D. Soyini Madison's complex and innovative monograph is a substantial blend of performance text, historiography, ethnography, personal narrative, and performance theory. Her primary focus in reporting on fieldwork she completed in Ghana from 1998 to 2006 is “to address the relationship between performance and local activism . . . [and] to present the often neglected yet compelling and important story of local activism in Africa, specifically Ghana” (1). Though Madison's language is at times mired in performance-studies jargon, the ideas and practices that she engages shed light on complicated relationships among groups and identities both within the nation and between nations, with an emphasis on human rights. The book comprises an introduction, three “Acts” (chapters), “illustrations of actions that generated activism relative to human rights and social justice” (26), and an epilogue. There is also an appendix of the scripts Madison developed at UNC–Chapel Hill, in which she stages the activist interventions witnessed in Ghana in conversation with her own positionality as an African American woman scholar.
Madison introduces her fieldwork and implicates herself in the complicated relationship of ethnographer to subject and its implicit power imbalance by exploring some theories of her particular performance ethnography, especially the idea that participant observation is insufficient to capture this complicated relationship. Instead she subscribes to a methodology, inspired by Gayatri Spivak's notion of intimate habitation, that emphasizes the researcher's “own split identity and gendered body” (1) by acknowledging it in the resulting performance texts. Referencing Toni Morrison's argument that the best art must be political without simply indulging in polemic, Madison says, “Staged ethnography seeks to avoid the harangue while . . . staging a moral discourse through an embodied epistemology where our own intentions, biases, subjectivity, and politics never disappear” (13). In subsequent chapters, the reader gains a substantial and deep understanding of Madison's experiences and analyses through the connected media of self-reflective journal entries, participant observation accounts, transcriptions, and performance texts in which the researcher is staged as a character alongside Madison's ethnographic subjects.
Act I, “Is It a Human Being or a Girl?,” introduces a debate between the proponents of a traditional religious practice in Ghana wherein young girls are effectively enslaved in religious shrines as proxy-punishment for their relatives. Those who perceive the practice as barbaric are often derided as neocolonialist chauvinists. Madison elucidates the practice's initially hidden complexities by relating the way her own relationship to it evolved from pure outrage to a more nuanced protest. She explicates her own practice as a useful example and deepens the reader's understanding of both the conflict and the activism she describes. Madison comes to see another side of the story through encounters with women who perceive their connections to the shrine as honor, not oppression. Her analysis is two-pronged: first witnessing the community-based “Liberation Ceremony,” in which enslaved women are reintroduced into society (54); then, in complementary fashion, sharing the performance she created around her fieldwork to illuminate “what we might not otherwise notice as we are blinded by the morass of the everyday or by habitual practice” (50). Madison's complicated rendering of multiple views of the events she describes, and her delineation of own positionality, embody the researcher's often conflicted position, particularly when working in human rights and ethnography.
Act II, “Water Rites/Rights,” addresses water access as a human right, focusing on the privatization of water distribution and the ways individuals and groups attempt to combat water scarcity in Ghana. In her fieldwork, Madison encounters a range of ways that scarcity affects urban and rural communities, from parasitic guinea worm infections in people who must wade into infected ponds to fetch water, to water companies refusing to activate the pipes that run water to their customers. This research inspired a performance titled Water Rites—“as much a pedagogical experiment for . . . [the] students as it was a staged performance for an audience” (111). In her “aim to provoke” à la Brecht, Madison insists that all involved should learn to think differently about water and consider it “beyond the language of conservation” (111)—that we should “feel compelled to do more, to learn more, think more, and effect change about water” (152). While Madison only speculates about audience response in her analysis, she theorizes that performance born of ethnography is particularly able to animate audiences via a productive (but potentially dangerous) metonymy of representing the Other outside her habitual space, wherein staged action makes audiences feel as though they are actually present with the Other, in order to deepen audiences’ empathetic responses. Madison's inclusion of performance texts alongside ethnographic narrative and analysis compellingly invites the reader to imagine this kind of presence, as well as the experience of the ethnographer in the field and her subjectivity regarding the material.
In Act III, “Acts of Activism,” Madison applies her methodology to street performances, including protest demonstrations, and to more recognizably didactic Theatre for Development models. She renders transcriptions in this section in verse, “in order to capture their unique poetics and verbal artistry, as well as to document the experiential and performative aspects that constituted their delivery or telling” (157). This daring choice generally works very well in this book; the form heightens the text without unduly distracting the reader. Madison describes several performances: in one, men and women in wedding attire stand at busy intersections in Ghana's capital, Accra, with obvious wounds and bandages in order to bring awareness to spousal abuse and intramarital rape. Another piece meant to offer ideas for successful child rearing is devised and acted by mothers for other mothers in central Accra's Makola Market. As always, interwoven with these records are Madison's reflections on her own position within this community, as an African American in Africa, and as a woman among women. The chapter concludes with the ethnographer feeling empowered and enmeshed in the community and its cooperative efforts both to enact and to stage change; the book itself concludes on a positive note, empowering scholars and human beings to enact change boldly, and to embody reimagining our world as we want to see it.
This book should interest scholars in many disciplines—Theatre for Development, performance studies, ethnography (both performative and otherwise), women's studies, and African studies—as well as writers of contemporary theatre historiography. It is a powerful statement, conveyed through multiple lenses and methods, in support of the idea that one's acts can constitute the seeds of vast and lasting change.
Although initially set slightly off balance by this book's unorthodox structure and methodology, I ultimately found that its approach and arrangement offered deeply nuanced and complex views of Madison's work, the cases she addresses, and the way she approaches analysis. Her comprehensive account serves simultaneously as example, as case study, and as methodology.
