of defining a term like ‘Latino/a media’. Marketers, audience researchers, and station owners all scramble to make sense of different generations, different countries of origin, different relationships to both Spanish and English, and a range of racial identifications. As many articles, such as the ones by Yeidy Rivero and Dolores Inés Casillas suggest, categories of latinidad fall apart very quickly as soon as they are scrutinised. Heterogeneity reigns, while advertisers and others do what they can to fit very different kinds of people into groups that they can sell things to. Other essays, such as Deborah Vargas’ chapter about Jenni Rivera, María Elena Cepeda's contribution on Los Tigres del Norte and Calle 13, and Héctor Amaya's work on narcocorridos take a different approach, offering arguments about how media, and in this particular case music, can be a shared point of identity, particularly if, as in these examples, it is created and circulates in transnational spaces defined by structures of feeling such as the edgy ambiguities expressed by narcotraficantes or Jenni Rivera. Further exploring the ways media interact with claims about identity is Cristina Beltrán's fascinating study of the ways that some undocumented young people have taken up the discourses of queerness and ‘coming out’ in more ways than one, and made use of the media as a primary political tool.
A final text, a transcription of a talk given by journalist Juan González, offers a historical perspective that the volume might have addressed more directly. González offers a long-term understanding of the changing boundaries between entertainment and news media, the role of technology and importantly, the ways that democratisation and inclusivity in the media have shifted over time. This essay brings the volume to a close and illuminates the stakes of all the contributions in its elegant survey of US media history. This rich collection demonstrates the best kind of interdisciplinary exchanges that media studies makes possible. The hope is that it generates many more in the near future.
