There is a vast (and growing) body of literature on the history, politics and jurisprudence of the two ad hoc international criminal tribunals: the International Criminal Tribunal for the Former Yugoslavia (ICTY); and the International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda (ICTR). The quality of the literature varies; some is meant for specialists (historians, political scientists, lawyers); some has a more general public in mind. The creation of the permanent International Criminal Court (ICC), as well as the establishment of a number of other international criminal tribunals (including so-called “hybrid” tribunals) that deal with past atrocities in countries ranging from Sierra Leone to Cambodia and East-Timor, provide for further and renewed interest in the study of international criminal justice institutions.
Victor Peskin's book on the difficulties and complexities of international cooperation to bring justice to the post-conflict Rwanda and the Balkans, is divided into four parts: Part One deals with the basic research question at hand and provides the reader with a critical literature review. Parts Two and Three deal with the ICTY and ICTR respectively. Part Four is the conclusion and also contains some thoughts on the future of international criminal justice, and in particular the challenges facing the ICC and other international tribunals. It is important to note that, although the four parts are distinct in the sense that they deal primarily with four different aspects of the body of research, they form a coherent unit with many cross-references and integrated commentary.
Many of the books and other publications in the field of international criminal justice are relatively easy to “classify” in terms of a target audience. In other cases, the classification is not so easy. Victor Peskin, in the introduction to International Justice in Rwanda and the Balkans, provides the reader with a critical overview of some of the important publications on the subject. Peskin is critical of the “court-centered” perspective(s) of many (if not most) of the publications. This is evidenced by (what Peskin claims to be) the absence of “a study of state cooperation that focuses at once on the battles among the tribunals, key international actors, and the states of the former Yugoslavia and Rwanda”.Footnote 1 Peskin states the following as the objective of his book:
“This study of state cooperation in the international prosecution of war crimes seeks to illuminate a political process whose actors are often poised to avoid or downplay its public acknowledgment. The posture by both tribunal and state of non-negotiable rectitude has obscured the important issue of how international law actually operates in the context of political negotiations between tribunals and states.”Footnote 2
Writing from the perspective of an international (criminal) lawyer (who focuses more on questions of individual criminal responsibility for the various crimes within the jurisdictions of the ad hoc tribunals and related procedural matters), I can at the outset state that books like Peskin's should be required reading for any serious international lawyer. No individual case before the various international criminal tribunals came about in a vacuum; and the genesis of the particular case cannot be separated from the institutional, procedural and, indeed, political context, including the oft forgotten and neglected behind-the-scenes history of state cooperation. But this book is also more than a “contextualizing” text aimed to sensitize “court-centred” lawyers; it is rather a specialist text in the field of international law and politics.
Peskin's critique of the body of literature on the ad hoc tribunals informed his methodology. He not only critically reviewed some of the most important texts on the subject, but also adds new perspectives and data to the body of knowledge with his well documented case studies. Quite clearly, one of his aims was to complete the blanks and connect the dots in order to provide the reader with a more complete (and nuanced) picture of the realities of international criminal justice in action. His interviews with prominent tribunal role players (past and present) provide for more than anecdotal reading. Indeed, the interviews with key figures like chief prosecutors and diplomats who were privy to some of the most dramatic and sensitive aspects of the establishment of the two tribunals, certainly underscore the “virtual” nature of international criminal justice (at least in the context of the two tribunals). The “trials of cooperation” (the basic theme of the book) serve as a constant reminder of the fact that the different role players, but especially the chief prosecutor, always had to keep in mind that the trials before the tribunals were not comparable to ordinary criminal processes at national level. These were “virtual” trials that could only become real with the help of considerable behind the scenes political and strategic manoeuvring. This fact is highlighted throughout the text with reference to some dramatic events, including the efforts to bring key accused persons like Slobodan Milosevic to trial.Footnote 3
The critical role of the chief prosecutor is one of the central themes in Peskin's book. One is left with the impression that, apart from reviewing evidence and drafting indictments, the chief prosecutors of the two tribunals were each first and foremost busy strategizing in order to obtain the necessary cooperation from states. These endeavours were complicated by the tension and conflict between national interests and the interests (and demands) of the “international community” (basically a handful of powerful players including the United States, Russia and the European Union). Peskin describes and analyses this with reference to the complexities inherent in the post-conflict societies of the Balkans and Rwanda. His knowledge and grasp of the different political undercurrents in these societies is impressive. Especially in the case of the former Yugoslavia, one can see how the intra-state conflict (and difference in world view and perspective) between entities like Serbia and Croatia (also during different post-conflict phases) impacted on their (un)willingness to cooperate with the ICTY.
The tensions between national and international expectations and perspectives on international justice are not limited to the political, or the institutional. Some of the tensions highlighted by Peskin stem from different perspectives on “justice” as an abstract concept. This is perhaps best illustrated by Rwanda's post-conflict reaction to the question of the penal jurisdiction of an international criminal tribunal, and in particular the question of the death penalty. Any debate about how to end the “culture of impunity” that ignores matters like those pointed out by Peskin, would be doing so at a peril. This also underscores the value of Peskin's book from a transitional justice perspective.
This book should be recommended for the above reasons, but also for its prognostic value. The future of international criminal tribunals (not least of all the ICC) still depends on effective cooperation between states (horizontally) and between these institutions and states (vertically). Peskin's text provides many lessons in this regard.
The book is compelling and well researched. The ample references make the book also a useful source from a research perspective. The maps and timelines (pages xviii to xxi) are very helpful to place particular events and personalities in their proper context. One small criticism in this regard relates to the references to, for example, the “Goldstone Court” or the “Del Ponte Court” in order to link certain periods to the names of the relevant chief prosecutors. I understand that this is shorthand for the particular periods, but perhaps it would be better not to create the impression that the chief prosecutors were the “heads” of the tribunals. There are in fact presidents (who are judges) of the tribunals, as stipulated by the relevant statutes of the ICTY and ICTR.
