Historians have long been attentive to the male world of the Welsh Marches and English frontier shires – to the activities of frontier barons, to military institutions and lordship, and even to the evolution of a Marcher identity in the aftermath of the Norman Conquest of England. The unsurpassed work of Rees Davies, and indeed the writings of many of his students and mentees in Oxford, has revolutionised our understanding of medieval Wales, and of the frontier between the monolithic kingdom of England and the several smaller kingdoms or principalities that made up what is now the nation of Wales.Footnote 1 In particular, the Welsh March (or Marches), that congeries of largely autonomous, and by no means static, lordships wedged between the English kingdom and Wales proper, or pura Wallia, has traditionally been seen as a man's world – shaped by men, for men: the barons, kings and Welsh princes. The historiographical March is a world in which women, if they feature at all, are cursorily skimmed over as adjuncts to the border lords who occupy centre stage, or as passive conduits for the transfer of land and alliance between men.
The prevailing model of the Welsh frontier is overdue for re-evaluation. It is time that historians of the March of Wales, or indeed of British frontier societies generally (for the expertise of Davies was by no means wholly confined to Wales and the Welsh frontier) engaged in closer scrutiny of the female place in, and contribution to, border societies in Britain during the central medieval period.Footnote 2 By the same token, historians interested in the medieval woman (and here particularly in the noble woman) ought not only to examine the impact of frontier existence on the propertied females whose lives were played out along the March before, and immediately after, the Edwardian Conquest of Wales (1282–3), but also to consider what the results of this examination might add to our understanding of the English noblewoman more generally, an area of research that, as far as lowland England is concerned, has made considerable headway in recent decades.
Of course, there can be little doubt that in many ways the Welsh March was a man's world. Medieval western society, as Margaret Howell has noted, was one ‘structured on patriarchy and male dominance’. Although historians disagree over whether the twelfth century or the thirteenth century was more hostile to women, western Christendom was ‘a society in which misogyny, at the level of theory, image and crude practice was rife’.Footnote 3 Add to this the overt warrior mentality of a military frontier, such as that between England and Wales, and one is looking at a world that was, ostensibly, more male-oriented than ever. The medieval March of Wales was a land of hard-bitten and competitive border men, whose castles were truly the caputs of their lordships, who championed their immunities from the common law of England and waged private warfare at will, and who might sooner force a royal messenger to eat his writ – parchment, seal and all – than take orders from the king.Footnote 4 Here, where the Marcher sword was rarely still, the feudal ethos took far longer to break down than in lowland England and contemporaries shuddered at the lawless reputation of the region and its inhabitants.Footnote 5 Little wonder, then, that modern historians of the Welsh frontier have tended to overlook the women of the March in favour of a focus on the barons, knights and castles that likewise fascinated and horrified the chroniclers of the time.
This essay proposes not so much to remedy the near-complete neglect (with one or two exceptions)Footnote 6 of the topic of women of the Welsh frontier, as to examine evidence relating to the greater noblewomen of the county and borderlands of Shropshire and, more specifically, to the widows of the barons and lords of the Shropshire frontier. By definition a landed woman, the English dowager (provided she was of full age) graduated from the tutelage of her husband, and came to the fore as a femme sole largely operating on a level with men: she was an estate administrator and manager of family affairs, she was prominent in the public sphere, she was highly visible in a broad cross-section of contemporary records and, most importantly, she has been the subject of extensive research by scholars interested in a range of issues including her dower rights and dower-related litigation at common law, the rise of jointure, the place of the noble widow in society and her family, and much more.Footnote 7 As this essay will show, despite the large body of excellent scholarship on the subject, the richness of the contemporary materials relating to the English medieval widow means that there is still more to be written. An examination of the activities and experiences of frontier dowagers is part of that process. This essay argues for very specific experiences attached to noble widowhood on the Welsh frontier, and for a unique relationship between widow and locality that highlights both the importance of women to a region often painted as ‘men only’, and the grave error made by scholars who fail to include women in their histories of the March of Wales.
Dower
The pattern and nature of dower assignment tells us something of the expectations of the socio-familial milieu in which the widow lived, and about contemporary attitudes toward the widow's provisioning. The priorities of the late husband and his family are perhaps especially evident when the arrangement was for pre-ordained dower (dos nominata), in the early days typically set out before the door of the church on the wedding-day itself; it might then be less than a third and need not be in land.Footnote 8 Such ‘church-door’ dower probably formed the basis of the arrangements made by William FitzAlan I (d. c. 1160), baron of Oswestry, at the time of his marriage to Isabel de Say around 1155, for Isabel subsequently acquiesced in the grant of her predetermined dower in Downton manor to Haughmond Abbey.Footnote 9 In return, her husband compensated her with several items of domestic use or ornament. It is unclear whether an interest in Downton was to have been Isabel's only dower land on the death of William FitzAlan, but by the mid-twelfth century it seems to have been typical of FitzAlan dower estates in the region. As a member of the important demesne manor of Upton Magna, Downton was located in the heart of central, lowland Shropshire, in the fertile lower Tern valley. It was also situated away from both the volatile Welsh border and the heavily fortified caput of the barony of Oswestry, itself located at the eastern edge of Shropshire's rugged north-west uplands.Footnote 10
From the combined governmental records of the dower allotted by the Crown to the widows of John FitzAlan I (d. 1240), John FitzAlan II (d. 1267) and John FitzAlan III (d. 1272) arises further information on the nature and location of Shropshire widows’ dower and, above all, a sense that the greater border dowager's lands were seldom situated in the principal estates of the barony – in line with Bracton Footnote 11 – or in the most turbulent regions of district. Certain manors were also re-assigned to FitzAlan widows in successive generations. Upton Magna, to which Isabel de Say's Downton interest had belonged, together with Cound, Acton Round and the ancient Roman centre of Wroxeter, each members of the barony of Oswestry, were allocated first to Hawise de Blancminster (d. 1242), widow of John FitzAlan I, and then to Maude de Verdun (d. 1284), widow of John FitzAlan II.Footnote 12 Evidently earmarked for widows’ upkeep, these four demesne manors lay roughly in a sixteen-mile, north–south line from the northern plain to the edge of the Clee Hills plateau, and encompassed some of Shropshire's most fertile lowland ground.Footnote 13
