No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 01 May 2004
This modest volume by a long-time ethnographer of Kufr al-Ma, a village in Jordan, will serve lower-division college classes with a non-confrontational and comparative way into some of the issues surrounding contemporary fundamentalisms. Antoun uses “fundamentalism” in the singular as an “ideal type” constructed of six characteristics (scripturalism, “traditioning,” selective modernization, totalism, cosmic struggle of good and evil, activism) not applicable to any individual or in toto to any group. This has advantages and disadvantages. The advantages are that Christian, Jewish, and Muslim fundamentalisms can be seen against a common repertoire of strategies yet as responding to distinctive historical contexts: the Holocaust for Jews, colonialism for Muslims, positivist science and secularism for Christians. “The aim,” says Antoun, is “to bring out the commonalties in thought and action, belief and practice” (p. xi). The disadvantages are that one gets a typology of groups and strategies without much in depth socio-historical analysis or trans-national connectivities or any other conclusion than a genial—but very important—ecumenicism.
Insofar as there is an explanation of why fundamentalisms should have arisen at the end of the 20th century, Antoun relies on Bruce Lawrence's definition of the “ideology of modernism” (valuing change, quantity, and commerce) and sees fundamentalism as protest and outrage against modernism, often by well-educated leaders and laity. The chapter on scripturalism is in many ways the best. Antoun stresses not only the emotional worlds built by the selective use of proof texts, but (quoting Marty and Appleby's edited volumes on fundamentalism) the “scandalous character” of much fundamentalism: practices or beliefs, chosen deliberately, emphasized only recently, precisely to challenge “enlightened” or “sophisticated” secular common sense. The comparative approach may help students to see fundamentalisms as parts of rich ecologies of religious forms. The implications, however, are not drawn out for civil society. Is dialogue acted out only through non-negotiable symbolic violence, withdrawal into communities of the pure, and militancy? Here the interesting legal, political, and media mobilization of American Christian, and Jewish Israeli, fundamentalists could be used for striking comparison with Hindu fundamentalists in India and Muslim fundamentalists in Turkey, Iran, and elsewhere.
Antoun briefly draws attention to Mark Juergensmeyer's observation that much religious imagery is symbolically violent, and “actual commission of religious violence…is also deliberately symbolically violent…dramatic, often shocking, and designed ‘to elicit feelings of revulsion and anger,’ involving notions of sacrifice and war in the cosmic struggle between absolute good and evil” (p. 104). Most of Antoun's cases of violence involve minority groups against majorities in their own tradition or secular modern society, not against other religions. There is discussion of the biblical imagery of the Boer covenant and wars but not of Christian missionary activity that has provoked violence in the Islamic and Hindu worlds, or Hindu–Muslim communal violence in India, the campaigns against the Fulang Gong in China, or cult formation in Japan. Indeed, there is something odd about yet another book claiming universal “ideal types” that overlooks expertise and examples from India, China, and Southeast Asia, particularly for an American classroom that nowadays will include many Buddhists, Hindus, Jains, Sikhs, and African New Christian churches.
Antoun says that his paternal grandfather was “religiously unmusical”; his maternal grandfather was atheist but married to a believer in the Melkite rite; that he himself was raised Methodist but learned nothing of religion; that he participated in Quaker, Lutheran, and Unitarian churches and recently married a Reform Jew. His main religious education was in Kufr al-Ma: the imam dictated sermons slowly to him so he could understand and transcribe them. He attributes his interest in religion to his lack of real religious education as a youngster, and he comes by his ecumenicism honestly.
“Religious musicality” could bear development. Bonhoeffer, the Christian leader against the Nazis, credited African American congregational prayer, sermons, and gospel singing with a profound tuning of his religiosity. Were his and Adam Clayton Powell's fundamentalisms mere diatribe against modernism or, rather, constructive contributions to a modernist mosaic? Note also: the fundamentalists Antoun has indirectly encountered in Kufr al-Ma since 1986 are the moderate South Asian Tabliqat-i Islami. They are not Hamas; the Muslim Brothers; Hezbollah; Wahhabis; Saudi money for mosques, madrasas, or Muslim student organizations; or any of the other recent newsmakers. Since 1986, youths have worried that Antoun was polluting their mosque and have tried to convert him; the causes are left unexplored. Antoun says that we need to know about his background to evaluate the book he has written, and the pieces do seem to fit together.
Antoun says he is more interested in popular religion, in what ordinary people do and believe, than in state- or national-level religion. The term “hizb” (party) was, in Kufr al-Ma, pejorative. The village ethos promoted consensus and eschewed political discourse. Thus, although we get statistics of militant fundamentalisms and violence (by country in Algeria, Egypt, and Turkey), and a sketch of Hamas (but no account of its growth in West Bank universities such as Bir Zeit), we learn little about religion and politics. By focusing on Kach (Baruch Goldstein, Meir Kahane), the haredim, and the Lubavitchers, he gives a bit of understanding of fundamentalism vis-à-vis the State of Israel. By some accounts (not Antoun's), the most serious looming political conflict for Israel is religious versus non-religious more than Palestinean versus Israeli or Sephardi versus Ashkenazi. (Antoun does not mention Sephardi fundamentalists; they do not fit his account of Yiddish insistence, but they, too, are key in Israeli politics.) There is a passing reference to Hammond's thesis that American Christian fundamentalisms today are a nativist phase of periodic Great Awakenings (what Anthony Wallace taught anthropologists to call “revitalization movements”), but there are no references to similar accounts of longer historical formations in which Muslim fundamentalisms arise. Antoun's account of the Iranian Revolution, for instance, relies heavily on his student Mary Hegland's dissertation in a village near Shiraz and the popular writings of Karen Armstrong, avoiding much of the growing literature on Iran.
Quibbles aside, this is a straightforwardly written, mature piece of comparative reflection that can be a useful teaching tool. A complementary book with a more cultural-ecumenical approach to the intertwined histories of Islam, Christianity, and Judaism contesting over Jerusalem, is Kanan Makiya's The Rock (2001), a collection of histories and stories about the Dome of the Rock in the narrative voice of Ishaq ibn K'ab, son of Islam's first important Jewish convert. The two books together might make a challenging exercise as starters in methodological approaches for upper-division and graduate-level seminars. But that is a different review.