An evaluation of mental capacity is critical to a clinician's judgment about whether or not persons can make medical treatment decisions on their own behalf, and uncertainty about their ability to meaningfully participate in that process is one of the more common reasons an ethics consult is requested. The care of decisionally incapable patients—particularly those who lack advance care documents and no living relative who can speak for them—presents a quandary to healthcare personnel attempting to plan care in their best interest, especially when options are multiple but none are ideal.1
American Bar Association Commission on Law and Aging. Incapacitated and alone: Healthcare decision making for unbefriended older people. Washington, D.C.: American Bar Association, Section of Individual Rights & Responsibilities; 2003. Available from: http://www.abanet.org/irr/hr/spring04/incapacitated.html (accessed Mar 12, 2007).
The term “dually diagnosed” can also refer to individuals diagnosed with intellectual disability and drug/substance abuse, a population distinct from the one that is the subject of this paper.
Mental retardation (MR)—also referred to as intellectual disability—is the most common type of developmental disability. MR affects 1%–3% of the population and is well documented across age, gender, ethnic groups, social strata, and geographic location. Individuals with MR are at a higher risk of developing a mental illness, with an estimated 60% having a diagnosable psychiatric disorder.3
White P, Chant D, Edwards N, Townsend C, Waghorn G. Prevalence of intellectual disability and comorbid mental illness in an Australian community sample. Australian and New Zealand Journal of Psychiatry 2005;39(5):395–400; Centers for Disease Control, 2005. Available from: http://www.cdc.gov/ncbddd/dd/default.htm (accessed Feb 15, 2007); Kerker BD, Owens PL, Zigler E, Horwitz SM. Mental health disorders among individuals with mental retardation: Challenges to accurate prevalence estimates. Public Health Reports 2004;119(4):409–17.
Shavelle R, Strauss D. Mortality of persons with developmental disabilities after transfer into community care: A 1996 update. American Association on Mental Retardation 1999; 104(2):143–7; Lamb HR, Weinberger LE, eds. Deinstitutionalization: Promise and problems. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass; 2001.
Kim S, Larson SA, Lakin KC. Behavioral outcomes of deinstitutionalization for people with intellectual disability: A review of US studies between 1980 and 1999. Journal of Intellectual & Developmental Disability 2001;26(1):35–50; see note 4, Lamb, Weinberger 2001; see note 4, Shavelle, Strauss 1999.
Lurigio AJ. Persons with serious mental illness in the criminal justice system: Background, prevalence, and principles of care. Criminal Justice Policy Review 2000;11(4):312–29; Krieg RG. An interdisciplinary look at the deinstitutionalization of the mentally ill. Social Science Journal 2001;38(3):367–81; McEver M. State trying to keep mentally ill people out of jail system. The Brownsville Herald. 2005 Aug 14. Available from: http://www.brownsvilleherald.com/onset?id=66080&template=article.html (accessed Oct 12, 2005). Although collaborative governmental efforts are underway to create jail diversion programs to place nonviolent persons into the mental health system rather than the penal system, it is certain that thousands of individuals with mental illness are currently being dumped into the latter, not just in Texas but across the country; Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act of 1990. Public Law 101-508 (Nov 5, 1990), §§ 4206, 4751. See 42 USC, scattered sections; Mental health crisis swells jails. Nursing.aust 2005;6(4):1,4.
The ideal model of shared and collaborative decisionmaking in the healthcare encounter that depends on the expression of individual autonomy is frequently not appropriate or useful when dually diagnosed individuals living in group homes present to acute care hospitals for treatment of a medical illness. Conducting ethics consultations in these cases can pose special challenges that are partially attributable to a lack of clear standards and regulatory guidelines protecting these individuals when institutionalized that do not transfer to the more independent, “least-restrictive” environments of privatized group homes. Typical questions entertained by the ethics case consultant or team include (1) how to determine mental capacity for medical treatment decisionmaking in this population of patients, (2) how to apply the concept of autonomy (as currently operationalized and understood within the health care system) and whether it has the same (or any) meaning for these persons, and (3) how to develop a best interest standard (in the absence of any living family members, legally appointed guardian, or proxy) for such persons deemed capable of making some life decisions but incapable of making medical treatment choices on their own behalf. If such a standard can be developed, what might that process look like?
