In September 2010, the Central de Trabajadores de Cuba (Cuban Trade Union Confederation, CTC) announced the state's plan to transfer one million unproductive state sector workers into alternative employment between 2011 and 2015. At that point, Cuba's workforce was 5.2 million, of whom 800,000, or 15.4 per cent, already worked in the non-state sector, mostly in agricultural cooperatives whose product featured in the central plan and a proportion of which was to be sold to the state. Just 140,000 Cubans, or 2.7 per cent of the total workforce, were self-employed. The official unemployment rate was low at 1.7 per cent. However, this figure excluded workers in the informal economy (where earnings were often higher and no tax was paid), those not seeking employment and those who had no work to do (due to a lack of inputs, for example) but remained on payrolls, receiving a reduced salary.
By 2015, the number of non-state sector workers had risen to 1.4 million, some 28 per cent of the workforce. Half a million of them were registered as self-employed (around 10 per cent); 7,700 workers were in nearly 500 cooperativas no agrícola (non-agricultural cooperatives, CNAs), new entities launched in 2010; and over 200,000 were ‘usufruct’ farmers (private producers who lease land, rent-free and under conditions from the state). With the exception of the long-standing agricultural cooperatives, still employing the largest proportion of non-state workers, these sectors are the focus of this book by renowned Cubanologist Carmelo Mesa-Lago.
From these soaring numbers, the analysis presented in Mesa-Lago's book is based on interviews with just 80 individuals. These interviews are divided into four categories and were conducted between September 2014 and December 2015. Following an overview on the emerging non-state sector and its importance, there are chapters dedicated to (i) self-employed workers, (ii) usufruct farmers, (iii) members of non-agricultural and service cooperatives and (iv) those buying and selling dwellings. Each of these chapters has sections on antecedents, characteristics, advances, obstacles and impact before introducing the results and analysis of the 25 interviewees in each category, except the CNA members, with whom only five interviews were conducted. This material is interesting and the interviews, carried out by assistants in Cuba, were clearly well prepared. However, the sample is extremely small and interviewees were selected ‘using non-probabilistic methods’; therefore, as Mesa-Lago recognises, ‘the sample is not representative’ (p. 10).
The question this raises for the reader is about the utility of an analysis based on a tiny, unrepresentative sample in which, for example, two interviewees can count for 33 per cent in the survey results (p. 31). In fact, on some points the sample inverts the national standard so, for example, of the five interviews carried out with members of CNAs, four were in ‘self-made’ cooperatives set up by members’ own initiative and only one was in a so-called ‘conversion’ cooperative where former state employees convert into cooperative members under state directives. Nationally, however, less than a quarter of cooperatives established by 2015 were self-made.
The decision to add the category of those ‘buying and selling dwellings’ is rather incongruous. The 2011 reforms authorised a free market for the purchase and sale of dwellings between Cuban citizens and foreign residents on the island. In 2014 the self-employment category of ‘agents for swaps and purchase/sales of dwellings’ was authorised. However, property ownership in Cuba is legally restricted to two homes, and 20 of the interviewees consulted (80 per cent) were not ‘brokers’ – they owned one property only and were therefore interviewed on the basis of one act of sale/purchase, which does not constitute an occupation. Indeed, the chapter is mostly concerned with housing construction, including the lack of materials (but without mentioning the US blockade).
What is really missing is a political economy narrative to help the reader understand why employment is being restructured and a non-state sector introduced, and how these factors are expected to relate to the centralised state plan or the socialist system more broadly. What are the objectives and imperatives that drive these changes? Without this analysis, it is difficult to understand why the issuing of licences to non-state workers was frozen between August 2016 and December 2018, why the restrictions in place exist or why they have been reinforced or waivered at different points.
‘The book's main objective’, according to Mesa-Lago, ‘is to offer key otherwise unavailable information about the NSS [non-state sector]’ (p. 1). However, by the time the English edition of this book was published, a growing body of work (largely authored by Cubans) analysing the non-state sector and covering all the aspects Mesa-Lago presents (and others) had emerged. That research is based on more extensive quantitative and qualitative analysis. For example, Yailenis Mulet Concepción's fascinating study of private sector shoemakers:
The research took six months of field study in five Cuban provinces. We interviewed 44 manufacturers (out of a total of 72) who have been operating for ten to 20 years, and ten production workshops were thoroughly studied. In addition, 120 workers were interviewed (including manufacturers, vendors and hired workers), as well as different workers in the state sector, central government officials, suppliers and clients. (‘Self-Employment in Cuba: Between Informality and Entrepreneurship – the Case of Shoe Manufacturing’, Third World Quarterly, 37: 9 (2016), p. 1717).
Cuban researchers I have consulted on these issues for my own work have highlighted some of the complex contradictions generated by the emergence of the non-state sector, including the conflicting interests of the formerly ‘self-employed’ workers who are actually now small-business owners, and the ‘contracted’ workers they employ. While legal since 2010, this relationship of exploitation (in the Marxist sense), was in contravention to the 1976 Cuban Constitution and one of the developments which made the updating of the Constitution an imperative. The New Constitution was approved in February 2019. However, for discussions about the implications of these new social relations in revolutionary Cuba and the impact on income inequality, trade unions, political cohesion and so on, the reader will have to look elsewhere because these important questions are not tackled by Mesa-Lago.
