In this book Naseem Badiey effectively explains the importance of land tenure as a key area of contestation affecting development and state building in South Sudan. Her focus on local dynamics shows that development does not happen from above nor is it driven by outside intervention. Further, she explains that confusion abounds regarding what exactly is being reconstructed in the post-conflict setting, if it is ‘post’ conflict at all. The case of Juba is telling in its diversity of contestations. She focuses on local communities’ notions of right-to and entitlement-to land compared with national claims by elites, government and international actors. Badiey's work provides an important contribution to scholarship examining the contemporary neo-liberal development agenda of which South Sudan has become a central project.
It is clear from the detail and nuance in her work that Badiey spent a significant amount of time in South Sudan. Most illustrative and telling is the explanation of the resistance of the residents of Gondokoro (a large island in the Nile) to the plan of then Minister of Lands Riek Machar of resettling residents and turning the island into a government focused capitol. This case illustrates how various individuals and groups had very different interpretations of the Comprehensive Peace Agreement (CPA) of 2005 with respect to land in Juba. Badiey also suggests that such contradictions are also likely more widely throughout the country.
Focus on the local, grassroots, traditional or customary (to note some of the more common rhetoric), has become popular amongst much of the international development community, as with some circles in academia. However it is a rhetoric that is often not reflected by practice and/or outcomes in South Sudan. Badiey shows that this is likely due to the fact that few development actors appreciate and understand local dynamics because there is little effective explanation of how the local level links to the national level and by extension the international level.
Although it may seem apparent that local understanding is important for development work, it remains however that local focus can often be a debilitating trap for development actors and researchers alike. Thus if Badiey's approach is to live up to its promise there is a corresponding need to apply it more widely in South Sudan so that a fuller picture of the emergent state can be grasped rather than very focused snap-shots of specific cases.
Outside of the core investigation of land tenure in Juba and its link to state building, Badiey engages in some tangential examinations of more general implication. These propositions, such as proposing donors’ ignorance of local dynamics and the corresponding questioning of the viability of the South Sudanese state is interesting; however they seem outside the Juba-centric focus of the work. The competitions and issues over land tenure in Juba are a special example in South Sudan. While land is hotly contested thorough the country in general, the specific issues from place to place are remarkably different. For example, the conflict over the use of land for pasture, agriculture or settlement is significant and has greater implications for national politics and state/nation building. Juba is a rapidly urbanising environment but South Sudan remains a rural and sparsely populated land making Juba a special case.
Badiey's locally focused unearthing of explanations of development politics in South Sudan will prove useful for many aspects of the study of South Sudan politics and is an important contribution to scholarship. Her work points toward a more effective understanding of political dynamics in South Sudan and is essential reading for analysts focused on the emergent state or those interested in development politics more generally.