Most notably none of these estates was situated within fifteen kilometres of Offa's Dyke. Nor did the two widows’ demesne interests detract from the principal estates of the baronies of Clun and Oswestry. The matter was made explicit at the end of March 1240, when John Lestrange of Knockin, then sheriff of Shropshire and Staffordshire and custodian of the FitzAlan Marcher territories, was instructed to oversee the assignment of a reasonable dower to Hawise de Blancminster from ‘anywhere in the late baron's lands, except in Oswestry, Clun and Shrawardine’ – the three hubs of FitzAlan frontier power: ‘Mandatum est Johanni Extraneo quod assignari faciat Hawisie, que fuit uxor Johannis filii Alani, rationabilem dotem suam alibi in terris que fuerunt ipsius Johannis, exceptis terris que fuerunt ipsius Johannis de Albo Monasterio [Oswestry], Clun et Shrawurthin.’Footnote 14
For much of the thirteenth century, the strategic and heavily fortified manors of Oswestry, Clun and Shrawardine represented the principal foci of FitzAlan influence, and critically important staging posts along the northern and upper middle Marches, at a time when the Marcher lords were hunkering down to defend their footholds on the edge of pura Wallia. Oswestry and Clun, abutting the eastern flanks of Powys, Cedewain, Ceri and Maelienydd, had been hewn from the county proper by the beginning of the thirteenth century, while Shrawardine, probably still within the purview of royal administration, belonged to an interior line of defence against Welsh aggression within Shropshire.Footnote 15 At all three locations the obligations of castle-guard and army-service were immediate and pressing, and each, to varying degree, provided military-supply depots, places of rendez-vous and locations for parley between the English and Welsh. At the time of John FitzAlan I's death in 1240, Shrawardine had a newly re-constructed castle to replace that razed by the Welsh in 1215.Footnote 16 Military factors alone presumably rendered the three capital manors of Clun, Oswestry and Shrawardine largely unsuitable, in contemporary eyes, for the introduction of a dowager's interests.
The rationale behind the dower allocations described above cannot have been wholly negative, of course. The widow's third was her maintenance allowance (and sometimes that of her young children) after the death of her husband, a social security buffer which was especially crucial if she had no inheritance of her own or a relatively meagre marriage portion, and if she was disinclined or unable to remarry. There was little sense in allocating the widow properties whose annual yields were low, which were ruined by periodic warfare, or, in the most extreme cases, where the widow's own life might be endangered. As the townspeople of Oswestry were to learn to their cost in 1281, the proximity of an impressive fortress could not spare them from the Welshmen of nearby Nanheudwy, who raided the town and demanded a heavy ransom for their plunder.Footnote 17
By contrast to the cases of Hawise de Blancminster and Maude de Verdun, the pattern of dower allocation to Isabel de Mortimer, widow of John FitzAlan III (d. 1272), differed notably. Although, like Hawise de Blancminster, Isabel received the earmarked demesne estates at Little Ness and nearby Forton in western central Shropshire, and, like both of her predecessors, a host of further interests within and outside Shropshire, the manors of Acton Round, Upton Magna, Wroxeter and Cound were not assigned to her. Instead, contrary to the strictures applied to Hawise de Blancminster's dower assignment in 1240, Isabel was granted the whole of the sizeable, fortified demesne manor of Shrawardine, excepting only its satellite estate at Ensden, which initially fell to the king as (default) guardian of the under-age heir. In addition, Isabel was to have a third part of the wardship of the castle of Clun, as it arose, except in time of war, when dower was said not to apply.Footnote 18 In the last condition we have further suggestion that military considerations contributed to the shaping of a widow's dower on the March of Wales.
Several factors contributed to the nature of Isabel's dower assignment and marked it out from her predecessors’ portions, the most obvious being that Isabel's mother-in-law Maude de Verdun, was very much alive in the 1270s and still holding Acton Round, Upton Magna, Wroxeter and Cound in dower.Footnote 19 Moreover, when John FitzAlan III died in 1272, his son and heir Richard was a boy of only five or six, a ward of the Crown, and in no position to contemplate the management of his estates then or in the near future. Richard's extreme youth was a far cry from the relative maturity of his father and grandfather, who, aged eighteen and twenty respectively at the deaths of their own fathers, had presumably been capable of active military service despite their legal minority. With Richard FitzAlan still many years away from full age in 1272 the Crown had more room for manoeuvre when it came to the maintenance or temporary allocation of the FitzAlan estates. Yet the untimely death of John FitzAlan III in early March 1272, followed closely by the demise of Henry III and the absence of Edward I overseas, also left an essentially ‘headless’ Crown, and an important baronial familia with an opportunity to bargain over the widow's dower. In the circumstances of a long minority it arguably made sense for some of the dynasty's main estates to remain in the family rather than defaulting to the king, particularly in a restive frontier district where the authority of a locally aware and interested kinsman or woman might better serve the needs of family, locality and realm than the interference of external administrators or of a Crown-appointed guardian (although the latter could also be chosen from among close kin and neighbours). A widowed kinswoman might also be less exploitative than a royal appointee seeking to profit on his investment.
More importantly, changes were beginning to take place both on the frontier and within the FitzAlan family's own socio-political outlook, which may also have convinced Isabel de Mortimer's contemporaries that a widow's tenure of Shrawardine manor and castle was now a reasonable proposition. As the English kingdom recovered from the damage inflicted by civil war and the resurgent might of Gwynedd under Llywelyn ab Iorwerth (d. 1240), and as the Marcher lords found something more like a common cause in the struggle against Llywelyn ap Gruffudd (d. 1282), Shrawardine may have lost some of the direct strategic significance it had held in the days when the frontier lords more often laboured in their own bailiwicks against disunited Welsh incursions.Footnote 20 Perhaps it had also begun to lose its appeal to a dynasty which would soon move its principal seat to Arundel.