The Cases
The following presents two cases (deliberately reconstructed to mask private health information) of ethics consultation involving dually diagnosed persons in the context of end-of-life care. The assumptions in assessing mental capacity for treatment decisionmaking, the specific issues confronting clinicians in developing a therapeutic plan of care, and the response of an ethics consultation team asked to assist with these challenges are discussed. Very little information exists in the literature on the specific situation of healthcare decisionmaking for this vulnerable population, and no previous in-depth research studies could be located to guide the committee in its efforts to craft an approach.
Michael
Michael is an elderly gentleman with a dual diagnosis of mental retardation and schizoid syndrome. He holds a job and is self-sufficient in his activities of daily living. He fell at the group home where he lives and sustained a spinal cord injury. He was treated and subsequently released from the hospital in halo traction. He fell again a few days later and returned with a second confirmed spinal fracture requiring cervical fusion. He now requires a ventilator to breathe and will be unable to survive without one. He has no living relatives or court-appointed guardian. Up until this point he made all decisions in his daily affairs. He has no advance care planning and those who know him best are the directors of the residential facility where he has lived for the past 20 years. His primary care physician and the consulting neurosurgeon believe that continuing aggressive medical intervention will not result in Michael returning to the life he experienced prior to his accidents. Michael is and has remained unresponsive since his second admission.
Sarah
Sarah is a high functioning Down syndrome individual with a mood disorder living in a residential home. Sarah was placed in a state institution as a child and moved to the community at age 21. She has always held a job, lived independently within the group setting, and made her own decisions. Now in her late forties she presented to the emergency department with congestive heart failure and pneumonia. She is a chronic smoker with a history of respiratory problems and this is her third admission in 12 months. Her clinical condition worsened rapidly, necessitating intubation and ventilator support before contact could be made with her aged mother (her only known living relative), who lives several states away and who has not seen her daughter in more than 20 years. In her late eighties, Sarah's mother depends on the administrator of the group home to inform her of all matters related to her daughter. When he called to discuss the situation, Sarah's mother replied that she did not know what to do. She refused to call the hospital or speak to the physicians herself, insisting that the home administrator do this—to “take care” of things as he always has. Health Information Portability and Accountability Act regulations forbid discussion of any patients care with anyone outside of “treatment-payment-operations” unless the patient has given explicit consent to disclose private health information. The administrator does not have Sarah's permission to access her medical record, nor does Sarah have a medical power of attorney, living will, or any other form of advance care planning. Sarah's condition stabilized but the opinion of both the primary care physician and the consulting cardiologist is that she will not be able to be weaned from the respirator. Sarah is unresponsive except to deep pain stimulation.
The Issues
The ethics committee was consulted to review both cases for the same reason: to assist in clarifying decisionmaking authority and to explore all possible avenues for resolving the situation. The option to seek guardianship was considered a last resort. A three-person team from the ethics committee performed intake interviews and collected information from the primary care physician, nurse case manager, chaplain, bedside care nurses, clinical psychologist, hospital administration, pastoral care, and others identified as appropriate. Current hospital policy and procedures were reviewed, including applicable state law regarding advance care planning and consent to treatment. The local office for the Guardianship Alliance was also contacted.
Following fact gathering the consultation team met and reached consensus for recommending that palliative care/comfort care measures be initiated along with an allow natural death (AND) order. The medical management of both cases was being constrained by a clear method of establishing legitimate decisionmaking authority legally recognized by the state that was also acceptable to the treating physicians and majority opinion of the hospital administration. Despite assurances from legal counsel and support of a consensus recommendation from the ethics consultation team, the respective attending physicians rejected committee recommendations and opted to seek formal guardianship for both Michael and Sarah. This option is nearly always unsatisfactory because it is typically long, time-consuming, and predictably not helpful because clinicians often need immediate answers. Concern and confusion regarding the meaning of “best interest” for a mentally disabled person pervaded physician attitudes and was remarkable for the presence of a paternalism that is generally (in our experience) uncharacteristic. Providers and administrators expressed fears of litigation and a tendency to choose the most conservative approach to treatment options, particularly in regard to life-sustaining treatment. Although clinical facts strongly supported a medical diagnosis/prognosis for an irreversible and terminal condition (state established criteria), and we achieved agreement among all stakeholders that a therapeutic plan of comfort care was indicated (including the opinions of those providing care for these individuals in their group homes), there remained an unwillingness among the responsible physicians to write corresponding orders to withdraw life-sustaining measures, withhold further aggressive treatment, institute palliative care, and allow natural death. This again was unusual, because in the past these same physicians were comfortable accepting the testimony of family members and others with close personal knowledge of a patient lacking advance care planning documents as evidence in determining what they would likely choose.
