As a tribute to the career of Ann Thompson, and specifically to her pioneering collection Women Reading Shakespeare (coedited with Sasha Roberts in 1997), the editors of this volume have collected thirty-three essays that examine the impact of women's involvement with Shakespeare over the past four centuries. In their preface the editors justify their imposition of an “unyielding ceiling” (xiii) of three thousand words per chapter, necessary due to the fact that they received so many affirmative responses to their request for contributions, a testament to the “full reach of Ann's professional acquaintance and influence” (xii). The result is a volume of concise, diverse, and stimulating essays that touch upon an extensive array of artistic, scholarly, pedagogic, and even quotidian engagement with Shakespeare by women.
The book is split into three parts: “Text,” “Reception,” and “Performance.” Although the structure acts as a useful guide for the reader in general, many of the essays inevitably escape or overflow these distinctions. The parts themselves also contain discernible topical subdivisions, though these, too, have been carefully curated by the editorial team. The opening essays of Part I, “Text,” investigate the literary phenomena of Shakespeare's female characters themselves. These chapters pose something of a thematic difficulty, as they inaugurate a volume on how women have made Shakespeare with an investigation of how Shakespeare crafted his women. None of the pieces explicitly theorizes the agential nuance of this interrelationship, though Jean Howard does note that “the character of Queen Margaret helped to make Shakespeare famous” (3). The second set of essays, which deal primarily with women as editors, are more clearly thematically germane and offer a wealth of historical data that demonstrates women's definitive contributions to the field of Shakespearean editing, even in what continue to be less than representative numbers. Suzanne Gossett, in her chapter on “Women Making Shakespeare—and Middleton and Jonson,” extends the analytical depth of this discussion by questioning whether “female authority actually lead[s] to editions that look different” (100). A particular highlight of Part I is David Scott Kastan's chapter on the history of women in the printing industry. In examining women's impactful (and named) presence in these roles, Kastan destabilizes the trope of female invisibility in early modern theatrical production.
Part II, “Reception,” offers the greatest diversity of topical intersections, demonstrating the enormously varied ways in which women have influenced historical perceptions of Shakespeare. Though a few of the essays intersect substantially with those in Part III, “Performance,” in that they consider the impact of actresses on reception, the majority investigate women's influence in nontheatrical genres. In “Women Painting Shakespeare: Angelica Kauffman's Text-Images,” Keir Elam provides a fascinating assessment of the work of eighteenth-century painter Kauffman, arguing that the artist's “engagement with the gestural as well as discursive texture of the scene[s]” (124) distinguishes her work from that of her male contemporaries, and thus achieves “a feminine and feminized reading of history and, more specifically, of Shakespeare himself” (130). Many of the chapters examine women's utilization and propagation of the notion of Shakespeare as universal moral authority and exemplar of highbrow culture. These include Kate Chedgzoy's essay on the upbringing of Mary Cowden Clark (a figure oft referenced throughout the collection), Gretchen E. Minton's historical explication of women's books clubs in settlement-era Montana, and Anne Isherwood's illuminating piece on nineteenth-century birthday books that featured Shakespearean quotations, offering an otherwise rare cultural access point for the “many ordinary people [who] did not think Shakespeare was for them” (174). Part II closes with Reiko Oya's elegantly rendered essay on Virginia Woolf's To the Lighthouse. Oya argues that in replacing direct citation of Shakespeare with more oblique references, Woolf instantiates an “aesthetics of anonymity” (213), granting the playwright immortality by freeing him from the binds of spatiotemporal specificity and thus “spar[ing] Shakespeare's works from the fate that befalls other human artefacts [sic]” (216). One might conclude then that, paradoxically, Woolf assists in “making” Shakespeare through her decision not to make him.
The final part of the book, “Performance,” is the most thematically consistent, featuring a series of case studies primarily of women actresses' and directors' work on Shakespeare, though there are chapters on theatre managers, dramaturges, and film editors as well. Unsurprisingly, perhaps, a number of essays tackle the so-called Shrew question. Iska Alter notes that it is a “critical commonplace” that gender politics “inevitably determine the methodology of dramatic action” (293) in the play. Other chapters, however, examine plays less overt in their implications for gender and performance. Trudi Darby analyzes the interpretive consequences of Patsy Rodenburg's centralization of the female characters in her production of Richard III, specifically in contrast with Laurence Olivier's 1955 film version of the play in which those characters are cut drastically. And, in one of the absolute gems of the collection, Judith Buchanan posits that the essence of dramatic conflict in The Tempest emerges from “the acuteness of Prospero's anxiety to be understood as the counter to unruly female sorcery—as, insistently, Not Sycorax” (339). Buchanan goes onto assess the aesthetic ramifications of two contemporary works based on the play, Jeremy Sams's opera The Enchanted Island, which features Sycorax as an onstage presence, and Julie Taymor's 2010 film Tempest, which stars Helen Mirren as Prospera, a regendering that Buchanan argues fundamentally compromises the protagonist's identificatory duality.
The topical and disciplinary breadth of this collection is both a boon and, in some instances, a hindrance. A few pieces seem somewhat arbitrarily related to the book's theme but offer valuable contributions nonetheless. Finally, though the brevity of the chapters occasionally leaves room only for provisional conclusions by the essayists, the analyses are effective and provocative, and will hopefully spur further scholarly engagement with this vital field of study.
