No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 29 March 2004
When discussing “markets” today we usually are bandying about abstractions; so it was with great anticipation that I started a book that deals with physical markets: the original sort, places where farmers came to sell food to townsfolk. This short, illustrated book treats the history of what the author calls the “public market system” in the United States from the nineteenth century, when publicly owned facilities “were the principal source of the city's daily supply of fresh food,” (p. 26) to the early twentieth century, when many markets had closed, replaced by distributed grocery stores and butcher shops. The reason the author calls public markets a “system” is that they embodied, in her view, a “moral economy”: “It was the duty of the state to ensure that the urban populace would have an adequate, wholesome, and affordable supply of necessities,” (p. 3) and the only way to accomplish this was through “regulated public markets.” This preconception runs through the book; against the ideal—a competently managed public market, where farmers and consumers meet directly—all other “laissez-faire” commercial arrangements (peddlers, shops, private market houses) are judged and found wanting. That the ideal frequently was not achieved, as the author recounts, does not weaken her conviction.
Central markets were ancient venues for trade. We learn that in America, laws regulating markets were commonplace. In particular, some laws restricted the selling of food outside public markets except under certain conditions. Markets were often located in the center of town, sometimes in the middle of a street, as was Philadelphia's High (later Market) Street market. They might be placed on the ground floor of multi-purpose buildings (like Boston's Faneuil Hall Market) or simply in open sheds. Animals were brought on the hoof through the streets to the butchers' market stalls. Over time in large cities, with populations spreading out and businesses replacing residences in the old centers, the early markets became inconvenient. Moreover, the rationale for a city operating real estate, rather than regulating food safety and weights directly, was questioned. Thus began agitation to loosen restrictive laws and reconfigure the markets. Food was supplied by peddlers, neighborhood shops, and modern private markets. But the tenants of public market stalls opposed these developments, as did some city fathers. It seems that markets could be important sources of revenue for cities, bringing in more in rents and fees than they cost to manage, and in such cases, cities were reluctant to loosen restrictions. Market buildings—some very large ones—continued to be constructed into the twentieth century by municipalities and private investors.
But demographic and economic trends worked against the central, publicly owned market. Not only was population living farther from the old centers, but farms were located farther from cities. Food arriving from greater distances was handled by wholesalers, and some public markets became wholesale markets. But with growing traffic, wholesale markets needed to be removed from congested areas. Public markets can be found in some cities today, and some cities arrange for farmers' markets in harvest season. But these play a minor role in a city's food supply.
What I wish the author had provided, in addition to the focus on markets, is an overall picture of how urban households obtained food. How important were public markets compared with alternative sources? What kinds of vendors actually occupied the markets: farmers, or retailers and wholesalers? Regarding the public markets' purported advantages, did the markets actually keep food prices down and quality high, and assure food abundance?
The biggest problem with the book for someone interested in economic history is that the author does not analyze the developments in economic terms. She takes for granted that her ideal market arrangement yields the best results for public welfare. Rather than tracing how and why food marketing changed, the author laments the divergence from her ideal. She plainly loves public markets, but writing as their defender rather than impartial interpreter, she fails to explore the interesting economic questions a study of markets raises.