The considerable bibliography regarding the Etruscan buildings on the Piano del Tesoro plateau at Poggio Civitate notably lacks consensus about the site's primary function. The Archaic complex has been variously interpreted as an élite residence, a federal sanctuary, and a multi-functional community centre akin to an early forum, and while studies of the site's architectural terracottas, crafts, and small finds have proceeded apace, the basic character of the inhabitants, as both agents and audience, remains uncertain. This volume is consequently welcome for its new focus on the nearby burial ground of Poggio Aguzzo. Logistical difficulties mean that the full extent of the necropolis remains unknown and confine this study to nine fossa graves with finds discovered in 1972. All date between the middle and third quarter of the seventh century b.c. and are contemporary with the Orientalizing structures on the Piano del Tesoro. Anthony Tuck rightly notes that the tombs thus offer a rare opportunity to examine Etruscan burials not only as examples of funerary practice but also within the larger context of associated habitation and production areas. His careful analysis delivers in both respects.
The volume begins with a concise introduction (1–3) to the burial ground and its relationship to the rest of the site. The temptation to emphasize the site's prominence in Etruscan studies and heighten anticipation of the conclusions is resisted and replaced by admirably direct and useful statements. The next section (5–10) briefly describes each tomb with cross-references to the finds in the catalogue (99–129) and images in the black-and-white plates. The relative and absolute chronologies of the burials are then discussed (11–23).
The bulk of the book is dedicated to an analysis of the grave goods as soil conditions have largely precluded the preservation of human remains. The majority of the finds are pottery ceramics and, as the material predominantly consists of contemporary, typologically discrete forms, with few parallels from other sites, T. wisely chooses to examine potential sources for the vessels' shapes rather than develop a typology that would be relevant only to Poggio Aguzzo (25–48). As part of this investigation T. identifies five fabric types, including ‘orangeware’, a new designation, and gives brief but informative descriptions of bucchero, buccheroid, impasto, Protocorinthian, and orangeware that will be of use to many students beginning ceramic studies. The results suggest that early pottery production at Poggio Civitate featured a strong correlation between the form and fabric of the vessels: many bucchero and buccheroid items can be related to metal prototypes; orangeware shows an affinity to Protocorinthian forms; and the shape of impasto vessels references indigenous ceramic traditions. The following chapter examines pottery decorations that generally appear to have been less restricted to particular fabrics (49–72). Another chapter examines the metal spear-points, counter-weights, knives, daggers, arrow-heads, belt buckles, fibulae, and pins found in eight of the nine tombs (75–82).
The final section of the text attempts to place the community represented by the Poggio Aguzzo burials and the Piano del Tesoro buildings within the wider context of slowly urbanizing settlements in northern inland Etruria (83–98). Interestingly, while the inclusion of ceramics associated with food and drink in the graves accords with a widespread Etruscan conception of the deceased as a participant in a meal, the specific form of the burials appears highly distinctive, suggesting that fossa burials may exhibit local variations similar to funerary architecture. T. argues that particular burial forms may consequently have been associated with membership of a proto-urban community. The community using the simple fossa burials, however, with their lack of external monumentalization and expensive banqueting paraphernalia, do not appear to T. to have been the same as the group responsible for the ‘élite’ buildings on Piano del Tesoro. Comparison with developments at Satricum may give pause for thought here, as the nobles who built that site's tombe principesche in the first half of the seventh century are likely to have lived in non-descript huts (Waarsenburg in J. Rasmus Brandt et al., From Huts to Houses (2001)); one wonders whether such discrepancies between domestic and funerary architecture also represent the different priorities of the same social group in communities beyond Latium. The perceived absence of non-élite accommodation at Poggio Civitate further leads T. to suggest that proto-urbanism in inland Etruria may have featured a dispersed pattern of settlement, with subordinate communities on the nearby hills currently occupied by towns such as Murlo, Lupompesi and Montepescini, looking up to Poggio Civitate for leadership (96). Regardless of whether such a community meets current definitions of proto-urban settlements or not, this hypothesis succeeds in embedding the site back into populated surroundings, and it is to be hoped that the urge to label this community does not obscure further attempts to identify its members.
A few other remarks are warranted. References to building OC3/Tripartite as a likely example of religious architecture (20, 92, 95) trouble this reviewer, who regards a tripartite ground plan as insufficient evidence that a structure sheltered ritual activities, particularly given the use of a tripartite plan for many Late Orientalizing houses at Acquarossa. A plan showing the relationship between the Piano del Tesoro and Poggio Aguzzo would have been helpful (although this is discussed in the text), as would a plan of the Orientalizing buildings on Piano del Tesoro. Fig. 1 presents the location of Tombs 1–6 but lacks a scale. Typographic errors are few but regrettably early (2: ‘inlaied’ iron; 3: ‘vessels shapes’).
These are minor quibbles, however, and should not detract from a book written with satisfying concision and clarity. Those who can meet the considerable purchase price will find it a worthwhile addition to Etruscan bibliographies.
