Biographies and histories of female U.S. theatre stars and popular entertainers of the nineteenth and twentieth centuries do important revisionist work by acknowledging women's contributions to the development of American culture and performance. Two new studies of famous female artists contribute to and expand this important area of history: Anne Anlin Cheng's Second Skin: Josephine Baker & the Modern Surface and Michael Foster and Barbara Foster's A Dangerous Woman: The Life, Loves, and Scandals of Adah Isaacs Menken, 1835–1868, America's Original Superstar. While both books address the significance of their respective subject's personal and professional identities to each woman's place in history, the authors deploy different approaches to analyzing Baker's and Menken's impacts on Western culture and performance. Cheng approaches Baker's iconographic legacy through architectural theories that enable a sophisticated, nuanced reading of skin and/as surface in the modern moment, whereas Foster and Foster present an accessible, popular approach to Menken's career as one of America's earliest superstars and sex symbols.
Anne Anlin Cheng's book centers on an analysis of the relationship between modernism and primitivism as aesthetic and cultural movements that influenced Western ways of seeing and knowing in the early twentieth century. Over the course of ten chapters, Cheng reads Josephine Baker's body and her body of work as pivotal sites for exploring the relationship between these two movements and their respective and related preoccupations with cultural markers such as race, skin, surface, self, and otherness. Cheng contrasts her readings of the corporeal surface with readings of the synthetic, architectural bodies of two founding fathers of modern architectural design, Adolf Loos and Le Corbusier. Baker's organic, luminescent skin and the plastic, shining surfaces of modern buildings and spaces, when viewed through the lenses of Freudian psychoanalysis, Loos's theory of Bekleidung (cladding), and Le Corbusier's fascination with American infrastructure (and especially skyscrapers), provide a tantalizing escape from Old World Europe and the promise of a new, modern world and aesthetic. Cheng notes that this study is “not a biography of Baker, nor a historiography of her performances. Instead, it offers a series of associative and cumulative meditations about the intimacy between the philosophical origins of the ‘denuded modern surface’ and the theatricalization of ‘naked skin’ at the dawn of the twentieth century, with Baker as a pivotal figure” (14).
These initially disparate-seeming sites of inquiry are powerfully related in the exemplary chapter “Housing Baker, Dressing Loos.” Cheng describes how a chance meeting between Baker and Loos inspired the architect to design a house for the performer. Loos's aforementioned preoccupation with Bekleidung—cladding, covering, or “skin,” if you will—translates to an architectural tendency to create womblike buildings and spaces that ensconce and protect the inhabitant, man, from the outside world. In contrast, Baker House is a study in the inverse, creating public–private spaces conceptualized to display rather than to seclude its famous tenant. Cheng reads Loos's design as a fetishization of Baker, an encasing or skin that, like Baker's own carefully designed exterior, satisfies the Western viewer's desire for access to a primitive racial and sexual Other. She argues, “[t]his architectural vision may therefore be said to exemplify the racial and sexual fantasies of European, masculinist, and Primitivist desire. We may go even further and see this house as an architectural translation of the banana skirt . . . literalized as architecture in Loos's vision of Baker literally living inside an exposing costume” (52). Her analysis includes readings of the floor plans and model for the Baker House (which was never actually built), various other Loos buildings, and extant Baker iconography. These images reveal stark black and white color contrasts in interiors and exteriors—the Baker House model sports graphic horizontal black and white stripes wrapping around the entire facade—while photographs of Baker depict the “infinitely dressable surface” of her “eroticized flesh,” which is itself neither black nor white, yet always suggestive of the primitive (81).
Cheng concludes by reiterating the significance of comparing and contrasting Baker's nuanced representations of difference on her own skin with manufactured ones:
If the endgame of the story of the modern object, distilled from architectural theory and its attachment to the purified look of the anonymous façade, is about erasing the bad (and dark) taste of materiality to cleanse the body and to liberate the eye toward the shine of rational thought, then we have to see the naked Baker as the implosion of, rather than a backdrop for, that fantasy. (161)
In doing so, Cheng offers a valuable new approach to Baker's agency and the impact of her work, as well as an elegant and successful model for pairing performance sites with unexpected theoretical lenses. Cheng challenges the reader to reconsider her reaction to Baker's seductive sartorial skin, the larger commentary her performances suggest about our attraction to the surface, and to the simultaneously restrictive and freeing politics Baker's performances, and visuality writ large, ultimately suggest.
While Cheng's project is concerned with the theoretical reading of surfaces, Michael Foster and Barbara Foster provide a rather entertaining, though decidedly surface-level, biography of Adah Isaacs Menken in A Dangerous Woman. Relying on sensational spinning of historical facts about her performance career, salacious editorializing about her personal life (particularly her romantic attachments), unconfirmed rumors regarding her origins and identity (religious, sexual, and racial), and unreliable sources such as Wikipedia, the Fosters exacerbate the muddying of the historical waters surrounding Menken, sullying extant evidence regarding her life and career with unsubstantiated and at times judgmental commentary.
The book is organized into five major parts with twenty-three chapters, an Introduction and Coda, and photographs. While each part's title suggests its theme, from “Part One: A Colored Girl from New Orleans,” to “Part Three: Prince Mazeppa” (a breeches role and one of Menken's most famous), the chapters themselves bear more tawdry titles such as “Chapter One: Naked,” and “Coda: The Sexy Spirit,” thereby undermining the significance of Menken's work as well as that of the text itself. The authors spend a significant amount of time chronicling Menken's sexual exploits, drawing connections between her offstage love life and the professional persona she developed as one of America's earliest sex symbols. Menken was indeed an anomaly in the Victorian era due in part to her five marriages and to her unapologetic and public attitude toward female sexuality; however, the authors’ editorializing about her most intimate personal moments (including fictionalized descriptions and comparisons of her wedding nights with different husbands) trivializes her relationships and distracts from her work as a professional artist at a time when attempting—and succeeding at—such a career as a woman was a rarity. Menken's success is both worthy and in need of further serious treatment and research by theatre historians.
But theatre historians the Fosters are not, and in some ways this may contribute to more successful aspects of the book that receive less attention in other scholars’ treatments of Menken. (Daphne Brooks's chapter on Menken in the excellent Bodies in Dissent [Duke UP, 2006], not cited by the Fosters, comes immediately to mind.) One positive and significant contribution the authors make is a strong emphasis and reliance on Menken's poetry, which was widely published in periodicals during her life, and in a collected volume posthumously. Noting the personal nature of Menken's poems, the authors identify and trace themes important to the artist throughout her career: love, respect, trust, and an eerie premonition that she would meet an untimely death. They convincingly suggest these poems offer readers a vulnerable vantage point from which to consider Menken as not only an objectified but successful international superstar, but also a lonely, peerless woman in search of personal and professional security.
While vastly different in tone, approach, and scope, Cheng's and Foster and Foster's work reminds me of the importance of histories that will continue to broaden our understanding of, and suggest new perspectives on, women's contributions to the development of American theatre and popular entertainment, and their roles in the cross-cultural circulation of ideas, style, and art on the worlds’ great stages. These books on two well-known female performers demonstrate that there is still much to be said about even our most treasured artists, and even more to be discovered about those who have fallen out of view but are waiting in the archival wings to be called, once again, to center stage.
