Christin Essin's Stage Designers in Early Twentieth-Century America: Artists, Activists, Cultural Critics proves that we have only just begun reclaiming the value of spectacle from Aristotle's banishment. The intent of this book is to broaden our understanding of famous designers by recontextualizing their work both inside and outside the theatre. Not only does Essin, a designer turned historian, shed new light on the designers themselves, but via her methodology she also opens up new avenues for design analysis of both historical and contemporary designs/designers. Essin states it quite clearly when she says, “My goal is to suggest an alternate analytical approach, a path toward a cultural history of design that supplements existing scholarship in the field of theatre studies and introduces theatre design as a mode of authorship, cultural criticism, activism, and entrepreneurship to other disciplines in cultural studies” (5–6).
Essin's approach is to look at design as part of American cultural history, so she has broken up her chapters and her examinations thematically, not chronologically. Stage Designers begins with an introduction explaining her approach, followed by the briefest of overviews for those not familiar with the history and philosophy of New Stagecraft. Essin implies that she intends her book to join in conversation with books focusing on the aesthetics and techniques of design, such as Orville Larson's Scene Design in the American Theatre from 1915 to 1960 (U of Arkansas P, 1989), rather than to update or replace them. Limiting her inquiry to the period from 1912 to 1964 (4), Essin combines a wealth of historical research with clear and precise visual analysis as she charts new methods to contextualize famous designs, as well as designers whom previous studies have erased. However, it is interesting that a text focused primarily on the visual uses photographs so sparingly. Although her representative images were always perfectly calibrated to support and clarify the textual arguments, for newer scholars I would suggest using a companion text like Larson's to supplement the range of images included in Essin's book.
Essin titles her chapters according to different roles that designers also assume; she offers new terminology, as well, to label her design analysis. Chapter 1, “The Designer as Author,” looks at what Essin calls “scenographic authorship” (19) to chart the discourse that established New Stagecraft, revealing conflicting attitudes toward design, and recovering authorship that has been dismissed. I was especially moved by Essin's recovery of Aline Bernstein as a significant female voice in early design history. This was a woman who found ways to make an end-run around the gender bias in two male-dominated fields: theatre design and publishing.
While most of Essin's chapters argue that designers have been a driving force in a cultural turn, in Chapter 2, “The Designer as Cultural Critic,” she looks at how designers comment on already established cultural phenomena through the practice of “scenographic criticism” (52). While this is not a totally new idea, Essin adds to the argument by examining the way different stage settings have commented on modernization, social inequality, and suburban isolation. “Scenographic criticism” and “scenographic activism” (95) might be a short step apart, but in her third chapter, “The Designer as Activist,” Essin investigates intentional ways that designers have applied their various talents in order to promote social change. Her claim that several designers proved their passion for specific causes is supported by her examination of designs of various publicity posters, and of photographs of skilled laborers during the Depression. She also narrates how Bernstein became the first woman admitted to the labor union United Scenic Artists of America (USAA) as a designer.
One of Essin's strongest chapters demonstrating the influence of theatrical designers on cultural history is her fourth, “The Designer as Entrepreneur,” in which she examines the concept of “scenographic entrepreneurship” (132). Joseph Urban and Norman Bel Geddes, Essin argues, might have been dismissed by theatre critics for selling out, but in actuality, they were applying their talents to making design and aesthetics a part of our everyday lives. These designers demonstrated to industry that adding beauty to functionality would increase sales.
Sadly, Essin's strongest chapter is followed by her weakest. In “The Designer as Global Cartographer,” Essin claims that “scenographic cartography” (170) was a part of shaping the public's understanding of the world. I felt that Essin's examples here, unlike those in previous chapters, were not enough to establish that the designers in question either followed or started a cultural trend; yet this does not negate Essin's line of investigation. I posit that this chapter, like many of the others in the book, might provide the starting point for future work. All five forms of scenographic analysis Essin discusses have cleared new paths for the scrutiny and historicization of the visual aspects of theatre. In this regard, Stage Designers in Early Twentieth-Century America will be valuable to both scholars and practitioners not only as a history, but also as a reminder to reexamine history itself.
Essin combines rigorous scholarship with clear and precise visual analysis delivered via an approachable writing style. Western theatre has been obsessed with textual analysis for a very long time; Essin proves that cultural history and studies can be applied to—and found through—an examination of the visual aspects of theatre, not just its textual ones. Design is visual communication, and it has a lot to say.