From what can be gleaned of dower allocation among the widows of the principal vassals, tenants and neighbours of the FitzAlan family, similar considerations applied: the avoidance of the core estates and the immediate frontier region.Footnote 21 The most notable exception was the dower of Alice d'Orreby, the widowed second wife of Peter Corbet I of Caus (d. 1300), for whom the shape and configuration of her late husband's barony necessitated her provisioning almost exclusively in Shropshire and the local March. In contrast to the cases just outlined, Alice held much of her dower close to, or directly on, the western border of Shropshire: her portion even included lands to the west of Offa's Dyke.Footnote 22 Particularly notable for its inclusion of territory in the region known as the Gorddwr, which had been the subject of the expansionist aggression of both Gruffudd ap Gwenwynwyn and Llywelyn ap Gruffudd, and was ever a bone of contention between the Corbets and the rulers of southern Powys,Footnote 23 Alice's dower in the barony of Caus did not, as I shall presently discuss, sit easy with her stepson Peter Corbet II, who did everything he could to harass his father's widow.
Yet the decision of Peter Corbet senior or his associates to allocate Alice's dower on the frontier is less surprising when it is considered that at the time of Corbet's marriage to Alice, around 1297,Footnote 24 the Marcher region had acquired a measure of stability. Edward I's conquest of Wales in 1282–3 had removed the immediate military threat to the border lordships, while the conversion of the native Welsh principality of Powys Wenwynwyn into the Marcher barony of Pool meant that Caus no longer lay hard against pura Wallia and its western-most regions were no longer the militarised frontlines they had once been.Footnote 25 Perhaps, too, Peter senior had intended that Alice should enjoy a share in those Marcher liberties, significantly free of royal control, which as yet the king was not apt to stifle; and it was probably with an eye to the Marcher lordships’ virtual immunity from royal authority that Peter junior showed such patent disregard for his stepmother's common law rights.
When it came to dower litigation in the courts of law, Shropshire dowagers certainly fared no better in this matter than their counterparts in other regions of England,Footnote 26 and they may even have fared worse against the tough border lords who operated at the furthest reaches of royal power.Footnote 27 Alice d'Orreby's feud with Peter Corbet II was bitter and protracted. Cast in the mould of his notorious grandfather, Thomas Corbet of Caus, Peter II harassed and bullied his stepmother, withheld dower, stalled and defaulted on dower suits and interfered in matters between Alice and her own tenants. In 1302 Alice complained that she had not been assigned her full share of the Corbet lands by her stepson, and in 1305 that Peter (with accomplices) had ejected her from certain of her Welsh tenements, stolen goods, usurped her judicial rights or blocked proceedings, broken into one of her parks and stolen beasts, poached large game from her reserve and even assaulted some of her men.Footnote 28 On two further occasions, when Alice attempted to distrain tenants for non-payment of services, her stepson armed his own tenants and launched a series of raids on her holdings, destroying property and removing the impounded cattle.Footnote 29
The testiness of Marcher lords likewise contributed to Maude de Verdun's trouble, this time with her own flesh-and-blood. In 1269 Maude, the widow of John FitzAlan II, ran into difficulties with her eldest son John III, who baulked at relinquishing £200 from the settlement of his late father's estate, despite an earlier agreement with the Crown, and played the well-worn Marcher-immunities card to justify his refusal to respond to the king's demands that he pay his mother immediately.Footnote 30 With great presumption, the twenty-two-year-old baron famously announced that ‘in the parts of the March where he now resided, he was obliged to do nothing at the king's mandate and nothing would he do’.Footnote 31 Rather than directly seeking to injure his mother, FitzAlan may well simply have been making a show of defiance toward the king. He was not the only Marcher baron to have done so, and he would not be the last.
For all that dower litigation at common law was a drawn out and often emotional experience for the English widow, the further westward one went the more difficult that experience seems to have become. Above and beyond the usual legal processes were questions of Welsh law and tenure, Marcher franchise or customs in time of war and the realities of cross-cultural fertilisation and hybridisation, which had to be considered before any decision could be handed down. The prickliness and ambition of many border lords, and their recourse to Marcher immunity, cannot have made the process any smoother. The complexities of frontier living were scarcely more evident than in the case of Emma d'Audley, relict of Gruffudd Maelor (d. 1269) of northern Powys, who was compelled to sue her son Llywelyn for the restoration of what appears to have been dower land in the commotes of Cynllaith and Nanheudwy. He had to be summoned twice before he relinquished the property.Footnote 32 A conflict of interests between Emma's English-style dower claims and her son's inheritance in Wales may lie at the heart of the dispute, and it is certainly conceivable that Welsh heirs of mixed marriages were reluctant to hand over land to their English mothers and into the purview of an alternative authority. When it came to the widow's common law rights, too, Welsh heirs may have found themselves thinking with fondness upon the old native law of dower which did not permit the widow an automatic share of her late husband's patrimonial lands.Footnote 33
But even as she was suing her son, Emma was seeking reinstatement in two manors in the Maelor district of northern Powys – Overton in Maelor Saesneg (English Maelor) and Eyton in Maelor Gymraeg (Welsh Maelor) – from which she claimed to have been evicted by the powerful Llywelyn ap Gruffudd during the recent warring between England and Wales.Footnote 34 The inquiry into the status of Overton conducted by the justice of Chester in July 1277 found that Emma had been granted a life-enfeoffment in the manor by her late husband, in accordance with the ‘custom of Wales . . . that any Welshman can give his lands to his wife, before or after marriage, at will’.Footnote 35 This was perhaps not dower per se, but a native Welsh custom that might be used to the same effect as English common law dower.Footnote 36 The inquisition further found that when the war broke out in early 1277, Llywelyn ap Gruffudd, prince of Wales, had seized Overton from Emma, who had remained in the king's faith (ad fidem domini Regis) through the war of 1276–7, and bestowed it upon his own adherent Madog ap Gruffudd Maelor, another of Emma's sons. On this issue, too, native Welsh law was ascertained: when anyone left their lands, for fear of war or for other reasons, and departed from Wales, the lord might seize the land as his escheat and do what he liked with it.Footnote 37 It seems that Emma may have fled the war-torn Maelor district.
