Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-7pwfn Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-17T01:55:08.692Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Normality-based analysis of multiscale velocity gradients and energy transfer in direct and large-eddy simulations of isotropic turbulence

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  23 October 2025

Rahul Arun*
Affiliation:
Graduate Aerospace Laboratories, California Institute of Technology, Pasadena, CA 91125, USA
Mostafa Kamal
Affiliation:
Department of Mechanical and Aerospace Engineering, University of California, Irvine, CA 92697, USA
Tim Colonius
Affiliation:
Department of Mechanical and Civil Engineering, California Institute of Technology, Pasadena, CA 91125, USA
Perry L. Johnson
Affiliation:
Department of Mechanical and Aerospace Engineering, University of California, Irvine, CA 92697, USA
*
Corresponding author: Rahul Arun, rarun@caltech.edu

Abstract

Symmetry-based analyses of multiscale velocity gradients highlight that strain self-amplification (SS) and vortex stretching (VS) drive forward energy transfer in turbulent flows. By contrast, a strain–vorticity covariance mechanism produces backscatter that contributes to the bottleneck effect in the subinertial range of the energy cascade. We extend these analyses by using a normality-based decomposition of filtered velocity gradients in forced isotropic turbulence to distinguish contributions from normal straining, pure shearing and rigid rotation at a given scale. Our analysis of direct numerical simulation (DNS) data illuminates the importance of shear layers in the inertial range and (especially) the subinertial range of the cascade. Shear layers contribute significantly to SS and VS and play a dominant role in the backscatter mechanism responsible for the bottleneck effect. Our concurrent analysis of large-eddy simulation (LES) data characterizes how different closure models affect the flow structure and energy transfer throughout the resolved scales. We thoroughly demonstrate that the multiscale flow features produced by a mixed model closely resemble those in a filtered DNS, whereas the features produced by an eddy viscosity model resemble those in an unfiltered DNS at a lower Reynolds number. This analysis helps explain how small-scale shear layers, whose imprint is mitigated upon filtering, amplify the artificial bottleneck effect produced by the eddy viscosity model in the inertial range of the cascade. Altogether, the present results provide a refined interpretation of the flow structures and mechanisms underlying the energy cascade and insight for designing and evaluating LES closure models.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2025. Published by Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Figure 1.(a) Symmetry-based scale-local and scale-non-local contributions to interscale energy transfer in forced isotropic turbulence. The symbols represent direct numerical simulation (DNS) datasets at Taylor-scale Reynolds numbers of ${\textit{Re}}_\lambda \approx 315$ (DNS315) and ${\textit{Re}}_\lambda \approx 400$ (DNS400) and the curves represent the ${\textit{Re}}_\lambda \approx 400$ results of Johnson (2020, 2021). The shaded region captures the bottom of the inertial range for DNS400. (b) Energy spectra for the unfiltered and filtered velocity fields in DNS400 as well as LES cases that employ eddy viscosity (Vis400) and mixed (Mix400) models at ${\textit{Re}}_\lambda \approx 400$. The filtered DNS and LES cases employ a filter width of $2\ell /\eta = 48$. The dotted line represents the inertial range scaling, $E(k) = 1.6 \langle \mathit{\varPhi } \rangle ^{2/3} k^{-5/3}$, and the inset depicts a linear–log plot of the compensated energy spectra. Technical details of the simulations are described in § 3.

Figure 1

Table 1.Primary simulations considered in the present study. The DNS cases employ $N_x^3 = 1024^3$ collocation points and are dealiased using the $2\sqrt {2}/3$ truncation rule with phase-shifting (Patterson & Orszag 1971) such that $k_{\textit{max}} = N_x\sqrt {2}/3$. The LES cases employ $N_x^3 = 128^3$ collocation points and filter widths of $2\ell _{\textit{LES}}/\eta = 48$. They are dealiased using the $2/3$ truncation rule such that $k_{\textit{max}} = N_x/3$. Additional cases, including random velocity gradients, DNS cases at lower Reynolds numbers and LES cases with different filter widths are described and analysed in Appendix B.

Figure 2

Figure 2.Partitioning of filtered velocity gradients for the DNS cases, where shearing is represented using $S_{\ell ,\gamma }^2 = {\varOmega }_{\ell ,\gamma }^2 = ({1}/{2})A_{\ell ,\gamma }^2$. The horizontal dashed lines represent the unfiltered partitioning in the high-${\textit{Re}}_\lambda$ limit, the vertical dotted line represents the typical thickness of small-scale shear layers, $\delta _\gamma = 9\eta$, and the shaded region approximates the inertial range for DNS400 as $50 \leq 2\ell /\eta \leq 150$.

Figure 3

Figure 3.(a) Partitioning of filtered velocity gradients for the LES cases. The solid curves represent the filtered DNS400 partitioning and the horizontal dashed lines represent the unfiltered partitioning in the high-${\textit{Re}}_\lambda$ limit. The lower limit of the filter width axis represents the LES filter width, $2\ell _{\textit{LES}}/\eta = 48$, and the shaded region approximates the inertial range. (b) Partitioning for Vis400 replotted as a function of $2\ell _*/\eta _*$, where $\ell _* = \sqrt {\ell ^2 - \ell _{\textit{LES}}^2}$ is the complementary filter width and $\eta _* \approx 15 \eta$ is an effective Kolmogorov scale. The solid curves represent the partitioning produced by a DNS at ${\textit{Re}}_\lambda \approx 61$, which has a Kolmogorov scale of approximately $\eta _*$. The vertical dotted line represents the typical thickness of small-scale shear layers, $\delta _\gamma = 9\eta$.

