This insightful, wide-ranging volume provides a revealing window into current scholarship on urbanisation, class formation, state relations, and housing in Latin America. It is a welcome addition to the somewhat inchoate field of housing studies, a field that has long been influenced by perspectives from Latin America. An interdisciplinary venture, the volume includes contributors from sociology, anthropology, geography, architecture and urban planning and design. One of the editors, Ouweneel, is an historian. While most contributors adopt interdisciplinary elements in their approaches, they develop their interpretations from their own disciplinary perspectives. Accordingly, the book's approach to housing and belonging does not contain a tightly defined theoretical or methodological direction, but rather suggests varied paths of study.
The editors seek to develop an intricate, nuanced understanding of housing and urbanisation, in which empowerment and constraints, possibilities and injustices, exist side by side. The overall approach grants the contributors the freedom to develop their work on their own terms. The contributors do so through case studies from Brazil, Colombia, Mexico, Argentina and Peru. While these countries do not cover all of Latin America, they are distinct enough to make fruitful generalisations possible. Just as importantly, the book contains overlapping, yet varied takes on particular cities, granting the volume empirical depth and richness in interpretation.
The book contains a series of articles on the uneven processes through which squatter settlements have become consolidated in Latin America. Such consolidation has granted many Latin Americans a greater security in land tenure, but it has also included processes of neoliberal restructuring that have, on balance, led to less secure forms of employment, expanding debt loads and heightened criminality. Byran Roberts, a sociologist influential in the first wave of studies on squatters in the 1960s and 1970s, provides a general, insightful overview of these changes.
Many other contributors pick up on the themes that Roberts presents, at the same time that they provide fruitful new directions for research. In a contribution on Lima, Michaela Hordijk underscores how second-generation inhabitants of these neighbourhoods now focus on attaining homes ‘through one's own effort’, rather than on the collective actions that once marked seizing land and gaining access to infrastructure. In a wonderfully suggestive chapter on Mexico City, Erika Denisse Grajeda studies how the pioneers who first settled squatter settlements bequeath their homes to their children. With great insight, Grajeda develops how ideas about who deserves to inherit a house uncover fundamental tensions involving the right to scarce resources, the making of home, and family relations. In another excellent contribution, Fernando Luiz Lara demonstrates how the self-builders of Brazil's favelas have adopted modernist designs in constructing their homes. In illuminating this fascinating phenomenon, Lara casts the massive construction processes that have gone into the making of Latin American cities since the mid-twentieth century in a provocative new light.
As with all studies of urban life generally and of Latin American cities in particular, this volume must counteract the existing interpretations that dominate discussion. In this regard, housing in Latin America has been a particularly problematic topic, as two ideologically charged understandings have generally informed opinions on the subject. In the first instance, academics (and a broad range of reformers and revolutionaries) have often portrayed the massive number of squatters and the subsequent poor conditions in the urban periphery as an indication of all that is wrong with the Latin American city. Partially in response, a very different group of academics have viewed squatters as ingenious pioneers who have courageously carved out vibrant spaces for themselves and would succeed further if the state could bring them out of the shadows and legalise their housing lots. Certain powerful development institutions and famous politicians who support a generally unfettered free market (ranging from the World Bank to Margaret Thatcher) picked up on this latter narrative in order to justify property-titling programmes.
The political charge behind these views is rather obvious: one indicts capitalism and the other celebrates it, while each includes different ideas about both the role of the state and what kinds of social actors squatters are and might be. Housing and Belonging generally seeks to avoid these ideologically charged views, and, in keeping with the book's overall approach, focuses instead on nuance and openness. Yet if this permits the contributors to present innovative new lines of inquiry, it also leads the book into certain problems, as it often elides critical issues of politics, power and history.
It is not that these themes are entirely absent. Two works on the middle class in Buenos Aires and another on more consolidated working-class homes in northern Colombia perceptively focus on how class distinctions and tastes figure in the contemporary making of homes and identity. In a fascinating chapter that explores similar themes, Christina Inclán-Valadez examines massive lower-middle income housing developments in Mexico and reveals how construction interests and marketing efforts profit from and feed into the making of class through home improvements and additions.
Other chapters contain criticisms of the workings of the state. In their contribution on the massive increase in federal housing programmes in Buenos Aires since the early 2000s, Fernando Ostuni and Jean-Louis Van Gelder analyse how these programmes have largely failed to deliver on their promises. They insightfully reveal how the cosy relationship between the state and the construction industry has been a significant factor in this failure. In their chapter on Medellín, José Samper and Tamera Marko develop how residents of consolidating squatter settlements seek to narrate and make sense of their lives in oral histories. Adopting a novel, socially engaged, and collaborative methodology, the authors seek to recover voices and experiences that are often drowned out by the dominant discourses emanating from the state and the mass media. In a chapter on Rio de Janeiro, Palloma Menezes investigates how the residents of a small section of a favela that is scheduled for removal have sought to remain in place. In doing so, she exposes the often fraught and limited spaces within which citizens seek to claim rights and gain sympathy from broader publics.
The volume, then, contains critical and astute interpretations of certain dynamics of power and inequity. Most of the contributors, moreover, recognise the importance of neoliberal reforms and the subsequent influence of leftist policy frameworks in much of Latin America. Still, the authors only occasionally hit on themes of ideology and conflict, violence and coercion, and (in)security and indebtedness. Yet in ostensibly covering a period from the mid-twentieth century to the present, the book examines an era dominated by intense polarisation, violent dictatorial regimes, massive social schisms, ambitious, wide-ranging development projects, and a deepening of the market, especially under neoliberalism. This volume, however, only sporadically deals with these issues.
Somehow, housing and belonging seems not to wholly belong within the purview of such crucial phenomena. As such, the ideologically charged narratives that have framed debates (and actions) surrounding housing are not themselves an object of study. If this volume presents rich new directions in the study of urban residence and its intersections with state policies, family life, spatial dynamics, and class distinctions, it also underscores the need for further work on the evolution of housing and belonging in Latin America.
