Allyson Hobbs' A Chosen Exile: A History of Racial Passing in American Life is that rare work of scholarship that captures public attention and acquires a general readership. Originally a dissertation in history at the University of Chicago, A Chosen Exile is a cultural history of racial passing from the late eighteenth century to the 1950s, when the phenomenon “reportedly ‘passed out’” (25). Hobbs uses “the predicaments of those who could pass as white” as a way to engage the changing meanings of race in our own day as well as in the past (5).
In this evocative book, Hobbs mines social historical and literary sources to offer a panoramic view of racial passing from the Colonial era to the present. A prologue begins the narrative in the eighteenth century, when freedom and whiteness were not synonymous, and slaves could cross over into free black communities. Hobbs then moves quickly to the successive Southern racial regimes of slavery, Reconstruction, and Jim Crow. This portion of the book consists of five chapters, each of which focuses on a specific moment and cast of characters. Some of these characters are well known, such as Ellen and William Craft, who escaped from slavery by passing as white (and, in Ellen's case, as a man). Others, such as the Johnston family, which passed for white in midcentury New Hampshire until they chose to reveal their ancestry, are not. Much of the book concerns writers who engaged the question of racial hybridity and identity in their work and lives, such as Charles Chesnutt, Jean Toomer, Langston Hughes, and Nella Larson.
Hobbs is a gifted writer, both organizationally and stylistically. Her prose is authoritative and energetic. Hobbs's success in gaining a broad readership reflects her capacity to convey knowledge in a radically compressed way, as when she explains Reconstruction in one perfect phrase as being when the “prospect of being both black and a citizen existed” (74). This is a book that might easily have become bogged down in detail. Hobbs's skill at moving the narrative along is so sure that it is completely undetected by the reader.
This is a book with a point of view. Hobbs begins A Chosen Exile by announcing forthrightly that, “This book is about loss.” Racial passing, she continues, “is an exile, sometimes chosen, sometimes not,” and once one has passed, there is “no available avenue for return.” Hobbs explores not only the experiences of those who passed, but also, intriguingly, the anguish of those left behind, who experience a different form of loss, including abandonment.
Hobbs's focus on what was lost through passing, at the levels of the individual and of the collective, is powerful and original. Her statement that “historians and literary scholars have paid far more attention to what was gained by passing as white than to what was lost by rejecting a black identity” (11) is well taken, although not entirely fair to historians, such as Daniel Sharfstein, whose painstakingly-researched book The Invisible Line: Three American Families and the Secret Journey from Black to White (Penguin, 2010) rejects the gain/loss binary and demonstrates Hobbs's point that family histories bring into focus “the collective nature and community politics of passing” (14).
Unlike Sharfstein, who considers passing a migration, not an exile, and rejects the idea that passing required a radical refashioning of identity and the severing of all social and familial ties, Hobbs emphasizes the ineradicable consequences of passing and highlights the emotional trauma of losing one's people (271). “Loss was a prerequisite of passing,” she writes (230). This may be truer for those left behind than for those who crossed the color line, but it is impossible to say given the sources. It is not clear that the Johnstons experienced a sense of loss on either side of their racial journey. Their decision to retire to Hawaii in 1966 speaks volumes, however, about where ambiguously raced Americans could be culturally comfortable (as well as warm).