Case Outcome
Michael remained on ventilator support and continued to deteriorate clinically for the 11 days it took to secure a guardian, apprise her of the case, and allow enough time to render a decision. Initially an AND order was written, and on the 12th day all life-sustaining treatments were withdrawn and palliative care measures initiated. Michael died less than 3 h after this process began.
Sarah's case was somewhat different in that she had previously expressed to her caretaker that she did not want to be connected to machines of any kind to keep her alive. A year prior to her own illness, Sarah had been a frequent visitor to a close friend from the same home hospitalized for emphysema. Her friend never regained consciousness after being intubated and placed on a ventilator where she remained for several weeks until she died. Testimony of Sarah's caretaker on the profound effect this ex- perience had on Sarah, with her subsequent conversations about her own wishes, were eventually enough for Sarah's physician to write an AND order (with the concurring opinion of a second physician not involved in her care) 7 days after guardianship proceedings began. Although in other cases these verbal expressions had counted as evidence of treatment preference and are considered legal in our state, the physicians remained uncomfortable about withdrawing life support and instituting palliative care. Sarah experienced a major cardiac event and died before the guardianship process could complete.
Both Michael and Sarah remained in the intensive care unit until they expired.
Discussion
The difficulty experienced in establishing decisionmaking authority in a manner acceptable to the treatment team and hospital administration was expressed as a profound discomfort related to the fact of these patients' disability and that they had “no one” to speak for them. This attitude persisted despite repeated efforts to assure them that existing laws and processes were valid and applied equally regardless of these patients' preexisting mental states. The members of the consultation team expressed frustration at being unable to provide convincing assurances in support of a different course of action.
There is no question that disabled persons have historically been discounted and denied fundamental rights and privileges—the mere presence of a disability was considered enough to justify unequal treatment, leading to rampant paternalism and often an attitude that such persons be regarded as “patients for life.”7
Baynton DC. Disability and the justification of inequality in American history. In: Longmore PK, Umansky L, eds. The New Disability History: American Perspectives. New York: New York University Press; 2004:33–57.
Although it was quite apparent that physicians in both cases believed their patients were in an irreversible and terminal condition, they insisted on a treatment approach that differed from one normally taken in the past with similar clinical presentations. The physicians expressed a complex array of rationalizations, varying from exaggerated fears of liability (supported by hospital administration) to an obligation to “try” even though it ran counter to their clinical wisdom and experience in the past. Their conversations with the consultation team revealed a reticence to withhold/withdraw aggressive intervention and initiate palliative care based on their belief in a duty to fully disclose the risks/benefits to “someone” even though acknowledging little to no probability of benefit for continuing such efforts. This left the consultation team in a quandary: how to produce a person qualified to hold that discussion where none existed—other than to pursue legal guardianship—an option previously discussed as not helpful. Neither the physicians nor hospital administrators would budge. The result was (in the committee's view) an overly protective, overly conservative approach to care that prolonged the expected death of both patients and that may have contributed to unnecessary suffering.
Case Review
All conducted case consultations are reviewed at the next regularly scheduled meeting of the full committee. When the cases were presented the recurring question among those present was: “Why did these persons come to our hospital without advance care planning?” For us, this was a “foreseeable event.” The law in our state mandates that every client in a group home must have an established primary healthcare provider as a necessary condition of placement; therefore the opportunity to assess these patients' mental capacity for medical decisionmaking and to explore alternatives such as surrogacy or guardianship (if warranted) were there. Unfortunately, it is common for persons with mental retardation to not be involved in their healthcare decisions and for healthcare staff in acute care settings to be generally unfamiliar in caring for them. This can lead to a “status approach” on questions of capacity to consent—a presumption made that because they are intellectually disabled they cannot participate in making decisions about their care in a manner that would be legally valid.8
Keywood K, Fovargue S, Flynn M. Best Practice? Health Care Decision-Making By, With, and For Adults. Manchester, England: National Development Team; 1999.
When our ethics committee was first established it recognized the strong possibility of encountering situations involving patients admitted to our facilities for medical treatment who might also have a diagnosis of mental illness and/or mental retardation because of the proximity of several institutions specializing in their treatment and care. This was the rationale for a permanent place on the committee for a member with expert knowledge in this clinical area—to give our practitioners and administrators immediate access to information not typically available in the existing clinical setting. It was disappointing for us that we had not been able to use that knowledge to effect better therapeutic planning in these cases, and this was perhaps the biggest disappointment in evaluating case outcomes.
