Gilberto Freyre (1900–87) needs no introduction here. The most influential intellectual of twentieth-century Brazil, he pioneered any number of approaches to the country, particularly the relationship of the past to modern Brazilian society. For most Brazilianists, he is an inevitable intellectual precursor; we debate him, we attack him, we dismiss him, but only the foolish ignore him. The authors' intent here is both a full-scale intellectual study of Freyre for the more scholarly world and an introduction to Freyre for the Anglophone intellectual laity. It is a very successful endeavour. Well written, well paced and well prepared, it reminds one of a cultivated conversation demonstrating the intriguing origins and scope of Freyre's learning and his enduring relevance to Brazil and to the wider world.
The authors combine the close study of Freyre's many texts, his own autobiographical works, the most accessible of his correspondence, his accumulated interviews and memoirs, and some of the authors' precursors among scholars and Brazilian writers. What is unexpected is the broad panoply of non-Brazilian writers and scholars the authors deploy to suggest Freyre's learning and affinities. In a method of citation that reminds one of no one so much as Freyre himself, the authors drop the names of the great writers, thinkers and scholars of the late nineteenth and twentieth centuries to make their points. Initially one might find this annoying, as one does in Freyre, as if the citation of great names is done to establish the credentials of the authors. However, particularly in the latter chapters where the authors make their conclusions regarding Freyre's place as a historian, a social theorist and a relevant contemporary public intellectual, this passes. The citations work as the authors intended, to indicate Freyre's debts, stature and affinities. The more scholarly among us may regret that the authors apparently were unable to study the archived correspondence in Recife. We may also note that, while they cite, the authors do not always engage the arguments or contributions of their predecessors. Finally, we may regret that, in support of key analyses, Pallares-Burke's critical, pioneering study of Freyre's youth is cited, rather than the primary sources she must have used. Overall, however, no scholar could doubt the intellectual seriousness, scholarly background or important contribution of this work.
The sympathy of the authors for Freyre is marked in the book, however much they note the arguments of Freyre's many critics. This sympathy is generally to our advantage. Instead of damning Freyre for his lapses from academic criteria he never accepted, they can appreciate him for what he attempted: an intuitive, impressionistic, highly personalised understanding underpinned by a pastiche of varied disciplines and literary references, with an explicit disdain for disciplinary boundaries or social-scientific rigor. Nonetheless, some of us may wonder at times if the authors' sympathy goes too far. Particularly in his foundational work in the 1920s and 1930s, Freyre's attitude towards modernismo and modernity was not only ambivalent, it was frankly reactionary. The authors include Freyre's celebration of an oppressive social hierarchy and his embrace of a traditional political authoritarianism as natural to Brazil. They help explain his early support for the 1964 military coup. While the authors demonstrate the ambiguity and complexity of Freyre's views, and the way in which some changed over time, the clarity and implications of these earlier positions are embedded in his classics and demand debate. Moreover, the true significance of Freyre's historical context, particularly the revolution of 1930, while noted here, might have been more profitably discussed in terms of Freyre's highly personalised sense of the national past. The relationship between the fall of the old regime, with which Freyre had direct personal links, his consequent 1930 exile, and his impression of salient aspects of the explicitly modernising, populist trends he associated with 1930, is clarifying. Casa grande e senzala (1933) and Sobrados e mucambos (1936) are not only the cumulation of his learned meditation abroad and at home; they also comprise testimony to a fatal blow to the world of his real and imagined past. If, as the authors demonstrate, Freyre came to use his understanding of the past to map out ways to form the future, he did so only decades later. When he wrote his classics, his internal gaze rested upon the dust, damage and decline of the world he had created for himself. Particularly in Sobrados e mucambos, there is a clear dislike of the urban, the Jew, the modern, the mulatto, and the professional middle class – all inimical to a seigneurial, plantation civilisation he created and whose decline he lamented. Moreover, as the authors show, his concern with foreign models, whether Left or Right, as potential pathogens for ‘his’ Brazil was an abiding fear. While he himself boldly adapted such things as he saw fit, he dreaded their embrace by others as potentially deracinating.
The contribution of this study is clear. Serious Brazilian intellectual history and explication, thriving in Brazil itself, remain embarrassingly neglected in the Anglophone world. The authors have brought Freyre to the English reader, with all of his enormous appetite for cultural, social and historical comparisons. Importantly, they have done so at the level at which he wrote, in which references to the advancing social sciences were as natural as the citation of novelists, critics and historians. Furthermore, the contribution made is not to the laity alone. As graduate students and as mature scholars, many of us read and return to Freyre because we must; however, that does not always mean that we understand his intentions, his ambitions or all of his achievements. In accompanying the authors, one suspects many of us will learn a great deal about Freyre that we did not know (for instance, his debt to Spencer and its relationship to his embrace of ambivalence as an intellectual method). Moreover, we may learn how much we have missed in the work itself. The authors help us to read Freyre afresh – for example, his preoccupation with material culture and his fastening upon the ‘significant detail’ are matters one can sense without understanding. Many of us have enjoyed the nearly tactile impressions one finds in Freyre, but have not thought about them as a careful artifice, the ‘intimate history’ Freyre knew might help in the recovery of the past. For the book's examination of this, and for much more, the reader will be grateful.