Although Overton was soon restored to Emma, her claim to Eyton was complicated by the dower interests of her daughter-in-law Margaret, widow of Madog ap Gruffudd Maelor and, as it happens, also the sister of Llywelyn prince of Wales. After Madog's enfeoffment in Overton and Eyton by Llywelyn, he had granted the latter to his wife Margaret as (pseudo) dower, presumably under the same directives that had earlier permitted Emma's enfeoffment in Overton.Footnote 38 The need for further action was avoided when the two widows came to an agreement: the manor of Eyton was to be restored to Emma and Margaret was to hold it of her at farm at ten marks per annum. Margaret evidently had enough on her plate as it was, for the sources reveal that she too was picking up the pieces left by the depredations of her powerful brother.Footnote 39
Emma d'Audley's situation also highlights the meeting of two principal legal cultures, English and Welsh, and the effects of a dynamic interplay between divergent legal norms and practices upon aristocratic widows of the northern March – and especially on those who had married beyond Offa's Dyke. In entering a union with a Welsh man, Emma perforce acquired Welsh status, at least in the eyes of the society she had joined.Footnote 40 In the classical Welsh law of women, she should have had no rights in any land governed by Welsh tenure, her property interests in widowhood taking the form of moveables instead.Footnote 41 Yet it is also clear, as J. Beverley Smith has demonstrated, that by the mid-thirteenth century, even before the Statute of Rhuddlan (1284) had ironed out the contrast between cyfraith Hywel and the common law of England, widows of Welsh rulers occasionally received landed dower, along English lines, in Welsh territories.Footnote 42 Emma d'Audley and her daughter-in-law, Margaret, Angharad widow of Owain ap Maredudd (d. 1275) of Ceredigion, and the unnamed wife of Owain's father were among such women.Footnote 43
This spirit of compromise (if indeed that is what it was) or the adaptability of practice and procedure in the March and adjacent regions of pura Wallia is scarcely clearer than in the arrangements made by Gruffudd ap Gwenwynwyn for the distribution of his lands after his death. His English-born widow, Hawise Lestrange, was to have a dower third and his eldest son, Owain, lordship of the entire patrimony, as was the practice in England; those of Gruffudd's other sons who remained in the secular world (two became clerics) were to enter into a partible Welsh inheritance, each holding of the eldest brother.Footnote 44 The exact forces at work behind the creation of dower in land held by Welsh tenure is not clear; but it is highly possible that those ‘dowering’ Welshmen who entered into unions with English or Marcher lineages were guided by the demands of their in-laws. In more general terms, proximity or kinship to these lineages may have urged them to provide land for widows, like Angharad, who were not themselves of English or Marcher birth.Footnote 45
If the issue of Emma d'Audley's dower was not already complicated enough, her recovery of the manor of Overton was ultimately conditional upon the will of Edward I, whose interference in, and exploitation of, the Maelor region in the late thirteenth century was nothing short of notorious.Footnote 46 Having been granted restoration to Overton, Emma was compelled to acknowledge before the bench that she would return the same land to the king if he chose to grant her property elsewhere in England for the term of her life.Footnote 47 And this is exactly what the king did. In October 1277, seemingly even before Emma had even re-entered Overton, Edward I had already notified Chancery that he intended to make an exchange with her. Thirteenth months later the widow traded the land for an annual pension from the farm of the town of Derby, together with two manors in eastern Shropshire, free from any service obligations.Footnote 48 While Emma was clearly well rewarded for her compliance, it is impossible to ignore the fact that the king's uncompromising agenda in northern Powys at this interval had overridden both Emma's interests in her late husband's estates and the rights of the heirs to the reversion of those lands. Then again, Emma may actually have preferred the relative peace and security of dower in the lowland English territories.
Estate management
On the death of the husband an extensive range of managerial and administrative concerns fell to the widow, who as an independent member of landed society was, if not necessarily more active, certainly far more conspicuous than the married woman. What becomes apparent at first glance is the extent to which the functions and duties carried out by the independent, adult male were transferable to the independent, widowed female in the context of estate management. Both were prominent members of landholding society and, with the notable exception of bearing arms, the widow carried out much the same tasks as the male lord. She would presumably already have had extensive experience of estate management gained during marriage and, where her dower was concerned, functioned as an agent of continuity between old lord and new.
The FitzAlan demesne manors of Cound, Wroxeter, Acton Round and Upton Magna brought with them a host of duties and perquisites, which few were inclined to neglect. By the end of the thirteenth century, the FitzAlan demesnes in both frontier and lowland England represented a growing enterprise involving vast acreages of arable, meadow and farmland, large numbers of livestock, the exploitation of the waste, forest and waters of the lordship (a key means of asserting control over Welsh communities),Footnote 49 and presumably also the hives, bird decoys and the like found on the neighbouring Corbet estates.Footnote 50 Although no estate records survive to reveal any direct evidence of widows’ exploitation of demesne lordship, Alice d'Orreby's readiness to defend her game reserves, those jealously guarded features of the vast Marcher pasturelands, is evident in her complaints against park-breaking – complaints which, moreover, suggest that gender was not perceived as an impediment to demesne exploitation (or, indeed, to aristocratic recreational pursuits like hunting). Moreover, the widow who neglected the upkeep of the various instruments of demesne exploitation in her late husband's lands, or who allowed the destruction of forests, failed to keep land in cultivation, depleted animal-stocks or facilitated asset-stripping of any sort, was liable to prosecution. The responsibility of the widow as caretaker of the patrimonial third was critical and enforceable, as Maude de Verdun was to learn to her cost in March 1278, when she and her second husband, Richard de Amundville, were sued for waste in the woodlands which belonged to her dower.Footnote 51
More than in lowland England, baronial estates of the Welsh frontier placed enormous emphasis on judicial rights and on the seigneurial court, the instrument of lordship par excellence. While the FitzAlan widows were excluded from control over the great central courts at Oswestry and Clun, the lowland manor of Wroxeter, held in dower by Hawise de Blancmister and Maude de Verdun respectively, certainly included pleas of bloodshed and hue-and-cry, as well as the maintenance of a gallows.Footnote 52 In the barony of Caus, Alice d'Orreby's grievances against her stepson Peter Corbet II highlight the importance placed by lords on judicial rights over tenants, including the hearing of pleas in the manorial courts and entitlement to amercement, distraint and attachment.Footnote 53 For widows like Alice d'Orreby, who had no inheritances of their own, their judicial rights within their dower estates were arguably not only lucrative money-earners, but also important symbols of their own power and authority within the parameters of their lordships, which they could not easily have relinquished without loss of prestige.Footnote 54
Rees Davies has reminded us, too, that judicial lordship meant far more to medieval lords than law-keeping in the strictest sense. Judicial lordship lay at the very heart of the relationship between lord and tenant, and the court represented the intersection of their interests: here the lord ‘defined the services of his tenants and compelled them to pay their dues, supervised their land sales, registered their land-deeds, collected their death duties and reliefs, and exacted fealty from them’.Footnote 55 Here, too, he ensured that his tenants’ needs were met. Just as the lord expected to realise his or her rights over men, so his vassals anticipated the continuity of good lordship during a dowager's governance: the FitzAlan vassal Fulk FitzWarin of Whittington, whose services on a manor called ‘Hilfrich’ were assigned in dower to Isabel de Mortimer in 1272, could no more have made allowance for Isabel's failure to fulfil her responsibilities as lord than Isabel and her advisers would have tolerated any dereliction of duty by Fulk, the tenant.
