This book convincingly debunks the common wisdom that societies defeated in war experience drops in civic engagement, as discouraged and desperate citizens seek individualized rather than collective solutions to their problems. By means of a sophisticated methodology that involves quantitative intra- and international analyses combined with careful, detailed case studies, Rieko Kage offers compelling evidence that wartime mobilization can actually increase a society's capacity for civic engagement postwar, and that legacies of prewar organizational structures can help explain where citizens direct their new civic skills. Furthermore, using the Japanese case, the author offers a theoretical model that can explain the existence of “long civic generations” in several countries, including the United States.
In a nutshell, Kage argues that the involuntary mobilization of citizens during wartime instills important civic skills that can then be directed toward voluntary civic engagement once the conflict ends. Those organizations that had strong memberships and organizational structures before the war are best positioned to capitalize on higher civic capacity after the war because reviving a repressed or disbanded organization has lower costs than beginning a new organization entirely from scratch.
The strongest parts of the Civic Engagement in Postwar Japan are the careful case studies found in Chapters 6 and 7, which examine how two different “hard case” organizations were revived during the immediate postwar period. Whereas the Young Men's Christian Association (YMCA) was forcibly repressed by the wartime regime and actively supported by the Allied occupation, judo participation was actively supported by the wartime regime and strongly repressed by the occupation. Chapter 6 explains why Kobe's YMCA recovered so much faster than Sapporo's, and Chapter 7 reveals why postwar judo participation quickly returned to Fukuoka while languishing in Yokohama. The two chapters together demonstrate that state/occupation support or repression of the organization did not appreciably affect its revival: Both types of organizations thrived after the war in those cities where they had strong prewar institutional legacies and struggled in cities with weaker prewar organizational structures. The evidence is rich, original, and compelling. These chapters highlight in great detail the mechanisms through which involuntary wartime mobilization can give citizens a higher capacity for voluntary civic engagement after the war ends, and how and why particular organizations can capitalize on that enhanced capacity.
Two chapters use quantitative analyses to examine variation in civic participation across Japanese prefectures (Chapter 4) and across 13 countries involved in World War II (Chapter 5). Both chapters compare the difference in postwar civic participation rates between generational cohorts (those born between 1911 and 1920, and those born between 1921 and 1930, with the latter representing those most affected by wartime mobilization) in order to identify the effect of wartime mobilization by generation. To capture the cross-regional or cross-national variation, the overall level of mobilization is measured by the total number of conscripted soldiers per population. All of the analyses carefully control for variables that might also affect participation rates, such as level of education and income. The author also creatively tests plausible alternative hypotheses, such as damage levels, “baby-boom” effects, demand for child care, or the effect of the Great Depression. Together, the two chapters offer considerable additional support for Kage's argument that wartime mobilization facilitates, rather than inhibits, postwar civic engagement, and, contra expectations, it does not matter whether the affected citizens were “winners” or “losers” in the war.
The statistical analyses are quite persuasive in their support of Kage's overall argument about the linkages between wartime and postwar mobilization, but they are less convincing with respect to the subargument that posits that mobilization by the state is distinct from mobilization by society. Indeed, one of the strengths of the book is that it highlights the important interplay between state and society in citizen engagement and problematizes theoretical frameworks that suggest that state and society are somehow separate from each other or, even more problematically, that their efforts to mobilize citizens have a zero-sum relationship with each other. And yet, assuming that state and citizen mobilization efforts are distinct is exactly what Kage does when she posits that rates of civic participation in a region/country and military mobilization rates are both independent variables. In certain places she examines their interactive effects—and indeed their interaction is the core of her main argument—but most of the statistical analyses assume that their effects are independent.
It is quite likely, however, that regions and countries that have high levels of social engagement will also have high response rates to state calls for military mobilization, and those with low levels of civic engagement will also have low rates of military mobilization (see, e.g., Margaret Levi, Consent, Dissent, Patriotism, 1997). The problem of the high correlation between military and civic mobilization is addressed in the case studies because Kage carefully selects organizations with different participation rates while controlling for cities with similar mobilization rates. However, at the aggregate level of the prefecture or country, it is very likely that the two types of participation go together. Unfortunately, the reader is not given the correlation figures for the two “independent” variables, and so it is difficult to assess how distinct the two types of participation actually are. Furthermore, there are a few problematic inconsistencies across the two sets of analyses. For example, in the cross-regional analysis, participation in labor organizations is excluded (for good reason), but in the cross-national analysis, participation in labor unions is included. It is likely that the very compelling graph on page 87, in which country-level variation in mobilization is almost perfectly correlated with the percentage difference in postwar memberships between generational cohorts, would look very different if labor participation were excluded from the analyses.
The seventh chapter offers a closer examination of the reasons why legacies of prewar voluntary associations are so important to postwar revival of civic engagement, arguing that their most important role is one of information sharing. Kage then offers statistical evidence that a prefecture's mail volume (proxy for dense interpersonal networks), combined with economic resources, sped the recovery of jobs, hospitals, and schools across Japan. Since the main value of the organizations studied in the previous chapters (e.g., YMCA, judo, alpine clubs, etc.) had to do with their role as foci and facilitators of dense, informal, personal connections, rather than their role as formal channels of information distribution, the link between this chapter and the previous ones is not as strong as it might have been.
Overall, Civic Engagement in Postwar Japan is an excellent book that addresses important concerns for political scientists and policymakers. Its concluding chapter reflects on five implications of the research, and I highlight three here. First, the book offers new and innovative information about the postwar period for scholars of Japan, comparative civil society, and postwar reconstruction. Second, it supports the findings of others, such as Daniel Aldrich's Building Resilience (2012), that dense social-capital networks are critical to postdisaster recovery. Third, it suggests a new way to think about democratic transitions and the morphing of involuntary participation in war mobilization into voluntary participation in democratic civic organizations. As dozens of countries around the world struggle with war, reconstruction, and democratic transitions, and others face dwindling civic participation in the public sphere, Kage's book is of pressing and immediate relevance for all political scientists.
