Anyone who has taught the U.S. history survey (either half) is familiar with the standard reasons that voter turnout was so very high during the mid- to late nineteenth century, and also why it dropped off so precipitously thereafter. Jon Grinspan now gives us another explanation in this lively and accessibly written account: youthful participation. By focusing on the “virgin vote”—the first ballot cast by any voter—Grinspan highlights the role of young people in energizing the electorate and contributing to record numbers of voters during this age of popular politics.
While other historians have noted the fundamentally social nature of politics during this period, Grinspan argues this element of sociality was partially what fueled participation by youth—as debaters, campaigners, and ultimately voters. He demonstrates that this was so for young people of both sexes prior to reaching the age of majority, and indeed for many young women after reaching the age twenty-one, even though they were ineligible to actually cast a ballot. Young Americans were drawn into political discourse because it occurred in rowdy, intergenerational, mixed-sex spaces (at least some of the time). Until later in the nineteenth century, age and age grading were often less important than they would become, but the age of twenty-one was a distinct moment at which young men could recognize that they became adults, eligible to cast their virgin vote. It thus served as a powerful rite of passage for male voters and for their friends and family members. Young people embraced it enthusiastically, and that enthusiasm carried over into later life; the choice one made as a virgin voter was seen as especially significant for one's ongoing political engagement.
The book is divided into five chapters, with a substantial conclusion explaining why and how waning numbers of youthful voters at the turn of the century contributed to the death knell of popular politics. In Chapter 1, Grinspan documents how children grew up in families absorbing the importance of politics, as well as the political affiliations of their own relatives. Far from being insulated from political struggles, children overheard their parents, family members, and friends discussing politics. They also learned to associate political engagement and voting with the enviable privileges of adulthood. Until that time, however, young people were encouraged to talk politics in schools; participate in public political rallies; and at least for teenagers, become organizers at rallies and on election days.
In the second chapter, Grinspan connects the history of political participation directly to what we know about youth during this era: like many Americans, they were experiencing a period of transition, especially when it came to education, employment, rural-to-urban moves, and a postponement of marriage. Grinspan argues that at a time of uncertainty for young people, becoming active in politics gave them a sense of upward mobility, chronologically if not economically. As he puts it, “By joining parties, reading newspapers, attending rallies, speaking at debates, marching in processions, handing out ballots, or simply hurling bricks at the opposition, frustrated youths achieved a reliable sense of direction in life” (41–42). If structural forces stood in the way of achieving a meaningful sense of adulthood through independence, marriage, and self-sufficiency, participation in politics (both prior to, and after achieving the age of majority) allowed one to feel connected to adulthood.
Chapter 3 highlights how one's virgin vote, and reaching a twenty-first birthday, became sure signs of achieving adulthood in a society in which reliable markers of that status were increasingly elusive. Replete with myriad examples of voters losing their virginity—and exploring the analogies to loss of sexual virginity and its importance in American culture—the chapter makes the case for this signal moment in a man's life. Chapter 4 shows that men in their twenties made up the bulk of what we might now call campaign workers: hustlers, party thugs, and ballot distributors. These “chief persuaders” (87) were also particularly effective at convincing virgin voters, acting as a bridge between the young and older. As youth—a period stretching roughly into the late twenties—came to an end, so too did active public political participation for most men. Older men voted, to be sure, but were less public and vocal in their politics.
The fifth chapter steps back from the world of youth and focuses more squarely on the party politics of the era, arguing that party bosses were well aware, during this age of slim majorities and great party loyalty, that gaining control of the White House depended on each election's next batch of new voters. Aside from targeting virgin voters, politicians also tried to frame parties themselves as particularly fresh and youthful.
The conclusion argues that two factors explains why the age of popular politics came to an end, and why one major factor for this was a steep drop-off in youthful voter turnout. First, wealthier Americans sought to “wrest control of democracy from working-class politicos … creating new youth organizations that stressed rational, informed, sober political judgment” (131). This had the unexpected consequence of cleaving political life from social life and making the former much less exciting for young people. Second, by the late nineteenth century, a youth culture emerged that emphasized what young people had in common with one another, not with striving to advance toward adulthood, but rather with celebrating youth. As he puts it, “To many young Americans after 1890, politics belonged with politics, and youth belonged with youth” (132). While Grinspan is not the first to note these two underlying trends, the import of The Virgin Vote is to bring them to bear on one another, providing new insight into the history of politics and that of youth. It is engagingly written, peopled with varied archival voices, and would work well in classrooms at the undergraduate or graduate level.