Moreover, the gendered role of medieval women (particularly of queens) as intercessors, highlighted by Pauline Stafford and John Carmi Parsons,Footnote 56 may also have had particular resonance in the context of female lordship in medieval England, for a number of Shropshire widows directly petitioned a higher authority on behalf of tenants and other dependants. Most notably, when William Milicent of Ludlow was dispossessed of his lands while at court on business, his lord, the dowager lady of Chelmarsh, wrote to the chancellor, Walter de Merton, on Milicent's behalf.Footnote 57 Soon after the death of her first husband, Ralph le Botiler, Maude Pantulf likewise petitioned the king seeking redress for her ‘men of Wem’.Footnote 58 The intercessory function of the lordly widow may, in fact, have been rendered all the more critical in the March by the twin facts that judicial lordship was more comprehensive (through lack of conflicting or superior authority),Footnote 59 and that a woman could not take up arms on behalf of her tenants, a remedy that was not uncommon in a region where barons and knights could wage war at will.Footnote 60
Figures like William Milicent of Ludlow also remind us of the existence of staff who served the lord in regulating the day-to-day business of lordship over men and land. In large measure, the operation of the lord's deputies, seneschals, constables, stewards and the like, especially at the local level, helps to explain the ease with which noble widows stepped into the breach on the death of their husbands and, by the early fourteenth century, could hold anything up to an entire barony in jointure. The role of the individual lord, or even of gender, in influencing the actions of men and women in medieval England is not in doubt; but it is also true that neither the baron of Clun and Oswestry nor his widow personally supervised the ‘Monday-acres’ of the cottars on their Wiltshire demesnes, collected rent from the lessees installed at Acton Round after 1300, presided in the local courts, or kept watch from the castle turrets (except, perhaps, in siege conditions).Footnote 61 Far more at issue was the skill with which the widow, like her late husband, was able to function as a manager of property and people, a delegator of responsibility and a figurehead of power and lordship in the locality. This was as important a question for male lords as female.
Where the widow's role as lord had the potential to become more awkward, however, and where the lord's gender did become a central issue, was in a region where militarism was still a feature of everyday life. On the Welsh frontier before the final conquest of Wales, military power was not merely the ‘original foundation and ultimate sanction of lordship’,Footnote 62 but also remained an immediate necessity long after the winds of change had swept across lowland England. Seemingly most difficult to square with frontier life was the widow's automatic right to control an entire, fortified and strategic frontier lordship as her own inheritance. A number of high-ranking Marcher women inherited fortresses of varying size and importance. Indeed, it was hard to avoid doing so in a land that positively bristled with fortifications and where, more than anywhere else in England, the castle was truly the caput of the lordship.Footnote 63 In the most salient example from Shropshire, Isabel de Say, granddaughter of Earl Roger de Montgomery's henchman Robert ‘Picot’ de Say, became lady of Clun in her own right in the mid-twelfth century, and rightful lord of the single most important castlery on the Shropshire frontline.
Isabel de Say's almost constantly married state between c. 1155 and her death in 1199 (she married three times with little intermission) does not go unnoticed, and probably had as much to do with military expediency as with her exceptional value on the local marriage market. In 1160, at a time when Welsh attacks on the frontier were carried out with alarming regularity,Footnote 64 and when William FitzAlan II, Isabel's son from her first marriage and the heir to Clun and Oswestry, was little more than five years old, it was perhaps considered prudent to transfer the reins of military power at Clun to a male lord. That Magna Carta was still some years away makes it quite possible that the Crown intervened directly in Isabel's marital status. Henry II certainly demanded much of her second husband, who by marriage effectively became a ‘ring-in’ for FitzAlan lordship in Clun: Geoffrey de Vere was made sheriff of Shropshire in 1165. Moreover, the pipe roll evidence clearly reveals that, rather than remaining with Isabel in the period of her widowhood between the death of her first husband in c. 1160 and her marriage to de Vere in c. 1165, her own capital fortress at Clun was transferred to the control of the sheriff.Footnote 65 Assuming that Isabel was a legal adult in 1160 – and, admittedly, this is not certain – then the Crown's action was remarkable.
Yet the relationship between widow and fortress on a militarised frontier is not as cut-and-dry as this example might suggest, for there were also individuals for whom widowhood in a turbulent frontier zone enabled them to carve out an alternative means of participation. This was an essential paradox of Marcher life. While Isabel de Say was afforded few openings for independent castle administration on her own inherited estates, other dowagers assumed roles directly associated with the management of fortresses on their late husbands’ properties. Not only did Isabel de Mortimer have dower in Shrawardine Castle – a stronghold of lessening but not inconsiderable importance in 1272Footnote 66 – but in 1280 she was also appointed to the custody of her late husband's castle of Oswestry on the Shropshire frontline. Precisely what Isabel de Mortimer's role at Oswestry entailed is difficult to determine. The wording of her appointment on the patent rolls is singularly vague; but among her final duties was the arming and victualing of the fortress for the in-coming garrison at the commencement of the second Welsh war in 1282, suggesting that even if she were not the resident castellan, her custody gave her oversight of the martial aspects of the castle's administration. As I shall presently discuss, Isabel's command of Oswestry Castle also belonged both to her own broader enterprise in her late husband's lands and to Mortimer ambition in middle and northern Marches at this time.