Figure 4

Figure 4.Vortical flow structures associated with rigid rotation and shear vorticity for an unfiltered ($\ell = 0$) DNS at ${\textit{Re}}_\lambda \approx 61$ (a,b), DNS400 filtered at $2\ell /\eta = 48$ (c,d) and Vis400 (e,f) and Mix400 (g,h) at the LES filter width, $2\ell _{\textit{LES}}/\eta = 48$. The greyscale visualizations depict the strengths of rigid rotation, $\omega _{\ell ,\varphi }^2$, and shear vorticity, $\omega_{\ell,\gamma}^2$, normalized by the spatially averaged vorticity strength, $\langle \omega _\ell ^2 \rangle$, and the isosurfaces represent $\omega _{\ell ,\varphi }^2 / \langle \omega _\ell ^2 \rangle = 2$ (red) and $\omega _{\ell ,\gamma }^2 / \langle \omega _\ell ^2 \rangle = 2$ (blue).

Figure 5

Figure 5.Normality-based contributions to interscale energy transfer for the DNS cases. The contributions represent multiscale SS (a), VS (b), strain–vorticity covariance (c) and aggregates across these three mechanisms (d). The vertical dotted lines represent the typical thickness of small-scale shear layers, $\delta _\gamma = 9\eta$, and the shaded regions capture the bottom of the inertial range for DNS400.

Figure 6

Figure 6.Normality-based contributions (as defined in § 2) to the cascade rates associated with scale-local SS (a) and VS (b) and scale-non-local SS (c) and VS (d). The vertical dotted lines represent the typical thickness of small-scale shear layers, $\delta _\gamma = 9\eta$, and the shaded regions capture the bottom of the inertial range for DNS400.

Figure 7

Table 2.Normality-based contributions to SS and VS for the unfiltered DNS cases. The contributions to SS and VS are normalized by $\langle - {S}^{}_{\textit{ij}}{S}^{}_{\textit{ik}}{S}^{}_{\textit{jk}} \rangle$ and $\langle - {S}^{}_{\textit{ij}}{{\varOmega }}^{}_{\textit{ik}}{{\varOmega }}^{}_{\textit{jk}} \rangle$, respectively, such that they sum to unity for each mechanism.

Figure 8

Figure 7.(a,c) Resolved symmetry-based scale-local and scale-non-local cascade rates for Mix400 (a) and Vis400 (c) overlaid on curves that represent the DNS results of Johnson (2020, 2021) in the same style as figure 1(a). (b,d) Normality-based contributions to $\tilde {{\varPi }}^{\ell ,c}$ for Mix400 (b) and Vis400 (d). Panels (e) and (f) replot the Vis400 results from panels (c) and (d), respectively, normalized by $\langle \tilde {{\varPi }}^\ell \rangle$ and as a function of $2\ell _*/\eta _*$, where $\eta _* \approx 15\eta$. The curves (e,f) represent a DNS at ${\textit{Re}}_\lambda \approx 61$, which has a Kolmogorov scale of approximately $\eta _*$. The shaded regions approximate the inertial range and the vertical dotted lines represent $\delta _\gamma = 9\eta$.

Figure 9

Figure 8.Resolved normality-based cascade rates for Vis400, plotted in the same style as figure 7(e,f).

Figure 10

Figure 9.(a) Velocity gradient partitioning for Burgers vortex layers at ${\textit{Re}}_U = 10^2$ (solid), ${\textit{Re}}_U = 10^4$ (dashed) and ${\textit{Re}}_U = 10^6$ (dotted). (b) Velocity gradient partitioning for the Burgers vortex tube in the limit of ${\textit{Re}}_{\mathit{\varGamma }} \to \infty$. (c) Normality-based contributions to SS and VS for the Burgers vortex tube from (b). The vertical dotted lines (b,c) represent the vortex boundary as identified by $Q = 0$ and ${\varDelta}= 0$, where $Q$ is the second invariant of the VGT and ${\varDelta }$ is the discriminant of the VGT.

Figure 11

Figure 10.(a) Partitioning of filtered velocity gradients for DNS cases at various Reynolds numbers. The symbols represent averages over all snapshots and the shading represents ranges for single-snapshot averages. In all panels, the solid curves represent the averaged partitioning at ${\textit{Re}}_\lambda \approx 400$, the horizontal dashed lines represent the unfiltered partitioning in the high-${\textit{Re}}_\lambda$ limit, and the vertical dotted lines represent the typical thickness of small-scale shear layers, $\delta _\gamma = 9\eta$.

Figure 12

Table 3.Partitioning statistics produced by random velocity gradients and various DNS and LES cases. Each LES case represents a separate simulation where $\ell = \ell _{\textit{LES}}$ represents the LES filter width.