Hawraa Al-Hassan's Women, Writing and the Iraqi Baʿthist State explores the connections between culture, ideology, and the state through the examination of secular and religious texts produced by both the regime and its opponents during the period of Baʿthist rule in Iraq (1968–2003). The focus of Al-Hassan's discussion is the status and role of women in Iraqi society in the public sphere and at home. Its underlying assumption is that literature does not exist in a void. Rather, it is indicative of other events and processes, or, in Al-Hassan's words: “Literary texts do not exist in isolation from other texts and discourses and are inextricably tied to the material practices that bring them into being” (p. 204). The author's meticulous analysis of texts allows her to break dichotomies regarding literary genre and religion. That is to say, an Islamic text does not necessarily resist the authoritarian regime and a secular one does not necessarily collaborate with it (p. 215).
The book is clearly written, and provides a thorough, in-depth analysis of Iraqi fiction, ranging from propagandistic novels by Saddam Hussein to novels by Shiʿi women writers such as Bint al-Huda, May al-Husayni, Khawla al-Qazwini and ʿAlyaʾ al-Ansari, and then more personal writings, mainly by Dunya Mikhail, Haifa Zangana and Nuha al-Radi. Upon first glance, it might seem odd to readers to discuss Saddam Hussein's openly propagandistic texts in the same book with Shiʿi women writers, but the author convincingly shows the connection between the utopian vision set by the state as expressed in Saddam's works and the challenge to this utopia posed by Shiʿi women writers.
According to Al-Hassan, the reason for choosing these specific political or ideological texts was the fact that they “have been marginalised and often completely excluded from the scope of critical enquiry” (pp. 1, 74). Hence, the book's importance lies in the treatment of texts, some of which have received little scholarly attention, if at all, whether written by well- or less-known writers, including some whose artistic quality is relatively poor. The literary texts are discussed side-by-side with developments and changes in women's roles in Iraqi society and especially with respect to their levels of literacy. Through a close reading of the chosen corpus, the book addresses questions of canonical and non-canonical texts and analyzes them in a way which can enrich the existing knowledge on cultural production in this era. One of the book's unique strengths is its treatment of books’ paratextual aspects, which, more often than not, remain outside the scope of literary research; this includes titles, dedications, prefaces, covers, publishers’ notes and blurbs. Furthermore, the author draws significant comparisons between various editions of the novels and refers to the state's considerations regarding the dissemination of propagandistic books during the Iran–Iraq War according to political needs.
In her Introduction, the author discusses the literary, anthropological, and historical theories on which she will later base her findings. She also explains how the Iraqi novel was used as a space for the manifestation of nationalism, and how the Baʿth regime was aware of “the power of the word as a weapon to be resorted to at times of crisis” (p. 10). Al-Hassan sets the definition of “resistance” as a counter-discourse to the state's homogenized utopian discourse, and discusses major questions relating to gender, nationalism, culture and resistance. The first chapter explores the connections between the Iran–Iraq War's duration, its (un)achieved goals, and the length and distribution of propagandistic novels, focusing on their metaphors and symbols. The discussion includes state-sponsored literary criticism, (self-)censorship and the contradiction between the Baʿth Party's attempt to be perceived as progressive toward women and the way they were treated in real life.
In the second chapter, Al-Hassan delves into Saddam's propagandistic novels as a case study, with an extensive discussion of the novels’ messages and conflicts. The third chapter is dedicated to Shiʿi women writers and the pragmatic educational aims of their works, as well as their literary techniques and symbolism. Al-Hassan shows how conservative pan-Shiʿa female writing was subversive, and hence posed a threat to the declared Baʿthist narrative of homogenous nationalist Iraqi identity. She demonstrates that the novels constituted a literature of resistance and explains why they remained non-canonical. The fourth chapter deals with works of a more personal, poetic, and reflective nature by writers of dual identity or who belong to a minority; thus, “the very existence of hybrid ethnic or racial identities or religious ‘others’ had the potential to be subversive in its challenge to the homogenisation of nationalist discourses” (p. 195). These works acted as a type of resistance literature also by the mere fact that they focused on the self rather than on the nation, at a time of war and political oppression, due to the Iraqi regime and subsequently by the American invasion of Iraq. Al-Hassan concludes that one of the study's results is that Baʿthist attitudes towards women can be used to better understand other minority discourses in Iraq as well (pp. 214–15). Each chapter ends with concluding remarks and detailed endnotes. The book as a whole ends with a conclusion and two appendices that include summaries of the novels analyzed in the study and images of some of their covers, a bibliographical list and an index.
Overall, the author's research is well presented and well-documented. However, a discussion of war literature in other countries, if only in outline, would have contributed to the book's introduction, by placing Iraqi war literature within a broader context. Additionally, some statements need further references, as when, for example, the author asserts that “Many feminist thinkers have explained the encroachment of men into the affairs and space of women as a ‘compensating mechanism’ to make up for the resentment and impotence felt by men vis-à-vis authoritarian power” (p. 53). A reference would have made the argument more solid, especially in a work dedicated to the status of women as writers and as literary characters.
The book also has a structural shortcoming, in my view: its chapters are divided into subchapters, each of which contains a detailed discussion and analysis of a specific novel or two. A thematic and/or stylistic division, rather than a division by novel, would have been more useful for most readers. With such a proposed division, the connections between the different novels would have been clearer and the discussions would have included aspects of all the novels of the same genre, or most of them, and not only one or two novels at a time. Such interconnections could include recurring themes or artistic techniques in the novels, for instance: exile and visa issues which are prominent components of the (semi-)autobiographical works in the last part of the book, metaphors taken from the animal world, the sanctions on Iraq, anti-American criticism, the issue of rural life vs. city life, and so forth.
Despite these minor drawbacks, Al-Hassan's book constitutes an important contribution to the study of cultural production in Baʿthist Iraq, thanks in particular to its focus on works that are partly under-researched and to its consideration of paratextual aspects. It provides numerous examples from the novels and exemplifies a rich academic background, theoretical as well as practical. As such, the in-depth analysis provided by the study should be useful for those studying Iraqi literature, especially advanced students, and anyone interested in the connections between religion, state, and women in literature. The book should also be useful for research on sectarianism and gender, since much can be learned from the works by women writers which it explores. The proximity of Saddam's propagandistic works and the works by Shiʿi women writers in this book, along with the conflicts they raise, mirror the power struggle between the Baʿthist state and various sections in it, as well as religious-secular polemics, and the role and state of women in wartime.