The appointment of women to the custody of castles was neither entirely novel nor purely honorary, particularly under politically sensitive or highly irregular circumstances. The redoubtable Nicholaa de la Haye was made castellan of Lincoln Castle in 1215, an appointment which Louise Wilkinson has revealed rested on a combination of hereditary claim to the post and prodigious personal ability, and belonged squarely to the context of King John's deteriorating fortunes.Footnote 67 Over a century later, Aline, widow of the Shropshire lord and royal administrator, Edward Burnel of Acton Burnell, was granted custody of the great royal citadel of Conway in Caernarvonshire from January to October 1326.Footnote 68 Aline was a Despenser and the Despensers were in grave danger: they had not troubled to cultivate a party of supporters in England and, with resentment against them building, turned to family members to hold key positions.Footnote 69 As an autonomous and clearly robust member of landed society – she lived until 1363 – Aline was perhaps not such an extraordinary choice for the office. The notice of her appointment entered on the original patent roll states that she was to receive ‘the keepership of our castle of Conway (custodiam castri nostri de Coneweye)’ during pleasure; she took office at her own risk, being responsible for the safe-keeping of the castle and receiving an allowance.Footnote 70 The castle came fully stocked with armour and victuals, and Aline presumably had to answer at the Exchequer for the issues of the castle, as her successor was required to do.Footnote 71 As a linchpin of her family's ambition she may have been expected to reside there during her tenure.Footnote 72
Similarly, the dowager countess of Arundel, Isabel widow of Earl Hugh d'Aubigny (d. 1241), was made constable of the royal castle of Portchester, with an annual stipend of 16 marks, for the period of March 1268 to May 1272. She, too, assumed the usual duties of building maintenance and rendering account at the Exchequer.Footnote 73 In two separate notices on the original liberate rolls Isabel d'Aubigny is referred to both as constable of Portchester Castle and as custos or keeper, terms which, at least as far as male post-holders were concerned, appear to have been largely interchangeable.Footnote 74 In this particular case, any attempt to establish whether the Latin nouns constabularius or custos were rendered as masculine or feminine when applied to women, and thus whether (in theory at least) contemporaries might have viewed the post as inherently gendered, is foiled by scribal abbreviation and Latin grammar: in the first instance the scribe has simply written constabul’, and in the second the word custos, of Greek derivation, is both masculine and feminine in form.
Nevertheless, the existence, recorded elsewhere,Footnote 75 of terms like cunestabularia and châtelaine (the latter also denoting lady's girdle from which hung personal and household keys) suggest that not only did there exist scope for female appointment, but that contemporaries had a theoretical place for female post-holders that found its way into the vocabulary of government. It was not especially common to find female keepership, constableship or custodianship – terms that were vague, overlapping and sometimes interchangeableFootnote 76 – but it was far from unheard of. Legal status and managerial acumen where what really mattered in the first instance.
When it came to the militarised and often turbulent March of Wales, however, the normative relationship between the noblewoman and the castle became rather more problematic. On the one hand the fluidity and adaptability of aristocratic life on the March meant that independent landed women like Isabel de Mortimer might, with tenacity and ability, carve out a leading role in the management of strategic fortresses and the holding of the frontline. Indeed, it was sometimes the only suitable course of action. On the other hand, the very warlike nature of the frontier region also dramatically increased the likelihood that the female lord might be denied, or stood down from, castle governance: combat offered little room for women in thirteenth-century England and Wales, except under extraordinary circumstances.Footnote 77 The ambitious and fully able Isabel de Mortimer was removed from control of her late husband's castles when full-scale war with the Welsh broke out in 1282.
The widowhood of Isabel de Mortimer
Isabel de Mortimer, daughter of Roger de Mortimer of Wigmore and Maude de Braose, was not an heiress. Her brother Edmund was destined to inherit her family's burgeoning estates, and her own value lay principally in the marriage market and the connections her marriage would forge between her natal family and kin and those of the man she married. Still in her teens, Isabel was married to the heir apparent to the neighbouring frontier baronies of Clun and Oswestry and the earldom of Arundel, and much of her young life was spent under the guidance and protection of her husband and his family. Despite (perhaps even because of) Isabel's limited access to land through birth, her widowhood saw her determinedly carve out an administrative portfolio within her late husband's estates, which she continued to manage on behalf of the Crown until shortly before her second marriage in 1285.
