There is not much public awareness about the protection of biodiversity, since much of it has no immediate personal economic values. This applies not only to the public but also to the policy-makers of the least developed and developing countries. However, international policy-makers appear to have realized that the loss of biodiversity of any kind is irreversible and is able to create many catastrophes, such as natural disasters. This is why, perhaps, the world has witnessed a fundamental change in the concept of development, particularly when it interacts with the use of biodiversity. Global and regional frameworks for the protection of biodiversity and the emerging concept of sustainable development embodied in various international framework documents are the evidence of such a change. Where there are some global frameworks for the protection of biodiversity, initiatives and attempts vary due to the different levels of commitment of the members of the international community. Such differences in the levels of commitment can be attributed to various factors, including the development need of the specific region and the conceptual understanding. Therefore, a regional framework between like-minded groups of countries within such a global framework is very important for the success of any such global initiative. Ananda Mohan Bhattarai argues in a similar vein in this book.
The book aims at examining the ongoing and impending practical problems of the Himalayan region. It also argues for the harmonization of regional and global environmental policies. Fundamentally, the author argues for a separate framework treaty between countries in the Himalayan region for the greater regional benefit, taking into consideration the particular and specific geographical, social, and lifestyle situation of the region.
The book is divided into seven chapters. Chapter 1 sets the background by introducing the topography, environment, and rich biodiversity of the region. It also outlines the issues and challenges faced by the Himalayan region and its people. Once the issues are introduced, it becomes necessary to explore global and regional initiatives to address those issues. Therefore, Chapter 2 explores some of the relevant developments, such as the Convention on Biological Diversity (CBD). Issues of access to genetic resources and benefit-sharing are central to the CBD, which is discussed in much detail in Chapter 3.
Chapter 4 analyzes the challenges of protecting traditional knowledge in the globalized context. This chapter also examines achievements under the global initiatives such as the CBD and the World Intellectual Property Organization (WIPO) discussions. Here, the author, acknowledging achievements under those initiatives, concludes that the protection of biological diversity and traditional knowledge has remained an “unfinished agenda” despite all those initiatives.
Whilst Chapter 5 discusses the development of the concept of the intellectual property in the northern hemisphere, it attributes the issues of bio-piracy to the international and Western intellectual property regime, which the author says is hostile to the biological resources, the holders of those resources, and their knowledge system. Analysis of some of the selected cases adds value to such an argument that the Western intellectual property regime is responsible for bio-piracy and other issues. This particular chapter covers a wide range of issues and materials, which makes it rather vague. While the author looked into the historical development of the intellectual property regime, a rigorous analysis of it as well as of the TRIPS Agreement could have benefited the book. On the other hand, however, it could have made the work overly lengthy.
Based on the problems and issues discussed in Chapters 1 to 5, Chapter 6 argues for a framework of regional co-operation for the protection of biodiversity in the Himalayan region. The author examines the gaps in the existing and emerging laws of the countries of the Himalayan region. The work in this chapter is comprehensive, as it analyzes all the existing and proposed local legislation in these countries. Most importantly, CBD has remained the central reference point in analyzing those local and national initiatives, which is perhaps the best possible way of taking the regional problems onto the global stage.
After a careful analysis of the Himalayan regional problems and of the global, regional, and local initiatives, Chapter 7 rightly points out the need for a regional legal framework for the Himalayan region in particular, and for every region in general. The author says that such a regime is “all the more important in the context of a threatened ecosystem such as the Himalaya where the states have to cope with both nature and human-induced challenges including the recent ones brought about by climate change and atmospheric brown cloud”. The author concludes that a regional coalition can more vigorously tackle problems such as bio-piracy, the loss of genetic variety, and the adverse effect of environmental pollution on vulnerable areas. The author further concludes that regional initiatives under the International Centre for Integrated Mountain Development (ICIMOD) and South Asian Association for Regional Cooperation (SAARC) are not enough. Therefore, the author proposes some negotiating agendas for regional co-operation in which the creation of awareness, establishment of a coalition of governmental and non-governmental actors, civil societies, and researchers is important for the protection of Himalaya and its people.
In general, this book is perhaps the most comprehensive in the study of the particular problems of the Himalayan region, and proposes solutions under global initiatives, while recognizing the need for a particular and distinct regional policy. Bhattarai provides clear guidelines to the policy-makers for the development of mountain-sensitive law under global frameworks such as the CBD. It provides a very useful insight to the issues of the protection of biodiversity and traditional knowledge, as well as to the issues of the livelihood of the poor people of the Himalayan region, and provides a way forward for it. It is an excellent piece of work, which contributes to the understanding of the issues of biodiversity protection and the traditional knowledge system of the Hindu Kush Himalayan region. This is a brilliant addition to the existing literature on global environmental law and policy.
