The historical literature on African American education immediately following the Civil War concentrates on the efforts of newly freed slaves, philanthropists, and federal agencies, most notably the Freedmen's Bureau, to establish and support schools and school systems. The withdrawal of the Bureau from the South has been seen as a definitive turning point, after which southern whites quickly reasserted control, establishing the highly unequal Jim Crow education systems that would hold sway well into the following century. Hilary Green's excellent new work, Educational Reconstruction: African American Schools in the Urban South, 1865–1890, pushes back against this narrative of immediate decline, arguing that it is the product of a “backward gaze” that reads the postwar years through the lens of what followed instead of as a distinct period in its own right (6). Rather than marking an abrupt dashing of African American hopes, Green finds that the withdrawal of the Freedmen's Bureau and the closure of the Freedmen's Schools began a complicated and contested period in which African Americans continued their struggle for education within the emerging state-funded public school systems of the South. This effort necessitated the forging of new alliances and coalitions, and African American communities successfully found new strategies and built networks that included state agencies, local school boards, and political leaders, both white and black. Although white supremacy eventually reasserted itself, Green insists that African American efforts in the two and a half decades after the close of the Freedmen's Schools bore fruit as they “successfully embedded African American education as a state right of citizenship, increased educational access for future generations of African American children, and established educators as middle class leaders essential for turn-of-the-century activism” (9). By the time white supremacist governments reclaimed the South, African Americans had gained a space within the public schools and constructed an educational edifice to withstand the coming trials.
In order to tell the story of this overlooked but important era, Green divides her text into eight chapters that alternate between the contrasting experiences of African American educational activism in Richmond, Virginia; and Mobile, Alabama. The choice of these urban centers is purposeful, as both were social and economic hubs with traditions of common schooling stretching back to the antebellum period. In focusing on the educational experiences of African Americans in major cities, Green adds to the growing literature on urban African Americans in the South from authors like Michael Fitzgerald and Howard Rabinowitz.Footnote 1 Green's educational analysis adds to these previous authors’ studies of labor and politics in postwar southern cities, and shows how education was closely intertwined with these issues.
In both cities, African Americans in the postwar period initially worked to ensure access to education by supporting the Freedmen's Schools along with independent schools created and maintained by African Americans themselves. Yet, as Virginia and Alabama each moved toward readmission into the Union and the role of the Freedmen's Bureau lessened, African Americans made sure that their visions of educational opportunity were not discarded. Significantly, they pushed for the creation of state-funded public school systems, open to all, as part of the new state constitutions, thus changing African American education “from a marginalized institution into a state right of citizenship” (16). This process of developing and protecting African American education did not happen alone, however, and Green does an excellent job in revealing how networks and alliances formed, changed, and dissolved throughout the period. In Richmond, this process was marked by relative cooperation between the Richmond School Board, the African American community, state officials, and northern benevolent societies. These partnerships were fruitful, resulting in an environment that even gave rise to the historic, if brief, appointment of two African Americans, Capt. Robert A. Paul and Richard Forrester, to the Richmond School Board during the height of the Readjuster Party in the early 1880s. In Mobile, on the other hand, divisions between Creoles of color and African Americans, in addition to a more powerful and protracted white resistance, meant that progress occurred more slowly. Allies were few and far between, and the African American community was often forced to fight to maintain even a basic level of educational access. In both instances, however, Green's asserts that these communities were successful in laying an enduring foundation for African American education.
Some of Green's most significant arguments concern the unappreciated connections between the fight for African American public schools, broader communal activism, and the growth of African American higher education. Green contextualizes the growth of African American higher education as part of a larger conversation about who was, and who could be, qualified to fulfill the role of teacher in the newly emerging African American public schools. Fighting against the entrenched prejudices of their opponents, and in some instances those of their supposed allies who doubted the ability of newly freed slaves to become effective educators, African Americans insisted on the development of normal institutes and colleges as a means of “giving the community greater control over the schools and the information disseminated to their children” (68). Chapters 3 and 4 of Educational Reconstruction focus on two of these institutions, Emerson Normal in Mobile and Richmond Colored Normal. Not only did these schools supply highly trained African American teachers for the public schools, they also produced a cadre of middle-class leaders who formed the backbone of political movements outside the doors of their classrooms. African American teachers “participated in teacher training, literary societies, and racial uplift organizations,” extending their work outward into the community (87). The use of the schoolhouse as a platform for broader social involvement was particularly true for African American women, who formed a majority of the African American teaching force throughout the South. Green does not dedicate much time here to the connections among gender, activism, and education: engagement with recent scholarship from authors like Karen Johnson and Sonya Ramsey on this topic would have added even more to her analysis of African American teacher-activists.Footnote 2 Still, Green's main arguments, that efforts to create and sustain African American public schools were a catalyst for the development of higher education and a starting point for wider political action, come across clearly and convincingly.
The narrative of Educational Reconstruction ends in 1890 with the failure of the Blair education bill, which proposed the creation of a uniform national system for public education funded through the federal government. For Green, the defeat of this legislation marks the “real closure of the post-emancipation moment” for African American education (186). As African Americans rightly surmised at the time, federal control would have solidified the gains they had achieved since emancipation by providing much needed funding and insulating the schools from the reactionary political forces then gaining power throughout the South. The controversy surrounding the bill and its eventual failure necessitated a search for alternative strategies and philosophies. The dramatic ascent of Booker T. Washington with his more rural and vocational vision for African American education challenged and supplanted the more urban and liberal arts based tradition of early reformers like those in Richmond and Mobile. However, Green shows that although largely subsumed by later developments, the activism of the immediate postwar period was critical to the development of African American education in the South, that this period lasted longer than has been assumed, and that it was marked by real and substantive victories that set the groundwork for a continuing struggle for access and equity.