We have seen above that Isabel de Mortimer's extensive dower assignment differed from that of her two immediate predecessors to FitzAlan widowhood in its inclusion of the manor and castle of Shrawardine, traditionally an important staging post along the lower northern March. Although they were soon to become more settled, the conditions of the March in the 1270s were nevertheless still such that they directly interfered with the straightforward allocation of Isabel's dower, which, for a variety of reasons, had to be assigned to her piecemeal over a number of years.Footnote 78 The requisite pre-dower surveys of the FitzAlan estates had been carried by the August of 1272, when a strikingly detailed snapshot of the FitzAlan territories in the March and the d'Aubigny inheritance in lowland England, and of their division between Isabel as John III's widow and the king as default guardian of the young heir and his estates, was entered on the close rolls.Footnote 79 Isabel's interests were extensive and valuable. In Shropshire she received not only Shrawardine manor and castle, but also a third of the issues of the markets, fairs, ale tax (prisa cervisie), the Oswestry borough courts and watermills, as well as extensive arable, meadow, moorland and woodland rights.Footnote 80 In Welshry she was to have an array of interests attached to the barony of Oswestry.Footnote 81 A series of knights’ fees were also assigned to the young widow, the most notable of which were held by John Lestrange and Fulk FitzWarin.Footnote 82 Nor did Mortimer control over the FitzAlan inheritance in the March stop at Isabel, for her father Roger was soon granted custody of the manor and castle of Clun, £100 of adjacent land and the Shrawardine satellite of Ensdon, to hold until Richard FitzAlan came of age.Footnote 83
As the royal letters close reveal, the assignment of Isabel de Mortimer's dower was a far simpler task in lowland England than on the troubled border. Even after the substantial and carefully thought-out allocations outlined above, there remained sizeable omissions in Isabel's dower, largely consequent upon the activities of Llywelyn ap Gruffudd on the frontier at Clun during the 1260s. In the months and years that followed Isabel's initial dowering, several additional allocations were made to her, including a stop-gap measure implemented by her father, Roger de Mortimer;Footnote 84 but, although Isabel's dower claims in the honour of Arundel appear to have been settled by mid-1274, it was nearly twelve years before she finally received the full third that she was entitled to in her late husband's border territories. It was not until the end of 1284 that the final settlements were carried out: Isabel received seven towns in the Welshry of Portlock, together with extensive interests in the borough and forest of Clun and in the Tempseter Welshry of Clun.Footnote 85
The hill district of Tempseter, west of Offa's Dyke and largely Welsh in character,Footnote 86 had been occupied by Llywelyn ap Gruffudd from the late 1260s until he was ejected by Isabel's father, Roger de Mortimer, in 1277.Footnote 87 Although Mortimer, as custodian of Clun, had thus reclaimed the barony's western-most lands, no action was taken toward dowering Isabel in the region until both her father and the prince of Wales were dead. Nor does Isabel appear to have made any attempt to sue for dower here, and it is possible that Mortimer's substitute gift of Ensdon in Shrawardine, and of additional issues of Oswestry mill, both of which derived from the heir's portion of the FitzAlan estates held in trust by Mortimer, was a private agreement between father and daughter intended to supplement her existing dower and forestall any need for litigation. Once Isabel had been granted custody of her Welshry interests at Clun, she was required to return Ensdon and the issues of Oswestry mill to the executors of her late father's will.Footnote 88
The requirements of administration and management attached to her dower estates alone must have presented Isabel with a formidable challenge. Not only was she faced with the day-to-day running and longer-term maintenance of these holdings, but restiveness of the March on the eve of the final Edwardian campaigns in Wales probably heightened the need for security and vigilance in her Shropshire territories. Isabel's lands in the March were flanked by the custodial interests of her father, who held both the Clun castlery and his grandson (Isabel's son) in wardship, thereby presumably providing military support in the region and, perhaps too, paternal guidance; but Isabel herself may well have taken something from the lessons of her past. During the early days of Isabel's marriage, Llywelyn ap Gruffudd had seized control of the western fringes of Clun from her father-in-law, John FitzAlan II. Neither Isabel nor her ambitious and war-hardened father, who had lost extensive possessions in the March to Llywelyn between 1258 and 1263,Footnote 89 were likely to have forgotten those times in a hurry. Isabel had presumably also witnessed much of the civil strife of the mid-60s, which was largely played out in the March and contiguous counties, and in which her father and father-in-law had ultimately become prominent royalist partisans.Footnote 90 Indeed, it was to Isabel's own mother, Maude de Braose, that Simon de Montfort's severed head and genitals were said to have been sent as a trophy in 1265.
By 1276, only four years after her husband's death, Isabel de Mortimer had also begun to carve out a business enterprise for herself over and above her dower territories. In January 1277, in what appears to have been the first in a series of steps toward the deliberate augmentation of her footholds in the FitzAlan lands, Isabel obtained custody from the Crown of properties directly abutting her dower in the county of Sussex. Comprising lands and rents in Westdon and Charlton and a moiety of the hundred of Stockbridge, valued at around £35 a year, these interests were to be held in trust until her son came of age.Footnote 91 By 1280 Isabel had also taken control of the castle and the entire honour of ArundelFootnote 92 as well as the farm of the hundred and township of Oswestry in the Shropshire March.Footnote 93 As long as she kept abreast of the requisite yearly payments – and there is every indication that she did soFootnote 94 – Isabel de Mortimer could expect more or less free rein in the managements of land, and the administration of the courts and other perks of lordship. But more was to still come. In November 1280, in response to her own petition to the king the year before, Isabel was awarded full custody of the castle of Oswestry hard on the Welsh frontier.Footnote 95
Isabel's custodial tenures came with several attendant obligations, including providing the abbot of Vale Royal in Cheshire with a total of £300 a year for his building works, and ensuring that the archbishop of Canterbury received twenty-six deer a year from the forest of Arundel, in accordance with a grant made by an ancestor of her late husband. She was also ordered to allow the archbishop to hunt in the forest every year on his way to and from his manor of Slindon in central Sussex.Footnote 96 Isabel's management skills were clearly sound, and perhaps even above average, and I have suggested elsewhere that she may have been involved in the extensive survey of the FitzAlan estates undertaken at the end of the thirteenth century and known today as ‘Book A’ of the Two Estate Surveys of the FitzAlan Earls of Arundel.Footnote 97 Most tellingly, Isabel's view of her own ability as equal to that of any male lord was expressed in another petition to the king around 1279, in which she requested grace of scutage on the grounds that she had defended the March as well as her neighbours during the Welsh war of 1277; if granted the waiver, moreover, she pledged to redirect the same funds toward the castle of Oswestry which was dilapidated (decheu).Footnote 98 Isabel was clearly willing to bargain with the Crown for the augmentation of her interests, and it is interesting that she did so around the time that her father was rewarded for his role in the same Welsh war.Footnote 99
The prominence of Isabel's natal family during her adult career, and her own part in the fulfilment of Mortimer ambition in the March, are not acknowledged by historians, but are without doubt critical to the history of the region on the eve of the Edwardian conquest of Wales. From the very commencement of Isabel's thirteen-year widowhood, her father was the guardian of her infant son, the future earl of Arundel, Richard FitzAlan, and of the larger part of the FitzAlan barony and castlery of Clun, creating a circumstance in which Isabel's own sphere of influence lay check-by-jowl with that of her father in the northern and middle Marches. These factors alone must have encouraged regular communication between father and daughter, but the evidence that Roger de Mortimer supplemented his daughter's dower holdings in the barony of Clun during Llywelyn ap Gruffudd's occupation of Tempseter suggests that theirs was a cooperative relationship. Roger de Mortimer had been assigned responsibility for the security of the middle March during the Welsh campaign of 1277, and may actively have enlisted his daughter's assistance in extending his influence along the frontier, and particularly to secure the region around Clun. Between the two Welsh wars Roger and Isabel de Mortimer (with the assistance of Maude de Braose) together controlled most of the western front from the lower edge of Cheshire to southern Herefordshire.
