The book continues Maijastina Kahlos's research on the religious conflicts of Late Antiquity, analysing the ‘rhetoric and realities’ (2) involved in the Christian perception and treatment of pagans and heretics. Judaism receives no systematic discussion, despite occasional mentions and awareness of its place in the late antique Christian tableau of ‘religious dissent’ (e.g. 89). The aim is a more accurate grasp of religious transformation beyond schemes of decline or Christianisation.
Section I explores the rhetoric of religious deviance in imperial legislation and ecclesiastical discourse, cogently arguing that both bear the mark of earlier Roman concepts. K. shows how ‘religious dissenters were labelled as belonging outside the Roman state, Graeco-Roman civilization, and oikoumene — and also, in the crudest cases, outside humankind’ (15) and underlines the rhetorical dimension of imperial legislation (29–30) as well as its ‘responsive’ character (33), ambiguity and regionally varied and limited application. She highlights the complex relationships between bishops and emperors and the role of local elites in mediating the impact of imperial and episcopal endeavours, and closes with a poignant analysis of Christian aggression towards pagan cult places and its rhetorical amplifications in a ‘narrative of Christian triumphalism’ (59).
Section II deconstructs (cf. 83) the categories ‘pagans’ and ‘heretics’ as the result of Christian simplification through ‘naming, listing, and labelling’ (88). K. outlines how stereotypes of pagans were shaped and employed in Christian discourse and argues that imperial legislation lists and forbids individual practices, precisely because paganism as a ‘construct of Christian self-perception’ defies exhaustive definition (98–9; cf. 141). The adherents of traditional religion are presented briefly, with a focus on more irenic and less philosophically sophisticated figures. The emphasis is on social interaction and Christian labelling; pagan conceptualisations of religion and religious boundaries receive only summary treatment (95; 125). K. discusses heresy and orthodoxy as ‘relational concepts’ that document power struggles and are open to constant negotiation (104–5), surveys the rhetorical means employed to stigmatise Christian intra-group deviance and briefly highlights the ‘making’ of Arians, Donatists and Pelagians (111–20). Here too she focuses on rhetoric and the social construction of group identity, only marginally touching upon the theological issues at stake. The account would have profited from engagement with the argument of M.-Y. Perrin's Civitas confusionis (2017) that doctrinal issues, mediated via the cultivation of an ‘éthos hérésiologique’ (71) to wider strata of society, played a notable role in the social construction of heresy and orthodoxy.
In Section III, K. turns to the analysis of ‘local religion’, i.e. the lived religion of average practitioners, as the more promising alternative to monumental narratives about the religious transformations of Late Antiquity (137–8). Her assumption that ‘[w]e need to distinguish between early Christianity as lived religion and the early church as the institutional manifestation of Christianity’ (137) may perhaps explain the exclusion of Christian liturgy from the account, although K. notes occasionally that many practitioners probably took part in ‘both traditional and Christian celebrations’ (187; cf. 177). K. explores the decline and transformations of sacrifice, the competition between Christian charity and traditional euergetism, shared and contested practices related to time and space, the grey zone of funerary and martyr cults as well as the transformations mirrored by the shifting use of the label ‘magic’ from the second century to Late Antiquity. In her view, the constellations of continuity and transformation observed in these contexts defy clear distinctions between Christians and pagans, whether the emic ones of religious authorities striving to ‘repress and even eliminate religious ambiguity and dissent’ (212) or etic ones implied by concepts such as ‘survival’, ‘syncretism’ or ‘hybridity’ (139–40, 143–4).
The conclusion summarises the results and questions the concept of Christianisation, proposing instead (220) to ‘place the religious changes in Late Antiquity in the bigger picture and longer story of the Mediterranean world’, by focusing on practices, ‘the local and the ordinary’ and discovering the ‘John Does and Jane Does’ who ‘prevailed against and overcame the ideologues of separation’.
The book conveys a clear sense of the Christian rhetoric of religious deviance in late antique society. It uncovers the political, social and economic contexts and driving forces involved in the creation and regulation of religious group identities and captures masterfully the complexity and ambiguities of lived religion. Inevitably, the sharp focus on social interaction and Christian rhetoric comes with its blind spots. The intellectual dimension and issues of religious dissent remain largely obscure. There is little discussion of the distinctive weight placed on doctrine, truth and unity in Christian discourse. Viewing paganism primarily as a Christian construction eclipses the discursive practices of boundary-drawing and exclusion stigmatising Christians (and sometimes Jews) as ‘other’ in the religious landscape of the Empire and the oikoumene, which Late Antique pagans inherit from earlier centuries. Lastly, the distinction between the ‘John Does’ and the ‘ideologues of separation’ invites further qualification, taking into account the Christian emphasis on the necessity of religious education, however rudimentary, for all believers (vividly illustrated by the homiletic efforts documented in Section III), the place of Christian liturgy in local religion, the involvement of religious elite members in popular practices (156–7, 187) and the perpetuation of Greek and Roman paideia with its potentially religious dimensions by both ecclesiastical and lay elites. K.'s mapping of the late antique religious landscape thus invites us to explore its complexity further.
