A cursory glance over the scholarship on medieval Islamic civilization produced over the last few generations reveals a rich array of political and dynastic histories, historiographical studies, and works on intellectual and religious trends in the Muslim world. Scholars of medieval Islam have built a strong foundation for our understanding of the region's premodern history. At the same time, it is understood that medieval Islamic historiography often dealt with the elite stratum of society. The nature of these sources (and their “authors”) coupled with the comparative dearth of documentary evidence in relation to other fields of history (e.g., the medieval Latin West, Byzantium, Roman history) has, at times, limited the scope of our inquiries. A consequence of this limitation in the sources is that modern scholars, in their bid to “flesh out” the skeleton of the existing premodern Islamic historiography, have been hampered in their efforts to conduct studies of wide-ranging aspects of medieval Islamic society. Agricultural techniques and production, monetary histories, and communications systems—each of which was instrumental in the functioning of premodern societies—have received less attention in the field than they deserve. The ubiquitous nature of these topics coupled with their relative lack of coverage in the available sources only compounds the frustration of modern scholars.
Adam Silverstein's work on postal systems (i.e., the barid) and communications in the medieval Islamic world goes a long way toward correcting one of the deficiencies in the field. Expanding upon his doctoral thesis on postal systems in the early Islamic era, Silverstein adopts a systematic approach to the study of premodern communications systems. Starting with the pre-Islamic Near East and ending with an overview of Mamluk-era postal practices, the author meticulously draws upon textual and material sources, making a number of key observations. After dispensing with the notion that the Islamic barid system was wholly based on pre-Islamic Persian or Byzantine practices, Silverstein highlights the dynamic nature of the medieval Islamic postal system. Although not going so far as to say that the barid system was uniquely Islamic, Silverstein does make a strong argument for studying the changes and other innovations brought in during the Muslim era—among them the creation of the diwan al-barid and the introduction of having rulers fund the “institution” rather than placing the burden on the citizenry.
Throughout his study, Silverstein underscores the paramount importance of the barid communications system—an institution exclusively reserved for the ruling powers—not only in the establishment of these dynasties and powers but also in the effective running of their respective administrations. The author does not view the barid system as a constant or a single thread that runs throughout the region's history; on the contrary, Silverstein points out on numerous occasions the changing nature of communications systems while reminding the reader of the singular importance of the role the barid system played from one era to the next.
Readers will benefit from the author's comprehensive approach to the topic. Adopting a chronological presentation method, Silverstein breaks his work into three parts: the pre-Islamic period (Chapter 1), the Umayyad and Abbasid periods (Chapters 2 and 3), and the “post-Abbasid” period of the Mongols (Chapter 4) and Mamluks (Chapter 5). The reasoning for this stems from his desire to provide a clear historical context to developments within the varying communication systems over time, a task all but impossible using a thematic approach. Another advantage of this method is that it provides Silverstein the opportunity to highlight the myriad sources from each period and discuss their strong and weak points. In Chapter 1, on the pre-Islamic postal systems of Persia, Byzantium, and the Arabian peninsula, Silverstein uses a variety of sources, including the Persepolis Fortification Tablets, the Book of Esther, Procopius's work on the Justinian era, and pre-Islamic Arab poetry. Later chapters covering the Islamic era rely on the standard medieval chronicles and occasional administrative and geographic manuals in addition to the anonymous Siyasat al-Muluk from the 10th century.
Silverstein effectively ties the chapters together by following a rigorous format in each. In true administrative fashion, he provides categories for his discussion of the postal/communications systems (e.g., routes and stations, messengers, informants, methods of communication, and administration). He does not, however, attempt to address each of these categories in each chapter or in reference to each dynasty/civilization when the categories are not applicable. In an apparent homage to the bureaucratic nature of his topic, Silverstein starts each chapter, or section in a chapter, with a well-organized discussion of the medieval and modern views on the medieval postal/communication systems. He invariably follows this by stating how this received wisdom is incorrect; he then spends the rest of the chapter or section providing evidence to support his claim. It is an effective method albeit a bit stylistically awkward at times.
The wide-ranging scope of this work is laudable, but it also has its disadvantages. The first chapter is a lengthy linguistic tour de force on the pre-Islamic region that provides a solid foundation upon which he builds in later chapters. The difficulty is that in his attempt to cover every period from the rise of Islam to the Mamluk era (inclusive of the extensive and varying Mongol system), the depth and strength of his argument occasionally falter. This is most apparent in his discussion of the 10th- to 12th-century central Islamic lands during the politically and intellectually dynamic Fatimid, Buyid, and Seljuq periods. Silverstein's conclusions regarding the impact and influence of the barid system (or lack thereof) on the ultimate destiny of these dynasties would have benefited from more extensive coverage of their individual and combined narrative histories.
This aside, Silverstein is to be commended for this ambitious project; it is a welcome and much needed addition to the field. Students and scholars of the political, economic, and administrative history of medieval Islam will benefit greatly from the foundation he has provided.