If this period was ‘the high summer of Roger de Mortimer's career’, as historians have stated,Footnote 100 it was also his daughter's finest hour. By creating and running a business enterprise in her late husband's properties that bolstered her dower territories, Isabel not only supplemented her own power and wealth in widowhood, but dramatically increased Mortimer influence in the March (and elsewhere). She was a mainstay of Mortimer power in the FitzAlan territories at the end of the thirteenth century and, as she herself acknowledged, an important contributor to the security of the March on the eve of Edward I's final conquest of Wales. It is impossible now to determine where the ambition of Isabel's natal family ended and her own personal drive began – nor should they necessarily be separated out – but it seems certain not only that she and her father, and perhaps also her mother, reinforced each other's career successes in the decade between 1272 and 1282, but also that she was herself, like the far better known Maude de Braose, an ambitious, determined and fully capable woman. Given that she petitioned for grace of scutage and custody of Oswestry Castle around the same time that her father received reward for his services in the first Welsh war, and that she deliberately emphasised her own role in frontier security, Isabel was probably as eager for recognition and reward as the indefatigable Roger de Mortimer of Wigmore.
In June 1282, a new war against Wales underway, Edward I took the decision to relieve Isabel of her custodies in Oswestry and Arundel, and from Rhuddlan in August that year he ordered that these same interests be made over to Isabel's thirty-year-old brother, Edmund de Mortimer.Footnote 101 Still at Rhuddlan in November, the king ordered that Isabel's accounts for Oswestry Castle be audited and that she be reimbursed for all expenses incurred in fitting out the castle after the commencement of the war.Footnote 102 With a full-scale Crown enterprise underway in Wales and Isabel herself in no position to wield a sword, Edward I presumably wished to place the greater Mortimer and FitzAlan castles under the command of a single, strenuous leader, who could be relied upon to hold the middle and lower northern Marches and to fight when necessary. By August 1282, moreover, Isabel's notably supportive father, Roger de Mortimer, had only eight or ten weeks left to live, and Edmund was emerging as head of the Mortimer family. Perhaps Isabel's influence was deliberately stymied by her younger brother, irritated by their father's reliance upon his sister rather than him, or perhaps she was a casualty of the will of Edward I, whose policy toward the governance of the March may have undergone re-appraisal on the eve of the conquest of Wales (or, indeed, the demise of the once powerful Roger de Mortimer). We do not know what Isabel thought of her total dispossession of her Marcher and lowland custodies, but given the self-belief she expressed in 1279, she may not have been entirely pleased. Deprived of her custodial enterprises at the end of 1282, Isabel had re-married by 1285 and was once again shrouded by that greater obscurity that had surrounded her marriage to John FitzAlan III.
Conclusions
The main purpose of this essay has been to consider some of the implications for the English noble widows of life on a military frontier. The widow's dowering in a frontier region certainly seems to have brought its own unique considerations to the bargaining table. The importance of the lordship's military integrity and the centrality of the fortified caput and castlery underscored the generally held principle that a widow's dower should not be allocated in the most important of her late husband's estates. Few Shropshire widows in the period under discussion received dower either in property that had been central to their late husband's lordship, or in the traditional hotspots of the border. To the threat of border skirmishing or larger-scale land seizures, such as were perpetuated by Llywelyn ap Gruffudd in the 1260s, might also be added the scope for the circumvention of royal authority and resistance of legal process offered by Marcher immunities – to say nothing of the character of some of those war-hardened marchiones who inhabited the region. Family relations, complex at the best of times (especially where step and in-law relationships were involved), might be further problematised by the introduction of inter-cultural marital alliances into the mix. Yet these factors, doubtless highly variable, not only reveal the unique conditions of the frontier and their effect on widows’ dowering, but also throw into relief the agency of the widow herself in the working-out of her dower, and in its defence and maintenance.
Despite the potential for trouble between widow and heir, there is also evidence to suggest that, far from being automatically resented as a burden on the heir's lordship, the widow was often seen as an agent of continuity, especially during a protracted minority: she was already familiar with the estates she held and integral to the web of connection and kinship embracing the aristocratic family. Her managerial expertise, and that of the men and women responsible to her, was perhaps particularly useful with regard to regions where Welsh or hybrid customs obtained – customs which might have confounded the outside lord but with which she and her staff were presumably familiar. I have also suggested, moreover, that the noble widow might have had an intercessory role between her tenants and her own lord (usually the Crown), that was especially important in a region where judicial lordship was all but comprehensive, and where the female lord could not fight on behalf of her tenants.
Indeed, the bearing of arms was the main sticking point for female lordship, and it has been necessary therefore to examine the implications of militarism on the widow's tenure of castles, and the nature of her control over fortresses in a region where the waging of war was a relatively immediate concern. I have suggested above (and am not alone in doing so) that the actual bearing of arms was the only area of castle governance from which women were barred. It was only when warfare loomed that that the female lord might find herself sidelined. Isabel de Mortimer was relieved of her custody of Oswestry and Arundel Castles when war with the Welsh broke out for a second time in 1282; Isabel de Say of Clun either eschewed, or was debarred from, the administration of her own inherited castlery on the doorstep of native Wales during the second half of the twelfth century.
Life on the March could certainly be difficult for women; but it also brought them opportunities for action, underscoring the critical importance of their functions as managers of land and family, and enabling certain dowagers to carve out prominent roles in the maintenance of frontier security. The close study of noblewomen of Shropshire and the adjacent March of Wales not only sheds light on the lives, roles and personalities of women who lived in the region, thereby also adding to what we know about the English medieval noblewoman generally, but also clearly demonstrates that this ostensibly male, militarised zone cannot, in fact, be fully understood without the inclusion of the female members of aristocratic society. Nothing is more telling than the (hitherto unacknowledged) fact that Isabel de Mortimer, daughter of far more famous parents, Roger de Mortimer and Maude de Braose, actively helped her father to hold the frontier at Shropshire on the eve of the Edwardian Conquest of Wales.
