As Lisa Baldez points out in her lucidly written account of the UN's Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination against Women (CEDAW), “The first sentence of the Charter of the United Nations, written in 1945, vows to put an end to war. The second sentence establishes gender equality” (32). In other words, the United States’ failure to ratify CEDAW – the central focus of Baldez's inquiry – demands some explanation, since it would seem uncontroversial. Further, existing scholarship on international human rights treaties would lead us to expect the US to sign CEDAW, since the convention reflects already prevailing norms, making implementation costs fairly minimal. Baldez structures her study around three questions: how women's rights became a global norm, CEDAW's role in upholding that norm, and why the United States has resisted it. In the end, she argues, a combination of the geopolitical context in which CEDAW came about and ongoing disagreements about how women's rights should be defined have obstructed efforts to secure US ratification of the convention.
Although CEDAW gets little attention among women activists in most countries of what we now refer to as the “global North,” it remains an important tool in many parts of the world. CEDAW's reporting requirements allow organizations to hold their governments accountable to commitments made to international standards around a host of issues such as pay equity, political rights, and gender-based violence. Even CEDAW's supporters in places like the United States often point to the ways that it protects women elsewhere, assuming that women in wealthier countries do not need UN protection. Baldez deftly shows, particularly in chapters 4 and 5, how CEDAW has developed into a particularly effective tool, particularly in the hands of NGOs.
CEDAW deliberations unfolded amid debates about sex equality and sex difference – whether women should have protective labor legislation or equal work opportunities, for example, and whether women's issues should be deliberated in separate spaces such as the Commission on the Status of Women or in integrated spaces such as the more powerful Human Rights Commission. As Baldez highlights, CEDAW advocates explicitly deployed the language of discrimination to link CEDAW with the widely adopted 1966 Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Racial Discrimination, which the United States also declined to ratify until 1994. Indeed, efforts to analogize racial and sex discrimination were a recurring motif among women in UN circles. Like many UN documents from this period, CEDAW consists of “an awkward compromise between general affirmations of support for women's rights and Marxist language that reflects the political climate that dominated the UN at the time CEDAW was drafted” (102). It includes, for example, condemnations of apartheid, neocolonialism, and racial discrimination.
Those who assume that US women are always at the vanguard of sex equality will be surprised to learn how strenuously the US delegation opposed these provisions during the drafting of the UN Charter. The Charter's Article 8, guaranteeing equal opportunities for men and women within the UN, was only secured through the efforts of a group of Latin American women – particularly the Dominican Minerva Bernardino, the Brazilian Bertha Lutz, and the Mexican Amalia Castillo de Ledón – along with the Australian Jessie Street and a constellation of nongovernmental organizations (NGOs), over the objections of US delegates Virginia Gildersleeve and Dorothy Kenyon. Similarly, although the US delegation would later advocate for NGOs to have a stronger role in the UN, Kenyon had initially sought to restrict their role, perhaps concerned about the newly formed Soviet-aligned NGO the Women's International Democratic Federation (45).
Its writing style and its clear presentation of background about the United Nations and geopolitical conflicts make Defying Convention accessible even to a mid-level undergraduate class and certainly to general readers. Given the range that it covers, it may be less satisfying to specialists seeking a deep study of CEDAW itself and the negotiations over its contents, but that really is not this book's purpose.
At points, clarity and concision seem to come at the expense of sustaining the book's analysis. Chapter 2, for example, provides an illuminating account of the partisan and ideological disagreements that divided interested parties within the United States, but chapter 3, which turns to geopolitics, treats national interests as coherent and monolithic. The research leans heavily on the New York Times, US participants, and State Department correspondence, generally without accounting for the specificity of their perspectives.
None of these methodological and stylistic considerations detracts from the book's principal contributions. It provides an extremely useful primer on how UN conventions function and how CEDAW's particular reporting process gives leverage to civil society organizations. Given how unfamiliar most people are with the UN and how it operates, this aspect alone makes Baldez's book an extremely useful contribution. Second, Baldez traces the ways that geopolitical context and domestic conflicts within the United States have undermined support for a treaty that seems entirely in line with US policies on women's issues. Finally, Defying Convention shows the indispensable role that NGOs have played in developing and implementing CEDAW. Indeed, as Baldez demonstrates, without NGO involvement, CEDAW would be a dead letter.
