The most important thing to note about this collection is that it contains a major article on Francis Bacon and his ‘method’ by Sophie Weeks, under the unassuming title ‘The role of mechanics in Francis Bacon's Great Instauration’. This seems to me the most interesting and accomplished piece on Bacon that I have read in years, and it deserves to be widely noticed. By ‘mechanics’, Weeks means here artifice in general, and her quite lengthy essay attempts to restructure our understanding of Bacon's experientia literata, associated with the famous tables of presence, absence and so on, and its relation to his new ‘organon’, the means to the ‘interpretation of nature’ properly speaking. The result is a wonderfully persuasive and strongly argued account of a Bacon who was more of a true natural magician than many of us had fully appreciated.
The collection as a whole relates to a conference held in 2006. As such works often are, it is uneven in quality. Besides Weeks's outstanding piece, some other contributions are worthy of note, but this is certainly not a major contribution to Bacon studies. It comes in two physical volumes, at a price no one will be willing to pay, as Intersections: Yearbook for Early Modern Studies 11 (2008), and its title as a book, Philosophies of Technology, is certainly misleading, as Claus Zittel acknowledges in his introduction. The subtitle is closer to the mark: the overall theme is the relationship between technics and natural philosophy in early modern Europe, and Bacon is a frequent focus of attention. The essays in the book are divided into four sections, with the fourth, ‘Bacon's legacy: the impact for the arts and sciences,’ being much the longest, consisting of seven chapters unified less by references to Bacon than by their temporal focus – chiefly on seventeenth- and eighteenth-century topics after Bacon's time, although one concerns sixteenth-century Spain. There is, indeed, a rather unclear basis for the distribution of the essays; a substantial piece by Jürgen Klein, ‘Francis Bacon's Scientia operativa’, appears in Part I, while Weeks's chapter is found in Part II, although they could well have appeared side by side.
Because of the miscellaneous character of this collection, it is not possible to identify in it any substantial unifying argument or perspective, although Zittel's introduction makes a game attempt. Perhaps it is significant that the book lists no fewer than four editors; its editorial quality is certainly uneven. All the chapters are in English, but some exhibit strange features: not only do modern French words and quotations very frequently contain typographical errors in accenting (missing accents, graves instead of acutes and so on), but in one of the chapters French sources such as Pascal are quoted in English but are cited from German translations that are themselves quoted (in German) in the notes. This seems odd.
Among the more noteworthy of the contributions is a nice essay by Moritz Epple on eighteenth-century hydrodynamics and its relation to engineering practice under absolutism – hydraulics at Versailles, Sanssouci and elsewhere; it is followed by a piece on similar themes by Thomas Brandstetter. A lengthy and useful chapter by Arianna Borrelli on the Dutch weatherglass and its relatives in the early seventeenth century is likely to become a standard reference on the subject, while Claus Zittel's chapter on ‘Descartes as bricoleur’, concentrating especially on his ‘Meteorology’, argues for a Baconian character to much of Descartes's physical explanation. Other chapters also offer worthwhile ideas on technics and the artisanal as aspects of early modern natural philosophy. But the collection lacks real coherence; it will mostly be remembered, I suspect, for containing the chapter by Weeks.
