Donald T. Critchlow and W. J. Rorabaugh have written a well-researched, interesting work of history concerning the Left and the Democratic Party. At the same time, make no mistake: this book contains a very definite, strong political message, one that is very relevant to today's political debates. Progressives will almost surely dislike the thesis Critchlow and Rorabaugh put forward. And yet, this book surely deserves a hearing.
The authors seek to examine how liberalism got to where it is today. Others who have written on this topic argue that the roots of today's Left can be traced back to the early 1900s, with the founding of the Progressive movement, and then later continuing its development with Franklin D. Roosevelt's New Deal. But Critchlow and Rorabaugh disagree. They contend that, after all, neither Progressivism nor the New Deal was a truly radical movement; neither sought to eliminate capitalism or fundamentally transform America. No, instead today's “New Progressives” (as the authors come to refer to them) emerged after they made a sharp break with establishment liberalism in the 1960s. Back then, the New Progressives were the radical Left, fighting the battles of the Vietnam War and student protest. But these radicals became disillusioned, as they failed to take over the Democratic Party in 1968, were unable to move liberals in their own militant direction, and began to see the country move to the right.
So progressives came up with a new strategy. Instead of seeking to destroy the establishment, they would burrow from within. They would become activists within the Democratic Party; they would become lawyers and use the courts to impose their philosophy and the results they desired onto others. And so this long march began all the way back in 1969 when, in their first attempt to influence the Democratic Party, progressive activists created the McGovern Commission, which fundamentally changed the rules concerning how presidential candidates would be nominated. No longer would party insiders have the biggest say in the presidential nominating process. Instead, every state would be contested in either primaries or party caucuses—affairs in which motivated activists could play an important role—and state convention delegations would have to guarantee a certain number of spots to women and other minorities. Critchlow and Rorabaugh argue that all this was largely pushed by, and was a huge victory for, progressive activists.
Another area of triumph for these new progressives was the legal profession, as they pioneered the rise of public-interest law, and sought to achieve at least some of their political goals in court. Critchlow and Rorabaugh thus masterfully tell the tale of how progressives championed the idea of taking legal action against large corporations, heaping praise upon those who sued auto companies and big tobacco. We see here the emergence of Ralph Nader and his Public Interest Research Group (PIRG); of John Edwards who, the authors point out, despite his later fall from grace owing to personal scandal, was actually a long-time progressive hero, even though he was a very wealthy lawyer. The reason? Edwards more than once took part in major suits against tobacco companies. We learn about the rise of organizations such as the Ford Foundation, which funded and promoted these activities.
But what ideas, what beliefs, drove all this action and motivated these new progressives? Critchlow and Rorabaugh contend that it was the rallying cry of “social justice.” What does that mean? It is not always clear, and progressives can of course differ on such things. But at root, the authors argue, was the fact that “their mistrust of organizations and their ignorance of, and hostility to, free markets led them increasingly towards solutions that relied on big government and technocratic and legal elites. … They call for new standards of public morality to be built on a foundation of social justice in which individual rights are subsumed in the collective interests of the community—with the New Progressives defining those collective interests, of course” (6).
And the authors have amassed significant evidence to back up their conclusion. For example, they show that there have been more than one progressive who support abortion rights not simply because of their sincere belief in that right, but owing to the fact that one of the “collective interests” mentioned above is population control. One activist in the 1980s supported the availability of the morning-after abortion pill RU-486 because, he wrote, we could “start immediately to eliminate the barely-educated, unhealthy, and poor segment of our country. No, I'm not advocating some sort of mass extinction of these unfortunate people. Crime, drugs, and disease are already doing that. The problem is that these numbers are not only replaced but increased by the birth of millions of babies to people who can't afford to have babies. There, I've said it. It's what we all know is true, but we only whisper it” (quoted on 103). Earlier, progressive activist Harriet Pilpel wrote in an article supporting the right to an abortion that, while terminating a pregnancy should not be our first method of population control, “to cut down on population growth we should make abortion easy and safe while we continue to develop other and more satisfactory methods of family limitation” (quoted on 121).
The authors further contend that too often this new progressivism ignores the democratic will of the people, especially when it conflicts with their goals. Even though polls show that the majority of the American public have not been convinced by the claims of radical environmentalist progressives, such continue to keep up their drumbeat of urgings that more federal taxes and regulations be imposed to curb consumer consumption. Other environmentalists recently have hinted that the environment is in such dire shape that perhaps America needs a more authoritarian government led by experts. “US democracy,” they claim, “that offered freedom with diminishing collective responsibility is not a model that can sustain the world” (97). And of course, President Obama's health care package, passed in 2009 by Congress, was supported in the main by progressives despite the fact that polls consistently showed the public opposing it.
The authors strive very hard to make a reasonable case. They note that progressives are not part of a rigid, monolithic movement, that it is often “diffuse and fluid” (5). They do not deny that many progressives are sincere people with good intentions who simply want to deal with issues they see as being important. But on the whole, the authors are very concerned. They believe essentially that the historical change that has occurred within the Left is leading to the rise of an antidemocratic nanny state that seeks to control people's choices, no matter what those people think about it. They believe the current Obama administration is very much being driven by this kind of progressivism—the authors demonstrate well that Obama was just such a progressive activist himself early in his political career, and his most fervent support comes from progressives. And the authors bleakly conclude that, when all is said and done, this progressivism will fail: “The progressive plans to use governmental power to pursue absurd and destructive dreams of social justice require a flood of nonexistent government revenue and can be realized only with unsustainable deficits. As a result, inflation, increased taxes, slower growth, higher unemployment, and poorer government services will be the result” (213).
This book is a work of history. It is also a book that makes a definite political statement. Many historians today tend, of course, to lean toward progressivism in their political beliefs. One can imagine that their take on this book would be to find it at best polarizing, at worst outrageous and thus deserving of being ignored. (One unfortunately must “imagine” this because, as of this writing, the author was unable to find progressive reviews and/or responses to this book.) But that would be a mistake. This is a work both interesting and detailed, a work chock full of evidence. It deserves a response.
