Eunuchs were a part of ancient Mediterranean society, represented in contexts sacred and secular, enslaved and freeborn, comprised of those ‘born eunuchs’ (intersex) and those whose bodies were altered by accident or procedure. And yet the scholarly literature about them remains astonishingly sparse, particularly before the Late Antique period. So it is gratifying to see Tougher's Roman Castrati enter the scene to present a coherent narrative of eunuchs from Terrence to Procopius.
In taking this long view, T. adds rich context to the institution of Late Antique court eunuchs by exploring their roots; a fitting ‘prequel’ to his substantial publications on eunuchs in Byzantium. It is also an ambitious project, requiring the author to speak with equal authority on Roman comedy and Flavian legal advocacy, which T. manages by keeping tightly to the ancient source material and the eunuchs themselves. This results in a focus more concerned with individual eunuchs’ biographies than on questions of gender and identity. Here, too, is fertile ground for further work, but it does sometimes make for difficult reading, particularly if a reader is themself intersex or transgender; invective forms the bulk of the source material for the lives recorded here, particularly that of Favorinus, and as T. faithfully presents his sources, this can become rough going.
The chapter structure is chronological and linear, providing good supporting detail for undergraduate readers and friendly to syllabus assignments. The opening chapter introduces the Galli, priests to the Great Mother, the connection between the myth of Attis and the Galli themselves, and the reception of the cult into Rome. The second chapter on Terence's Eunuch, by contrast, turns to enslaved eunuchs as objects of comic writing in second-century b.c.e. Roman theatre. The two chapters together present the dissonance between the eunuch as sacred and powerful and the eunuch as enslaved and objectified avatar of gender transgression. This opening likewise contextualises the increasing presence of eunuchs in Rome within Rome's foreign policy during the period and its ambivalent attitude toward the eastern Mediterranean's political and social dynamics.
The third chapter moves us to the Principate and to more biographical material, focusing on two eunuchs of the imperial household: Sporus (Nero's spouse) and Earinus (Domitian's courtier). Here, T. reconstructs details of two lives from a frustrating and often hostile set of sources, providing a thorough account of the evidence available and guiding the reader through the pitfalls and debates surrounding these figures. As both were castrated as part of their enslavement and trafficking, and both were associated with an emperor, they make for useful comparisons that reveal not only court details, but also the grim realities of enslavement in the ancient world.
Favorinus the sophist takes centre stage in the fourth chapter, serving as the representative for the ‘born eunuch’, an ancient category in which intersex people with male-presenting bodies were placed. This will be familiar territory for those already familiar with the ‘Second Sophistic’, a topic with substantial scholarship in which Favorinus is a regular cast member. This chapter not only focuses on Favorinus’ self-positioning as a eunuch celebrity, but also provides an appendix of all Favorinus’ appearances in Gellius, a courtesy which will be a welcome bonus to many readers.
At this point, the book shifts into its second phase, in which the Late Antique imperial court eunuch has become an institution. Ch. 5 traces the rise of the court eunuch as praepositus sacri cubiculi, focusing on the later period with the eunuchs Eusebius and Eutropius. T. here uses the groundwork laid in the first chapters to support an argument for Late Antique chamberlains as a continuation of rather than a departure from earlier court institutions, rightly resisting older arguments based in Orientalist patterns of interpreting eunuchs. From there, ch. 6 turns again to the religious context of self-castrated sacred eunuchs, now under Christianity. While it would be tempting to draw connections between Attis and Origen, T. rightly refrains, focusing on a tight overview of how and why self-castration became an issue in Christianity and directing readers to the relevant scholarship. Origen is doubtless relieved.
Narses the eunuch general is the last person we meet, along with a supporting cast of military eunuchs, and he makes for an interesting final word in a topic so bound up with questions of masculinity, power and sexuality. In an arena where all seems stacked against him, Narses succeeded and did so with dignity. Narses’ status as a eunuch is both relevant and immaterial to his ability to lead, almost less important to the sources than his character and talent. In a field full of people whose bodies and persons were treated so unfairly and struggled to claim basic human dignities, it was gratifying to bid farewell to someone who emerges from the sources in triumph.
T.'s book is a boon to all of us with an interest in telling the story of the eunuchs of the Roman Empire. It is the full introduction that I would have loved to have when I first became interested in the topic and will serve its readers well for years to come.
