The book explores the relationship between science policy and dictatorship in the twentieth century by focusing on three countries, Argentina, Italy and Spain, which have not hitherto received much attention by scholars, who mostly focused on Nazi Germany and the Soviet Union. The editors claim that the three countries are considered part of a wide geographical region and that science policy is meant as governing both intervention and the involvement of science and scientists in government. A comparison between three countries whose history is connected by transcultural encounters is definitely interesting. Alas, the editors do not try to establish any criterion for a comparative history of the relationship between science and dictatorship in these countries. They recall that the various dimensions of the international context of the papers in the collection are Fascist Italian imperialism, the Second World War, international exile, the Cold War, international nuclear policies and the questioning of Northern science from an anti-colonialist Argentinian perspective. Any of these elements would have needed more discussion and some of them could have served as units of comparison. All three countries, for instance, experienced scientific exile, but the phenomenon differed from country to country and there were historical crossovers. Spain also experienced the so-called inner exile. Both Italy and Spain experienced autarky. However, it was deployed in Italy as a consequence of the international sanctions after the Italo-Ethiopian War, which prevented the country from securing certain products in the world market, whereas it was an ideological foundation of Francoism until the late 1950s, when it was given up because the country was going bankrupt.
The book consists of nine essays, five of them focusing on Spain, two on Italy and two on Argentina, plus a short preface, an introductory essay and an appendix. Amparo Gómez's contribution reviews science policy in Spain from the last decades of the nineteenth century to the Civil War. It focuses on the role of the JAE, Junta para la Ampliación de Estudios e Investigaciones Científicas (Board for Advanced Studies and Scientific Research), an institution mainly devoted to the promotion of research by means of fellowships to study abroad. Gómez highlights personal connections as well as political contrasts between liberals and conservatives in the allocation of resources. The stories of Republican scientists and institutions from the Civil War to the end of Francoism is the topic of Francisco A. González Redondo's contribution, while the history of Spain in CERN is that of Xavier Roqué’s. The latter, convincingly, argues that Spain withdrew from CERN in 1969 not because the costs of its participation were not affordable, but because of a lack of understanding that the benefits for the country would not be in the short-term ‘just-return’ policy but in the medium-term integration of the Spanish high-energy physics community within the broader European research context. Antonio Fco. Canales interprets the history of the Spanish Higher Council for Scientific Research (CSIC) as a reactionary dystopic project aiming at restoring a Catholic and nationalist imperial Spanish science. Rafael Huertas analyses the stories of Republican scientists under Francoism and of the different strategies they deployed to survive in a hostile environment. Roberto Maiocchi's article assesses the role played by the Italian National Research Council (CNR) researchers in searching for synthetic substitutes for commodities that could no longer be imported after 1935. Drawing on a previously published book in Italian, Maiocchi explains that the ambitious project could not be successful, although it was under autarky that crucial projects such as the future Nobel Prize-winner Giulio Natta's research on synthetic rubber supported by the IRI (Istituto per la Ricostruzione Industriale – Institute for Industrial Reconstruction, the state institution created by Mussolini to support Italian industries after the 1929 economic crisis) and Pirelli were started. Jean-Guy Prevost argues that Corrado Gini's struggle against inferential methods of ‘Anglo-Saxon’ statistics was grounded in professional rivalries and the regime agenda, rather than in theoretical concerns for Bayesianism shared by his pupil Bruno De Finetti. Of the two chapters on Argentina, Diana Maffia focuses on the persecution of scientists during the Jorge Rafael Videla dictatorship, and Pablo Miguel Jacovkis examines the relationship between politics and science throughout the twentieth century, which is quite an interesting case because in the history of Argentina the borderlines between dictatorship, authoritarianism and democracy are often blurred. Jacovkis explains, for instance, how universities were to some extent democratized after the military push that overthrew Juan Domingo Perón in 1955.
The main concern of the author of this review is the editors’ view on the book's topic. The editors focus on the intrinsic limitations of what David H. Guston and Kenneth Keniston described as the ‘social contract of science’, according to which the state supports scientific research, granting its freedom and autonomy, and therefore ‘good’ science can be produced only in democratic contexts. They observe that, however, both the militarization of certain sectors of scientific research in the Western bloc during the Cold War and the success of Nazi and Soviet science and technology undermine such a simplistic view. Thus they prefer to focus on a more nuanced view, such as that of Jonathan Harwood's national scientific styles. They then compare the three countries during dictatorship to each other, but sometimes also with other countries, such as Germany and Britain, without making use of the notion of scientific styles, but instead the political concepts of democracy, dictatorship and totalitarianism.
In the introduction, the editors state that Franco's regime and the various Argentinian dictators mistrusted science mainly because of the influence of the Catholic Church. Yet the relationship between Francoism, Catholicism and science in Franco's Spain was much more complex. The role of José María Albareda, the Opus Dei powerful head of the CSIC, in shaping research in Spain is overlooked, as is that of the Jesuits in scientific research. Despite its reactionary national–Catholic agenda, the Albareda CSIC changed science policy in Spain by endowing universities with research equipment and by concentrating resources in research sectors that were considered strategic.
Concerning Italy, the editors claim that Fascism promoted technology over science. Again, the picture is more complex. The editors’ view is mainly based on the work carried out at the CNR to find substitute products after the sanctions issued by the League of Nations in 1935. The CNR was an important institution, but some of the most important research groups were not connected with it. Giuseppe Levi's school of biology in Turin, from which came three Nobel Prize-winners (Renato Dulbecco, Salvador Luria and Rita Levi Montalcini), and Enrico Fermi's group in Rome worked in university laboratories. It was rather military campaigns and the 1838 Racial Laws that oriented research in Italy. The Racial Laws disrupted both Levi's and Fermi's groups, whereas military campaigns drained resources from pure research and oriented the activity of a number of Italian researchers towards military-related purposes.
The result is that, despite the high value of some of the individual contributions, the fuzzy units of comparison prevent the reader from gaining in-depth insight into how the relationship between science and dictatorship unfolded in the three countries. Nonetheless, the book is an excellent resource for all readers interested in the multifaceted relationship between science, technology and dictatorship with a special view to Argentina, Italy and Spain.
