No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 22 July 2005
Among the thousands of familiar television images and headlines that emanate from the Middle East, few mystify and bedevil Western publics more than the suicide bomber and the issue of “martyrdom.” What prompts a young man (or woman, increasingly) to don an explosives-laden jacket with the intent of killing innocent civilians or, perhaps, enemy combatants in a blaze of fire and rage? And what constitutes a “martyr” in the Islamic world? Joyce Davis ably contends with these questions in Martyrs: Innocence, Vengeance, and Despair in the Middle East, a book that is both accessible to the lay reader and sprinkled with important insights from the field for the specialist reader.
From the streets of a besieged Jenin (pp. 135–38) to the trail of the 11 September highjackers (chap. 5), Davis explores the motives, psychology, intellectual and political influence, and social background of such famous “martyrs” as Mohammed al-Dirrah, the twelve-year-old Palestinian boy whose martyrdom came unexpectedly in a hail of Israeli bullets (pp. 27–45); Izzidene al-Masri, the Sbarro Pizzeria bomber who killed dozens of innocent Israelis (pp. 121–35); the Christian female activist Loula Abboud, whose suicide attack on Israeli soldiers in 1985 shows that the tactic knows no religious boundaries (pp. 67–85); and the Iranian child soldier Hossein Fahmideh, whose “martyrdom operation” taking out an Iraqi tank is still celebrated in the war lore of the Islamic Republic of Iran (pp. 45–67).
Threaded throughout Davis's finely reported narrative is a basic theme, enunciated by several leading religious scholars: suicide bombings against innocents are anathema to Islamic principles. From the leading Mecca-based scholar Abdulaziz ibn Abdallah al-Sheikh to the top religious authority at al-Azhar, Mohamed Sayed Tantawi (pp. 111–13), Davis offers numerous quotes in support of this view. But she also points out the subtle distinctions, such as Tantawi's and several other scholars' view that suicide bombings against Israeli military targets represent a legitimate form of jihad, and the late Hamas leader Shaykh Ahmed Yassin's prevarication when asked about the justice of killing innocents in the service of his cause.
By laying out the various arguments and counterarguments, Davis skillfully portrays the vigorous debate over the issue of martyrdom, ultimately coming to this conclusion: “In the end, Muslims, Christians, and Jews can find common ground in this: Whatever their motives, their grievances, and their suffering, those who kill and maim the innocent are not what Islam praises as holy warriors. They are not shuhada. They are not martyrs” (p. 202).
While the debate about martyrdom plays a central role in the book, the real strength of Davis's work is her field reportage, bringing alive the subject with up-close interviews that explore the pain, loss, and contradictions surrounding the world of the suicide bomber/martyr. In the best tradition of journalism, she shatters commonly held stereotypes through skillful interviews. For example, her interview with Um Iyad, the mother of Izzidene al-Masri, the Sbarro Pizzeria suicide bomber, contradicts the commonly held view (promoted by both opponents and proponents of suicide bombings) that the mothers of martyrs feel great joy in their children's work. “What can I tell you?” Um Iyad told Davis. “I have to say it was not a good thing that he did. There were many innocents there. So many children. We don't support it when the Israelis kill our people, so we can't support when their innocent people are killed” (p. 127). Later, when asked what she would have done if she had known beforehand, Um Iyad responded, “I would never have allowed him to go. I would have tied him down somewhere. I would have locked the house up. I would have chained him to the bed” (p. 128). Um Iyad's honest reply counters the dozens of interviews aired incessantly on Palestinian TV or Hizbullah TV that depict the mothers of martyrs as joyful.
Davis's interview with the mother of Mohammed al-Dirrah also leaves a lasting impression (p. 39). Al-Dirrah is widely remembered as the cowering twelve-year-old boy caught in the crossfire of an Israeli–Palestinian gunfight, cringing in fear as his father tried to protect him, only to die after being hit by stray Israeli bullets. The al-Dirrah image, captured by a French television crew, powerfully depicted the tragic fate of young Palestinians in a war zone and infuriated the world. Local Palestinian militants depicted al-Dirrah as a hero and a martyr, though he was, in reality, just a frightened boy in the wrong place at the wrong time. Al-Dirrah's mother offered details of his life—he used hair gel and pretended to shave like his father, he loved popcorn, and he loved to grill tomatoes and onions over a charcoal fire—that in an odd way humanized him even more than those frightening images of the crossfire. In the crossfire, he was yet another child caught in a senseless war, an image we have regretfully become accustomed to. But in his likes and dislikes, his personal quirks, he became a more complete individual—not just a symbol, but a living, breathing young man whose life was cut tragically short.
In the end, what Davis manages to do is remind us of the human tragedy of young men and women who—for reasons of desperation, anger, frustration, hatred, nationalism, religious zeal, political resistance—take the drastic step of becoming human explosives. She manages to tell the story with empathy, but without apology. She correctly notes that moderate Muslims must increasingly take a stand against militants, but the facts on the ground—particularly in the case of Palestine—help fuel the militants' argument. While pointing out the struggle for the soul of Islam between the moderate majority and the militant minority, Davis also provides a unique, closer-to-the-ground view that is playing out every day in the Muslim world's war zones: the struggle for the soul of young men torn between militants and their mothers.