Recommendations
The committee responded to the case review with a list of specific recommendations:
- Create a forum for physician leaders and administrators to meet clinical experts on the committee with knowledge and experience on issues of evaluating mental capacity, decisionmaking, surrogacy, guardianship, and advance care planning in patients with a dual diagnosis.
- Establish a collaborative partnership with area directors of the group homes, hospital case management, and the local office of the Guardianship Alliance to promote more effective communication, share ideas, and explore solutions to effect better policy.
- Create innovative and reusable learning tools for RN staff and case management on early identification and intervention in cases of a poorly identified line of decisionmaking authority, patients who may lack the mental capacity to consent to treatment, specific issues related to the care of patients with dual diagnosis, and the role of the ethics case consultation committee.
- Provide educational materials on advance care planning to primary care providers in outpatient settings and arrange personal contacts with individual providers to encourage them to include an assessment of mental capacity for healthcare decisionmaking in their patient population, especially for those who have never developed or may never develop the capacity to make relevant medical decisions.
Results
The physician forum succeeded in the exchange of valuable information and important introductions to persons willing and available to provide assistance. The collaborative partnership created consisted of a self-selected panel from among the directors of the group homes and representatives from various hospital departments with whom they typically interact when their clients are admitted. Meeting quarterly, the panel mutually derived agendas from the self-identified needs of both providers and home administrators and to date has focused mainly on education. Education for group home administrators has focused on the types and uses of state-approved advance care planning documents, how they are implemented, and the circumstances under which they are used to guide clinical decisionmaking. With the help of the local chapter of the Guardianship Alliance, progress has been made in identifying persons in group homes who have “never been competent” with successful efforts toward securing surrogate decision makers.
For hospital staff, educational programming has focused on understanding the regulatory guidelines under which group homes operate, increasing sensitivity and awareness of the special needs and circumstances of dually diagnosed individuals and eliminating barriers to communication between providers and administrators as much as possible. Such efforts have required an expanded notion of the meaning of family (different from the traditional “related by blood” conception). The reusable learning tool became an ethics module for annual staff RN competency testing. This was created by staff development and deployed within a month. A protocol was developed for early recognition by case management of individuals admitted to the hospital without a proxy decisionmaker and who lacked the capacity to give consent. Identifying such persons early in the hospital stay allows for better planning and anticipation of special needs regarding issues of consent to treatment. As a result, communication has been facilitated and case conferencing increased. Group home directors and/or the patient's direct caretakers are now routinely invited to attend and participate. Perhaps most important has been the recognition of the need for serious self-reflection in recognizing and acknowledging the discomfort and anxiety so prevalent among hospital staff when encountering dual diagnosis patients in the acute care setting.
The idea to encourage primary care providers to pursue advance care planning for their dual diagnosis patients living in group homes during outpatient visits had to be modified. Subsequent to these plans we learned that this could have an unintended detrimental effect if an order was placed on a patient's chart to secure advance care documents and/or a surrogate decisionmaker that was not immediately carried out. Doctor's orders carry a lot of weight with regulatory officials, and if an audit revealed one that had not been carried out or completed, it could result in a deficiency citing for the group home. Alternative strategies are currently being explored, including the feasibility of establishing a group of local volunteers willing to act as surrogate decisionmakers for this population of patients. This was suggested by group home directors and has the support of the Guardianship Alliance and the leadership of the local mental health care community.
Conclusions
Our experience in conducting case consultations in this special population has produced systematic and ongoing institutional change benefiting both provider and patient. We discovered the potential risk of violating individual rights in the temptation to treat the mentally disabled as a homogenous group. The problems encountered convinced us of our obligation to establish a due process by which decisions to forgo life-sustaining treatment in this category of patients was transparent and consistent, and we found retrospective case review an ideal method to develop plans that were patient centered and multidisciplinary. As the number of persons who lack mental capacity to make medical decisions grows, communities need to experiment with new and creative approaches to assist those who are most vulnerable and easily identified. Ethics committees know firsthand the dilemmas involved when difficult situations that could have been anticipated are not handled in a proactive manner. Our experience in working community-wide on these issues has been both positive and productive.
